Beware: even the greatest brands can fail

For decades, John Lewis seemed to exist in a parallel universe. Now, a grimmer reality has dawned

Until this week John Lewis seemed able to rise effortlessly above the existential crisis that has gripped every other major retailer. From its origins as a humble drapery shop on Oxford Street in the 1860s, it remained a primarily London-based business for much of its history. But in the last 20 years, it pushed relentlessly into new markets, opening 50 department stores across the country. Its Waitrose unit expanded even more aggressively and now has 350 supermarkets. While just about every other retailer had to cut back and retrench in the face of rising staff costs, punishing business rates, tepid consumer spending and ferocious competition from the internet, John Lewis sailed on regardless. It was as if it was in a parallel universe, where running shops was a great business to be in.

Don’t get high on your own supply

In the last year, all that changed. Last week the chain announced it was scrapping its staff bonus for the first time since 1953. For the six months to June it posted losses of £635m. That included a huge writedown on the value of its stores, but it is still losing money overall. It has started to close shops, and has even floated the possibility of converting some into office space (although if there is one industry in more trouble than department stores right now it is surely offices). There are lessons to be learned here. 

Firstly, don’t overexpand. John Lewis started opening huge department stores across the country. Some of them were vast. Its flagship Birmingham store, opened in 2015, covered 250,000 square feet, the equivalent of 3.5 football pitches. Smaller stores started popping up on retail parks and in shopping malls around the country. It may have seemed like a winning formula at first. Every time you open a new shop, you attract more customers, extend the brand, and acquire more buying power to drive down the cost of suppliers. But at a certain point, you start opening up in more and more marginal locations, and you start cannibalising your own sales. Customers switch from an older store to a newer one closer to their home, but overall sales don’t increase. Likewise, Waitrose, by far the more successful part of the business, was expanding furiously at the same time as the discount chains such as Aldi and Lidl. They might appear to be at completely different ends of the market, but in truth, the grocery market is ferociously competitive, and far too crowded, and that makes it hard for anyone to make much money. 

Secondly, don’t fall for your own hype. John Lewis marketed itself brilliantly as being very different from other retailers. It traded on its reputation for value and quality. That was a great way of making itself stand out in a crowded market. The problem is that it seemed to think that it could also stand apart from all the wider problems in retailing. While customers were abandoning traditional shops for the internet, and while other department stores were running into deep trouble, John Lewis just carried on as if its brand would protect it. In truth, it should have started adapting its strategy at least five years ago. 

The downside of having loyal staff

Finally, don’t run the company for the staff. John Lewis’s unique employee-ownership structure created great team spirit. It had the most loyal staff in an industry that is often notorious for low pay and poor conditions. All that was reflected in great service. Loyal staff helped create loyal customers. The trouble is, that may also have stopped tough decisions being made when they needed to be. It is a fantastic structure when the business is growing. When it has to retrench, it suddenly doesn’t work so well. Stores remain open too long, and staff numbers are too high – and very quickly that starts to hurt.

It remains to be seen whether John Lewis can bounce back. Like many other retailers, it has too much space, often in the wrong places. It will take a lot of hard work to turn that around. Every firm is different, and each one faces its own set of challenges. John Lewis’s fall from grace is a reminder for investors that even the best brands may not be as secure as they appear.

Recommended

Index fund
Funds

Index fund

Index funds (also known as passive funds or "trackers") aim to track the performance of a particular index, such as the FTSE 100 or S&P 500.
18 Jan 2022
Model Y: Tesla has nailed it once again
Cars

Model Y: Tesla has nailed it once again

The electric carmaker’s new SUV crossover, the Model Y, sets the benchmark in the sector.
18 Jan 2022
The UK jobs market is booming – but wages are struggling to keep up with prices
UK Economy

The UK jobs market is booming – but wages are struggling to keep up with prices

Britain’s jobs market is booming, with wages rising and plenty of of vacancies. But inflation is rising faster than wages can keep up. John Stepek loo…
18 Jan 2022
A sophisticated trio of scintillating whites
Wine

A sophisticated trio of scintillating whites

An Australian sauvignon blanc that is as sophisticated and refreshing as any Loire superstar’s creation, plus a chardonnay and shiraz, too.
18 Jan 2022

Most Popular

Five unexpected events that could shock the markets in 2022
Stockmarkets

Five unexpected events that could shock the markets in 2022

Forget Covid-19 – it’s the unexpected twists that will rattle markets in 2022, says Matthew Lynn. Here are five possibilities
31 Dec 2021
Which investment trusts performed the best in 2021?
Investment trusts

Which investment trusts performed the best in 2021?

Shivani Khandekar runs through the top ten investment trusts of 2021 – and the worst performing trusts – and looks ahead to 2022.
7 Jan 2022
The booming jobs market points to inflation lasting for longer
Economy

The booming jobs market points to inflation lasting for longer

It’s a good time to be looking for a job, with plenty of vacancies and wages rising. But higher wagers are driving inflation up – and it’s not just a …
11 Jan 2022