A few weeks ago I had an argument with an acquaintance about Warren Buffett. Everyone in the financial industry goes on about his fabulous financial record and the skills he has used to create it.
But I have long wondered if it isn't possible that Buffett is just a really lucky guy. After all, toss a couple of million coins 40 times and a few are bound to fall on heads each time. That's the way probability works. Buffett's record could be no more extraordinary than that of the person tossing the lucky coin.
It isn't an argument that usually goes down all that well in financial circles. So I was pleased to see Matthew Vincent pointing out in the FT this week that it is entirely possible. You can read his column here: How fund managers get paid for winning the lottery. He sums up research from former pension fund manager Rick Di Mascio who, via his investment evaluation firm Inalytics, has shown that "there is a marked difference between the track record of a fund manager and his level of skill."
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Matthew also notes that out of 1,188 UK funds, only 16 have managed top quartile performance in each of the three years. And if you look at that with an eye on rational statistics, it is very hard to argue that that is the result of much in the way of skill. "Anyone with a rudimentary grasp of probability would know that a quarter of a quarter of a quarter must by definition be top quartile in all three years." That's 1.56% or 18 funds.
Those who aren't convinced of all this and can't be bothered to do the numbers need only remind themselves of illusionist Derren Brown's attempts to explain probability to the general population via his TV programme The System which appeared to show that he had a guaranteed method of predicting the result of horse races. He didn't of course. Wikipedia explains it here: "He had started by contacting 7,776 people and split hem into six groups, giving each group a different horse. As each race had taken place, 56 of the people had lost and were dropped from the system. Brown had a different person backing each horse in each race, and one individual, Khadisha, won five times in a row." Khadisha was the only one the TV audience got to watch the whole way through.
What if Warren Buffett is Khadisha? One answer to that is that it doesn't really matter anyone who invested with him early on is now very rich, regardless of whether he is lucky or clever. The other is that it does matter. Why? Because most of us believe in fund manager skill and most of us are prepared to pay for it. But if we thought all success stories were just Khadishas, we probably wouldn't.
I suspect most fund managers are well aware that their returns are more luck than skill driven. I spoke a few weeks ago to a stock-broking friend. He is keen to move to a hedge fund. Did he think he was particularly good at investing? No. Not at all. He can't imagine himself making more than average returns. But if he is working at a hedge fund when a new bull market starts (as he thinks it will), he'll be able to borrow lots of money and invest that too. Then his returns will look great and he'll make a fortune. As he said: "average returns plus leverage, that's where the money is." Nothing to do with skill.
-
Christmas at Chatsworth: review of The Cavendish Hotel at BaslowMoneyWeek Travel Matthew Partridge gets into the festive spirit at The Cavendish Hotel at Baslow and the Christmas market at Chatsworth
-
Tycoon Truong My Lan on death row over world’s biggest bank fraudProperty tycoon Truong My Lan has been found guilty of a corruption scandal that dwarfs Malaysia’s 1MDB fraud and Sam Bankman-Fried’s crypto scam
-
House prices to crash? Your house may still be making you money, but not for much longerOpinion If you’re relying on your property to fund your pension, you may have to think again. But, says Merryn Somerset Webb, if house prices start to fall there may be a silver lining.
-
Prepare your portfolio for recessionOpinion A recession is looking increasingly likely. Add in a bear market and soaring inflation, and things are going to get very complicated for investors, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
-
Investing for income? Here are six investment trusts to buy nowOpinion For many savers and investors, income is getting hard to find. But it's not impossible to find, says Merryn Somerset Webb. Here, she picks six investment trusts that are currently yielding more than 4%.
-
Stories are great – but investors should stick to realityOpinion Everybody loves a story – and investors are no exception. But it’s easy to get carried away, says Merryn Somerset Webb, and forget the underlying truth of the market.
-
Everything is collapsing at once – here’s what to do about itOpinion Equity and bond markets are crashing, while inflation destroys the value of cash. Merryn Somerset Webb looks at where investors can turn to protect their wealth.
-
Value is starting to emerge in the marketsOpinion If you are looking for long-term value in the markets, some is beginning to emerge, says Merryn Somerset Webb. Indeed, you may soon be able to buy traditionally expensive growth stocks on the cheap, too.
-
ESG investing could end up being a classic mistakeOpinion ESG investing has been embraced with enormous speed and zeal. But think long and hard before buying in, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
-
UK house prices will fall – but not for a few yearsOpinion UK house prices look out of reach for many. But the truth is that British property is surprisingly affordable, says Merryn Somerset Webb. Prices will fall at some point – but not yet.
