Merryn's Blog

Here's why British house prices will fall

Many people are still under the impression that the only way house prices can possibly go is up. But this just isn't the case. Here's why.

An email comes from a reader. She has read an unusually rude criticism of MoneyWeek's bearish stance on house prices and wants us to answer a few questions.

First, she asks why traditional income ratios matter when interest rates are so low. After all, if she can get a mortgage at 2.39%, as she says she can, what difference does it make if she borrows four times her income?

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

She has a point - but not a lasting one. Why? Because interest rates won't stay low forever. If you borrow money today, you need to be sure that you can meet your monthly payments, not just at 2.39%, but at 5%, at 7% and perhaps at 10%.

We don't see rates going up immediately, partly because we expect the global deflationary scare to run a bit longer, and partly because Mervyn King has made it very clear that he will support the new government as much as he can by keeping rates low as they slash spending. But the Bank of England can't ignore its targets for ever. That means rates will have to go up in the end and then our reader's monthly mortgage payments will, too.

Advertisement - Article continues below

But it doesn't have to be interest rate rises that force the next fall in prices. Low interest rates have allowed the financially stressed to hang on to their homes. But the cuts in public spending, along with the trauma in most of our export markets, suggest that unemployment might soon see another rise. Can the over-leveraged hang on to their homes even when unemployed? We'll see.

And rising unemployment isn't the only thing likely to push up supply in the market. Consider the rise in capital gains tax (CGT) to the same levels as incomes. That means whopping great bills for second-home owners. A house bought for £100,000 in 1985 would now be worth £490,617, says the Nationwide. Sell it today and you'll pay CGT of £68,500. Sell it when the rate goes up to 40% and, assuming no allowances are made for inflation, you'll pay £152,200.

That suggests that you should get out now. Indeed, if you own a second home it also gives you a huge incentive to sell at below what would have been the market price. Sell the £490,617 house now for £450,000 and you'll still pay less tax than if you waited and sold after the tax rise.

But the tax rise also makes a big difference to the buy-to-let industry. Much of the benefit to being in buy-to-let has come not from net yields (which have all too often been negative) but from capital gains. Paying 40% on those capital gains, such as they might be, can only make the business less attractive. That will push up short-term supply in the market and push down long-term demand.

On the demand side, I'd also point to the fact that mortgages are still not that easy to come by. Mortgage approvals for house purchases came in at 48,901 in March. The long-run average is well over 90,000. At the same time, mortgage lenders are already warning about a looming £400bn funding gap as the Bank of England withdraws special support schemes introduced at the peak of the financial crisis.

Our reader also makes the point that inflation should be great for those with whopping great mortgages. It means that the price of your house goes up and the real value of your debt goes down. I addressed this last week so I'll just let you read here why this isn't necessarily so.

Finally she suggests that the housing market won't fall because the government just won't let it. The Bank of England won't raise rates enough to crash the housing market because "that would be madness." And anyway a crash would mean another recession which would mean falling tax revenues and make our national debt even harder to service. "So the UK has to have rising house prices to keep paying the country's debts and the government will make sure it happens."

Advertisement - Article continues below

This is touching stuff. So far, if there has been one big lesson from the financial crisis it has been this: no government can make sure of anything. The US couldn't stop the subprime crisis; Gordon Brown couldn't stop boom and bust; the Monetary Policy Committee can't stop inflation consistently rising above target; Greece can't make its people accept austerity; the Irish government couldn't stop house prices falling by 40% plus; Spain can't stop unemployment rising above 20%; and Germany can't stop the market slaying the euro.

So why on earth would anyone think that the UK government even the new one would be able to stop house prices falling?

None of this suggests our reader shouldn't buy her dream house if she finds it and can easily afford it (even with rates at say 10%). Just that if she does, she should be prepared to find that doing so doesn't exactly make her fortune.




Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
Buy to let

Come back buy-to-letters, all is forgiven

The government is winning its war against small private buy-to-let landlords. But who benefits?
23 Feb 2020

Rishi Sunak: the maharaja of the Yorkshire Dales

Rishi Sunak is taking the reins of the world’s fifth-largest economy at a crucial juncture. The unflashy but likeable youngster may be just the man fo…
20 Feb 2020
UK Economy

What is Britain’s new economic policy?

At the moment, Britain doesn’t seem to have an economic policy. But radical-seeming announcements and the surprise ousting of the chancellor portend m…
20 Feb 2020

Most Popular


Will coronavirus kill off the bull market?

It seems clear now the coronavirus will at some point go global. And when it does, will it bring down the stockmarket’s bull market? John Stepek looks…
27 Feb 2020

Gold, coronavirus, and the high cost of face masks in northern Italy

The price of gold is spiking – as it always does in a global panic. But this bull market predates the coronavirus epidemic, says Dominic Frisby, and w…
26 Feb 2020
Pension tax

Why it makes sense to scrap higher-rate pensions tax relief

The point of pensions tax relief is to keep you out of the means-tested benefits system. The current system is ridiculously generous, says Merryn Some…
24 Feb 2020

The rare earth metal that won't be a secret for long

SPONSORED CONTENT – You can’t keep a good thing hidden forever; now is the time to consider Pensana Rare Earths and the rare earth metals NdPr.
31 Jan 2020