The abolition of NHS England, the world’s largest quango, is part of Keir Starmer’s “Project Chainsaw” to tackle a “weaker” but “ever-expanding state”, says Beth Rigby on Sky News. He also intends to get rid of regulators, slash red tape and use artificial intelligence (AI).
Every arm’s-length state body is up for review. Welfare secretary Liz Kendall also announced benefit reforms that she hopes will save £5 billion annually by 2030. Starmer is prepared to fight not just “blockers” and “NIMBYs” but also his own party, public-sector workers and the unions in the knowledge that if his government fails to deliver, the winners will be Reform UK or “even a revived” Tory opposition.
How Labour is fighting the flab
By prioritising fiscal prudence over social policy, he has set the scene for a “showdown” with the left of his party, though his 168-strong Commons majority does provide a cushion, says Joe Mayes on Bloomberg. Starmer’s attack on the “flabby state” has come as a shock, but for most of the modern left’s history, anti-bureaucratic politics has in fact been a “core principle”, says Thomas Peermohamed Lambert in The New Statesman.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
And if Starmer can “harness some of the justified animus towards NHS England” and direct it to other bureaucratic “nuisances” such as “corrupt procurement structures, murky public-private partnerships and powerful lobbying machines”, he might succeed not just in emulating the antibureaucratic right, but in beating them, too.
Starmerite centrism is “a historical reset” for the party, says Stephen Bush in the Financial Times. He wants to make the party the “natural home” for economically insecure workers uneasy about perceived generosity to the poorest at home and abroad. In part, Labour is driven by expediency: the worsening economic backdrop coupled with a need to stick to Rachel Reeves’ fiscal rules.
The problem, in practice, is that the government’s ability to “rewire” the economy “tends to be limited in the extreme” and it often does a “bad job”. Alarmingly, the labour market is “softening fast” and “much of the rest of Labour’s economic agenda” is aimed at “squeezing out the lower-paid jobs that are most likely to suit someone with a thin work history and health problems”, says The Economist. Changes to national insurance and the minimum wage mean “cheap” labour will cost 5% more in April.
It’s hard not to feel sorry for Reeves, says Martin Wolf, also in the Financial Times. As she presides over a stagnant economy with high indebtedness, she could either game her self-imposed new fiscal rules or relax them. Both would look “ridiculous”. The alternative would be for her and Starmer to say that this is a new world and we need to borrow more for defence, while also raising “broad-based taxes on income, sales and property” and going even further with spending cuts.
At the same time, the government must pursue pro-growth deregulation and investment, and embrace EU initiatives and new technologies. “The country needs leadership. A bold government would state that the constraints we have lived under on taxation, spending and regulation need to be reassessed. Times have changed. So must we.”
/This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
-
Defeat into victory: the key to Simon Wolfson's successOpinion Next CEO Simon Wolfson claims he owes his success to a book on military strategy in World War II. What lessons does it hold, and how did he apply them to Next?
-
Aircraft leasing companies can lift investors' portfoliosThe aircraft leasing business is a safer way to cash in on air travel and its booming demand. David Prosser explains how it works and how to access it
-
Defeat into victory: the key to Next CEO Simon Wolfson's success
Opinion Next CEO Simon Wolfson claims he owes his success to a book on military strategy in World War II. What lessons does it hold, and how did he apply them to Next?
-
How to find value in Asian small cap stocksThree competing Asian investment trusts all have good records, but this one is the obvious choice at present, says Max King
-
The battle of the bond markets and public financesAn obsessive focus on short-term fiscal prudence is likely to create even greater risks in a few years, says Cris Sholto Heaton
-
'Rachel Reeves’s tax rise will crash the economy'Opinion Rachel Reeves will be the first chancellor since Denis Healey in the 1970s to raise income tax. It will only push Britain into recession, says Matthew Lynn
-
Cringe Britannia: the decline of the UK's soft powerBritain has long wielded soft power through its commitment to sound political values and the export of high and popular culture. That is now under threat
-
'We still live in Alan Greenspan’s shadow'When MoneyWeek launched 25 years ago, Alan Greenspan was chairman of the Federal Reserve. We’re still living with the consequences of the whirlwind he sowed
-
Go for growth: how to invest in emerging marketsDeveloping countries offer investors compelling long-term economic prospects, says David Prosser
-
Isaac Newton's golden legacy – how the English polymath created the gold standard by accidentIsaac Newton brought about a new global economic era by accident, says Dominic Frisby
