Merryn's Blog

A solution to the housing 'shortage' – put a tax on luck

The housing 'shortage' has been created in part by affluent people living in big houses, and buying up property to use as holiday homes. But most of them just got lucky, and that's what we should be taxing.

As you may know, I am not mad about the idea of a wealth tax. But that isn't because I think it is in any way worse than any other taxes.

Instead it is partly because I don't think we need any more taxes at all. Seems to me that the government should be able to find a way to make do with the 50%-odd of GDP they control already.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

It is also partly about the fact that if we do end up with a mansion tax or a wealth tax, we won't get it instead of the 50% rate (which I don't like), stamp duty (which I hate) and inheritance tax (which is pointless because the rich don't pay it). We'll get it on top of them.

And that is just too much inheritance tax is already a wealth tax (just one collected on the dead instead of the living) so I can't for the life of me figure out why the government won't just cut the loopholes everyone exploits on that and be done with it.

However there is one thing that a property tax might be good for dealing with the housing problem. At a seminar for clients of a wealth management company this week I was asked what I would do about the lack of supply of housing in the UK. Many of the attendees are worried about their children given how expensive houses are, and how few of them there are about, how will they ever get a place of their own?

Advertisement - Article continues below

I'm not sure I approached the question with that much sympathy. Why? Because many of the people who make up part of the cause of the problem, such as it is (I'm not convinced there is a shortage of housing in the UK), were sitting right in front of me.

There are around a million empty houses in the UK around 300,000 of which are holiday homes. There are probably many hundreds of thousands more being lived in by people who just don't need all of them one elderly couple in a four-bedroom house for example.

So when they wonder what the government is going to do about the problem, they are looking at the wrong thing. They should be asking what they are going to do about it. If the affluent all moved out of their big houses into small houses and put their second homes on the market, supply would rise and house prices would fall in a flash. Problem solved.

I can't see anyone doing this voluntarily it isn't the kind of solution my audience were looking for. However, if everyone agrees that the supply of housing is too low and that Something Must Be Done, then it seems entirely reasonable to chuck a few property taxes into the mix.

You could tax spare bedrooms, tax houses over a certain square footage or tax houses over a certain value. And you could put a horribly punitive annual tax on any home not used as a primary residence (not that you'd get that one past the MPs.). It wouldn't be long before most people just had one house with no more bedrooms than they have family members and before most people could afford should they still want to to buy a house with said number of bedrooms.

Advertisement - Article continues below

An extra benefit would be that all these taxes would get the non-doms who are currently knocking around in vast London houses and paying not a penny in tax towards the upkeep of the infrastructure around them.

I'm not suggesting we do this (although if we dumped stamp, IHT and the 50% rate, and the government looked to be attempting to live within its means, I wouldn't be against it) but it would be a pretty quick way to get the UK's affluent to solve a problem that both bothers them and which they have at least in part caused.

However I wouldn't call it a mansion tax or a wealth tax. I'd call it a luck tax. Why?

Because most people work hard. But whether working hard turns into being well off or not is often a function of the environment in which you work. And this tax would be primarily paid by those who bought their houses when they were cheap and who made their money during the fabulous years for wealth creation before our great crisis.

And because it sounds nicer.




How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
House prices

UK house prices may be heading for a Boris bounce

The latest survey of estate agents and surveyors from the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors is "unambiguously positive" – suggesting house pric…
16 Jan 2020

Are UK house prices really on the rebound?

The latest house price data from the Office for National Statistics paint a picture of a housing market that is showing signs of rallying. That's not …
15 Jan 2020

Most Popular


Money Minute Friday 17 January: UK weakness likely to continue

Today's Money Minute previews UK retail sales figures the UK, inflation data from Europe and industrial production from the US.
17 Jan 2020

Currency Corner: how high can the pound go against the euro in 2020?

In the month in which we should finally leave the European Union, Dominic Frisby takes a look at the pound vs the euro and asks just how high sterling…
13 Jan 2020
House prices

UK house prices may be heading for a Boris bounce

The latest survey of estate agents and surveyors from the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors is "unambiguously positive" – suggesting house pric…
16 Jan 2020
Share tips

Class acts going cheap: buy into Europe’s best bargains

Value investing appears to be making a comeback, while shares on this side of the Atlantic are more appealing on metrics such as price/earnings ratios…
16 Jan 2020