The spectre of stagflation shakes stockmarkets

“With price increases slamming economies from all directions,” markets are getting increasingly jumpy, says Susannah Streeter of Hargreaves Lansdown. Investors also fret that weakening macroeconomic data could herald a slowdown. No wonder that in recent weeks concerns about stagflation, the combination of economic stagnation and high inflation, “seem to have turned from niggling worries to an anxiety attack”.

Markets have hit a wall

America’s S&P 500 finished September down 4.8%, its worst month since the crash in March 2020. The selling continued into this week, with the technology-focused Nasdaq Composite tumbling by 2.1% on Monday. Highly-valued technology shares are particularly vulnerable to rising interest rates and bond yields (which make bonds more appealing relative to equities). The FTSE’s exposure to commodity stocks has spared it the worst of the sell-off: the index is down by about 1% since the start of September. Yet markets seem gloomy about the outlook for the wider British economy.

Last week the pound tumbled to $1.3441 against the dollar, its lowest level of 2021, notes Philip Aldrick in The Times. That is worrying because the Bank of England is expected to raise interest rates sooner than other central banks, which should be giving sterling a lift. There are signs that UK “growth is flagging” just as energy and food prices soar; British wage growth is “the highest since 2008”.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

If stagflation takes hold then “the Bank of England can do little about” it, says Chris Dillow in the Investors’ Chronicle. It can raise rates to fight inflation or loosen policy to stop stagnation, but not both. Some of the current inflationary pressure should prove temporary: “labour market mismatches should fade as firms… train new staff”, while the commodity cycle will eventually turn, as it always does. If there is one area for concern, it is that the current shock is exposing Britain’s chronic problem with productivity, which has grown at “just 0.3% per year” over the last 14 years.

Goodbye “Goldilocks”

Global markets have enjoyed a “Goldilocks” environment for much of this year, says Olivier Marciot of Unigestion. That combined “record growth” with easy monetary policy from central banks, both of which boost stocks. But as inflation spikes and central banks rein in support, that favourable alignment of the economic planets has “probably come to an end”, driving the selloff.

Since 2008, investors have lived by “TINA”: “there is no alternative” to investing in stocks, says Jon Sindreu in The Wall Street Journal. The logic goes that whenever the economy takes a hit then central banks will step in with easy money to rescue stocks. So equities always go up. The fear now is that inflation will force central banks to hike rates no matter how much that hurts markets. Yet “every precedent suggests that… officials will course-correct whenever” bond markets throw a big enough tantrum. The recovery could also prove weaker than expected, enabling central banks to keep policy loose. “There is still no alternative” to TINA.