Why investors should get set for ten lean years

Forecasts for the next decade could be too bearish, but the 2020s are unlikely to be as simple as the 2010s

It didn’t matter too much what you invested in over the past decade. Most assets delivered strong returns. The MSCI World index of global equities had a gross total return around 12% per year in sterling terms (gross total return means including reinvested dividends but not allowing for the cost of taxes that some countries deduct from dividends). The S&P UK Gilt Bond index of British government bonds managed around 5.5% per year, with bonds with longer maturities doing better because they started on higher yields. UK commercial property has returned around 9% per year, according to the MSCI UK Monthly Property index. 

Obviously things have got steadily tougher for cash as interest rates dwindle, and emerging market stocks failed to beat less risky developed ones (6% per year for the MSCI Emerging Markets index in sterling terms). But if your portfolio was well diversified between assets and countries, you’d normally have done fairly well – your individual choices didn’t matter that much.

The bull must run out of breath

That very satisfactory situation is unlikely to be repeated in the 2020s. We’ve had a bull market running for more than a decade almost everywhere. Most assets are significantly more expensive than they were in 2010. While markets often rise far beyond what looks rational, it’s difficult to see how such a broad-based bull market can last until 2030. 

The chart above shows long-term estimates for various asset classes from the US investment managers GMO and Research Affiliates. The two firms use different models, but both assume that extreme valuations are likely to revert back towards historical averages. This may not happen as quickly as you’d expect: GMO’s team was consistently wrong in its forecasts for US equities in the 2010s because both valuations and margins have remained very high. It may well be too pessimistic again. But even Research Affiliates’ less pessimistic model does not produce returns in any asset class that are close to what we’ve seen over the last ten years.

Both expect a big difference between the best and worst asset classes, with emerging-market stocks coming top. That’s helpful for investors – at least there is one asset class that offers some opportunities. But there are few investors who would be comfortable having most of their assets in emerging markets. So the wider conclusion for anybody who wants to keep a prudently diversified portfolio is that we must expect a much leaner decade – and prepare to save more (or spend less) to make our long-term financial plans work in that environment.

Recommended

The best 0% balance-transfer credit cards
Credit cards

The best 0% balance-transfer credit cards

These 0% balance transfer credit cards offer some of the best deals on the market today.
26 May 2023
Where do we go from here?
Investments

Where do we go from here?

A new series of interviews from MoneyWeek
26 May 2023
Best savings accounts – May 2023
Savings

Best savings accounts – May 2023

Interest rates have been creeping up - we look at the best savings accounts on the market right now.
26 May 2023
The best one-year fixed savings accounts - May 2023
Savings

The best one-year fixed savings accounts - May 2023

You can now earn 5% on 1 year fixed savings accounts - the best rate seen in 14 years. We have all the latest rates available now.
26 May 2023

Most Popular

Nationwide to give £100 cash boost to customers
Personal finance

Nationwide to give £100 cash boost to customers

Nationwide Building Society is giving customers £100 as it reinvests profits. Dubbed the Nationwide Fairer Share scheme, we look at who is eligible.
22 May 2023
Share tips of the week – 26 May
Investments

Share tips of the week – 26 May

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
25 May 2023
Holiday rip-off: Millions of travellers hit with hidden costs by using debit card abroad
Personal finance

Holiday rip-off: Millions of travellers hit with hidden costs by using debit card abroad

A family of four on a week-long trip to France could pay an extra £212 in fees by using their everyday bank card compared to the lowest-cost option, a…
23 May 2023