Are you a contributor to or a burden on the nation's finances? Ed Monk asked the question in The Daily Mail a few weeks agowhen a new study came out from the Centre for Policy Studies (CPS) showing that some 53% of households took in more in benefits than they paid in tax in 2010/11. In 1979 that number was 43.1%.
The numbers in question are all averages of course, but using them, it seems that you have to get into the top two quintiles of income in order to be paying out more than you take in. If you are in the top 20-40%, you are paying in around £4,000 more than you get back. If you are in the top 20% you are paying in an extra £20,000. And if you are in the bottom 20%? You are getting out £10,000 more than you put in.
This was an argument picked up by Ruth Davidson, leader of the Scottish Tories last week. She told a fringe event at the party conference that only 12% of households in Scotland are net contributors in that "the taxes they pay outweigh the benefits they receive through public spending".That didn't go down particularly well.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
The opposition and some in her own party jumped on her for having something of a 'Romney moment' (two weeks ago MittRomney claimed 47% of Americans were benefit junkies for whom he could do nothing). Her numbers were also put under some keen scrutiny. But while you carp here and there at her use of data (and many have) the basic point stands.
The UK and Scotland are fast becoming client states in which the majority of people receive services for which both they and someone else pays. People don't necessarily want to take more than they contribute: they get services whether they (or the person making up the difference in tax) want them or not. And that matters.
As Gillian Bowditch points out in the Scottish edition of the Sunday Times, " it is not free money which government largesse dispenses to tax payers in a series of treats, which is how the Scottish government somehow portrays it it is hard-earned cash taken from people struggling to make ends meet to feed the growing demands of the state". How big the state should be is a question that all governments will grapple with for ever more, but right now the answer seems pretty clear not this big.
Whatever your ideology, it is hard to argue with the fact that a country in which more people (voluntarily or not) are financial takers than givers and in which the state accounts for more than 50% of GDP is just not sustainable. As Bowditch says, "we may not like the message, but shooting the messenger isn't going to make it disappear".
-
Water companies blocked from using customer money to pay “undeserved” bonusesThe regulator has blocked three water companies from using billpayer money to pay £1.5 million in exec bonuses
-
Will the Bitcoin price hit $100,000?With Bitcoin prices trading just below $100,000, we explore whether the cryptocurrency can hit the milestone.
-
Beating inflation takes more luck than skill – but are we about to get lucky?Opinion The US Federal Reserve managed to beat inflation in the 1980s. But much of that was down to pure luck. Thankfully, says Merryn Somerset Webb, the Bank of England may be about to get lucky.
-
Rishi Sunak can’t fix all our problems – so why try?Opinion Rishi Sunak’s Spring Statement is an attempt to plaster over problems the chancellor can’t fix. So should he even bother trying, asks Merryn Somerset Webb?
-
Young people are becoming a scarce resource – we should value them more highlyOpinion In the last two years adults have been bizarrely unkind to children and young people. That doesn’t bode well for the future, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
-
Ask for a pay rise – everyone else isOpinion As inflation bites and the labour market remains tight, many of the nation's employees are asking for a pay rise. Merryn Somerset Webb explains why you should do that too.
-
Why central banks should stick to controlling inflationOpinion The world’s central bankers are stepping out of their traditional roles and becoming much more political. That’s a mistake, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
-
How St Ives became St Tropez as the recovery drives prices sky highOpinion Merryn Somerset Webb finds herself at the epicentre of Britain’s V-shaped recovery as pent-up demand flows straight into Cornwall’s restaurants and beaches.
-
The real problem of Universal Basic Income (UBI)Merryn's Blog April employment numbers showed 75 per cent fewer people in the US returned to employment compared to expectations. Merryn Somerset-Webb explains how excessive government support is causing a shortage of labour.
-
Why an ageing population is not necessarily the disaster many people think it isOpinion We’ve got used to the idea that an ageing population is a bad thing. But that’s not necessarily true, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
