Why do house prices just keep marching higher?

Before I get started this morning – don’t forget to answer our 20th anniversary questions! Best answers will be published in next week’s mag – check out the questions here.

The second wave of Covid is clearly here. The pressure for a full-on lockdown is building. Markets around the world are rattled. The oil price has collapsed (again). Stocks are jittery. Gold has been on the slide too. Even bitcoin’s recent hot run has stopped in its tracks.

And yet, through it all, the UK housing market sales on. The latest figures from Nationwide, which issues one of the longest-running and most widely-reported house price indices in the UK, show that annual house price growth hit 5.8% in October. That’s the highest rate seen since January 2015.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

This isn’t some glitch caused by a small number of sales. It comes off the back of a big increase in activity. Mortgage approvals for house purchase came in at 91,500 in September, which is the kind of level we haven’t seen since 2007. Believe it or not, it looks as though 2020 will end up being one of the strongest years for house price growth we’ve seen in at least five years. Yes, 2020, the plague year. What’s going on?

What’s driving house prices in the UK?

Let’s start with the obvious. Everyone who wanted to move earlier in the year had to call a halt during lockdown, so that created a backlog of sales that are going through now. Given the pandemic, right enough, you could have been forgiven for expecting a lot of those sales to have collapsed. But that doesn’t appear to have happened – or, at least, new activity has compensated for previously planned sales falling through.

The next obvious factor is the stamp duty holiday. If you’d been on the fence about moving, then the idea of saving money on tax is probably enough to sway you in the direction of deciding to go through with it (yes, it’s not at all clear who benefits most from the stamp duty cut but let’s park that for now). The stamp duty holiday runs until March (which of course, does not mean that it won’t be extended). So that’s an impetus to get on with moving.

What about longer-term factors? Well, interest rates are still low and they won’t be going up any time soon. I’d just caveat that with a point – they aren’t going down either. In September, the average rate on a new mortgage was 1.74% (up by 0.02 percentage points on the month before) while the rate on existing mortgages slipped by 0.01 percentage point to 2.13%.

And it’s worth remembering that at least two of the big factors that had kept house-price growth more modest in recent years – unusually extreme political uncertainty, plus the impact of George Osborne’s landlord tax reforms – are now pretty much in the past.

OK – so we can see several factors why house price growth might be rallying. The next obvious question is this: that’s all very well, but what about the flipping great pandemic and the government reaction which has upturned our economy, our way of life, and threatens to create massive swathes of unemployment? How on earth can this be good for house prices?

The K-shaped recovery explains UK house price growth

Well, let’s think this through. Economists have run through lots of different alphabetical letters to try to describe the shape of the recovery (or lack of one) that we’re likely to have from Covid.

One such letter is the “K” shaped recovery. That’s when different sections of the economy recover at different rates. Long story short, the better off come back a lot faster than the worse off. I also think it’s fair to surmise that many of the people who are relocating because they are confident of being able to work from home for good are also probably in the upper leg of the “K” shape. And now they’re keen to exploit that newfound freedom.

“Behavioural shifts appear to be boosting housing market activity as people reassess their housing needs and preferences,” as Nationwide chief economist Robert Gardner puts it.

This urban exodus is in turn being driven by the relatively well-off selling properties in expensive urban areas, and then feeling able to splash the cash when they go shopping beyond the daily commuter zone. That’s going to push up prices in areas that previously haven’t enjoyed the benefit of “quality of life” movers.

On top of that, a lot of people have saved a lot of money during lockdown. It’s been clear that much of the cash that wasn’t spent on holidays, eating out, or all of those other things, has been redirected to home improvements. And what is moving house, other than a massive home improvement project?

So overall, as mad as it seems, there are clear reasons for the burst higher in prices, even in the face of the pandemic. Will it continue? The end of the stamp duty holiday might demonstrate that lots of house moves were simply brought forward. The urban exodus will also diminish over time, particularly if working from home is less feasible than believed.

But will either of those things then lead to a crash in prices? I can’t see it. And believe me, I say that as someone who feels strongly that high house prices are a bad thing, and one of the most potent destabilising forces in both our economy and our society.

We’ll see what happens. But it looks like it will take more than a global pandemic to put a dent in our dysfunctional property market.