Merryn's Blog

Germans need to wake up to the truth about who’s subsidising who in Europe

German taxpayers like to think they are financing the lifestyles of their feckless southern cousins. But the truth is rather different, says Merryn Somerset Webb.

Angela Merkel and Italian PM Matteo Renzi Germany is making a mint from Italian debt

The letters page of the FT is often pretty interesting. Today's is better than most. Several of the submissions are well worth a read (John Griffiths on the scandal of corporate remuneration, for example) but the most interesting comes from Olaf Dreyer of Hamburg.

We've written here before that one of the reasons we assume the eurozone will hold together for longer than seems possible today is that its main beneficiary is Germany. That's because the euro is a significantly weaker currency than a standalone German currency would be, something that has been a huge driver of Germany's recent export success.

Advertisement - Article continues below

But Dreyer notes that Germany has benefited in several other ways too.

The most obvious point to make is that "because Germany is perceived as safe, the interest rates on German bonds have reached historic lows". So servicing German debt (yes Germany does have debt to the tune of well over 70% of GDP) is "vastly cheaper than it used to be."

Less obvious is how much money Germany has made out of ECB bond-buying. In the first part of this, the ECB bought up €200bn of southern European sovereign bonds, around half of which came from Italy. There has been no default on these bonds and the average interest rate on them has been around 6%.

The result? "Via the detour of the ECB, the German taxpayer received €2bn from Italy alone."

You might think that the knowledge of these vast advantages resulting directly from the existence of very weak states in the eurozone would make the German taxpayer want to do all he can to keep those states happy perhaps meeting Greece half way on debt renegotiation.

You'd be wrong. The problem, says Dreyer, is that "the German press is mute on this point" any discussion of it is met with "disbelief".

When I met with Nobel Prize winning economist Robert Shiller earlier this week, he pointed out that all economics is about the stories people believe: as long as the Germans believe they are paying for Europe rather than being paid by Europe, compromises are going to be tough to find.




How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019

Boris Johnson’s big Brexit plan

The prime minister needs to get Brexit done, and get the economy growing – particularly for first-time Tory voters. Can he manage all that while negot…
15 Jun 2020
European stockmarkets

European assets bounce as the eurozone's economy turns upwards

Both the euro and European stocks have rallied strongly in the last few days.
12 Jun 2020
EU Economy

Margrethe Vestager: a symbol of all that’s wrong with the EU

Margrethe Vestager, the EU’s competition commissioner, wields enormous power over industry, and abuses it, says Matthew Lynn.
7 Jun 2020

Most Popular


House price crash: UK property prices are falling – so where next?

With UK property prices falling for the first time in eight years, are we about to see a house price crash? John Stepek looks at what’s behind the sli…
2 Jul 2020

How can markets hit new record highs when the economy is in such a mess?

Despite the world being in the midst of a global pandemic, America's Nasdaq stock index just hit an all-time high. And it's not the only index on a bu…
3 Jul 2020

The end of the bond bull market and the return of inflation

Central bank stimulus, surging post-lockdown demand and the end of the 40-year bond bull market. It all points to inflation, says John Stepek. Here’s …
30 Jun 2020