The Trump tariff chaos and the broader sense that the world is changing profoundly makes it hard to remain optimistic at times like these. There’s a temptation to retreat to safe assets – such as cash or gold – which may well turn out to be the smart call in the shorter term. Yet there is a bullish way to think about these changes as well. They may end up being part of a long-overdue adjustment – just not quite in the way that the US president and his advisers hope.
America has dominated global markets to an unhealthy extent over the past decade or more. The degree to which it has beaten almost everything else is striking: the MSCI USA index has returned 12.4% per year (in dollar terms) over ten years, while the MSCI World ex USA has returned 6% per year. There have been some solid reasons from this, ranging from America’s superior energy security after the shale revolution in the early 2010s to the greater dynamism of high-growth sectors (helped by capital markets that were willing to fund and scale up new companies in a way that the rest of the world was not). However, this cannot continue forever.
The US market trades at a large premium to the rest of the wold. The MSCI USA is on a forecast price/earnings ratio of around 20 times, the MSCI World ex USA on around 14 times. It may well still deserve some of that premium – but it cannot continue to expand the difference and keep outperforming. What’s more, to the extent that higher valuations reflected a superior business environment up until now, the premium may need to be smaller in future. Erratic policy making and weakening of the rule of law will surely make America a less attractive and more uncertain place to do business. It would be hyperbole to say that it now looks like an emerging market, but that contains a grain of truth: recent events are what you expect to see in a rather ineptly managed and somewhat autocratic country, rather than the lynchpin of the global order.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Two benefits for the rest of the world
If investors become a little more sceptical about the USA, it may benefit other markets in more than one way. The most obvious and immediate benefit is that a bit more cash going into the UK, Europe, Japan or emerging markets rather than America will – at the margin – help raise valuations there.
The more subtle and long-term benefit is the counterpoint to the Trump administration’s belief that the US trade deficit means that the rest of the world is simply harming America. After all, an alternative way to think about the real damage caused by this imbalance is that America’s capital surplus (the necessary offset to the current account deficit in the balance of payments) sucks in capital from the rest of the world, starving economies, markets and start-ups of investment.
While the US market was doing better, this was a rational decision for investors, but one that arguably created a virtuous cycle for America and a vicious cycle for other economies. If less capital now flows to the US, it may be good for growth elsewhere, which in turn will be good for earnings and create another tailwind for non-US stocks.
This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
-
8 of the best converted properties for sale nowThe best converted properties for sale – from an apartment in the former Hartley’s Jam factory on London’s Southbank, to a converted 18th-century mill in Itteringham, Norfolk
-
How taking a two-year career break could leave a £26k hole in your pensionCareer breaks are increasingly common but it is important to take steps to protect your pension, as gaps compound over time
-
Will Comstock crash – or soar?Opinion The upside for Comstock, a solar panel-recycling and biomass-refining group, dwarfs the downside, says Dominic Frisby.
-
'As AGMs go digital, firms must offer a new form of scrutiny for shareholders'Opinion Technology has rendered big AGM meet-ups obsolete, but the board still needs to be held to account, says Matthew Lynn
-
Unilever braces for inflation amid tariff uncertainty – what does it mean for investors?Consumer-goods giant Unilever has made steady progress simplifying its operations. Will tariffs now cause turbulence?
-
What will the unravelling of US-China trade mean for the economy?What will a US-China decoupling mean for the global economy?
-
What's next for Liberal Mark Carney after Canadian election winMark Carney will remain as Canadian prime minister after winning the country's election, despite falling short of a majority.
-
Two ways to tap into monopoly profits from airportsMost investors can’t get their hands on airports. Here are two ways you can
-
Fat profits: should you invest in weight-loss drugs?The latest weight-loss treatments could transform public health and the world economy. Should you invest?
-
How investors could profit from Ramsden Holdings' four-part growth strategyRamsdens Holdings offers a diversified set of financial and retail services and a juicy yield, says Dr Michael Tubbs
