Brazil passes pensions reform

Brazil has finally completed a long-awaited overhaul of its pension system.

Brazil stockmarket traders © Getty Images

Equities are attractively priced, but prepare for turbulence

Brazil stockmarket traders © Getty Images

"It took three presidents, four finance ministers and countless setbacks," says Julia Leite on Bloomberg. But Brazil has finally completed a long-awaited overhaul of its pension system. Lawmakers have approved reforms that should save the country about 800bn reais (£155bn) over ten years by increasing minimum retirement ages and closing loopholes.

Brazil's Ibovespa stock index has surged 21% over the past year. Yet that rally has been driven by domestic money. Foreign investors have withdrawn money amid scepticism about whether this reform story has further to run.

The passage of the pension bill could bring the "outperformance of Brazilian assets to an end", says William Jackson of Capital Economics. After a strong run at the start of the year, the total return on the country's stocks has been among the worst of any major emerging market since the first pensions vote on 10 July. "It looks like the good news on reform is already priced into local markets."

The end of the reform story?

Brazil's ballooning pensions bill was a serious threat to the nation's future, say Paulo Trevisani and Jeffrey Lewis in The Wall Street Journal. Pensions accounted for a whopping 44% of the federal budget last year. Many public sector workers retire as early as their late 40s on handsome pensions. The reform should begin to stabilise federal finances that were getting dangerously out of control. So urgent had the issue become that "many took to the streets in rallies to demand a pension overhaul, rare in a country trying to roll back benefits".

Yet while the legislation will help Brazil avoid bankruptcy, "it won't spark growth", says Leite. With GDP forecast to rise by less than 1% this year, the flagging economy "desperately needs a jump-start".

Finance minister Paulo Guedes is pushing ahead with plans to overhaul the "byzantine" tax code and cut a bloated public sector, report Anthony Boadle and Jamie McGeever on Reuters. Yet where pension reform had been "debated in Congress for years before [Brazilian president Jair] Bolsonaro took office", the rest of the Guedes agenda is likely to spark opposition.

A fight between rival factions for control of Bolsonaro's own party is a barrier to further progress. Bolsonaro could also torpedo Guedes if he turns "his big mouth" on his economic team, Monica de Bolle of the Peterson Institute for International Economics tells the Financial Times. Buyers of Brazilian stocks will thus need strong stomachs. Civil unrest in neighbouring countries is a reminder that the risks are high. Yet for long-term value investors, stocks trading on a cyclically-adjusted price/earnings ratio of 17.4 are attractively priced. Just be prepared for turbulence.

Recommended

Russian stocks suffer as the world fears it will invade Ukraine
European stockmarkets

Russian stocks suffer as the world fears it will invade Ukraine

Despite a booming economy, Russian stocks look extraordinarily cheap – but if it invades Ukraine, the Russian stockmarket will become all but uninvest…
14 Jan 2022
Erdogan’s risky bluff to save the Turkish lira
Currencies

Erdogan’s risky bluff to save the Turkish lira

Turkey's autocratic president has said the government will guarantee lira deposits against further deterioration in the exchange rate. Few people are …
7 Jan 2022
Myanmar: a coup, a civil war, a crisis and China
Emerging markets

Myanmar: a coup, a civil war, a crisis and China

Myanmar was heading in the right direction after decades of isolation before the army seized control again in February. Now the outlook is increasingl…
24 Dec 2021
Will emerging markets have a better 2022, or is it downhill from here?
Emerging markets

Will emerging markets have a better 2022, or is it downhill from here?

Emerging market equities had a dismal year in 2021. John Stepek asks if 2022 will be any better, and takes a look at some of the most promising areas …
23 Dec 2021

Most Popular

Shareholder capitalism: why we must return power to listed companies’ ultimate owners
Investment strategy

Shareholder capitalism: why we must return power to listed companies’ ultimate owners

Under our system of shareholder capitalism it's not fund managers, it‘s the individual investors – the company's ultimate owners – who should be telli…
24 Jan 2022
Three innovative Asian stocks to buy now
Share tips

Three innovative Asian stocks to buy now

Professional investor Fay Ren of the Cerno Pacific Fund highlights three of her favourite Asian stocks to buy now
24 Jan 2022
Temple Bar’s Ian Lance and Nick Purves: the essence of value investing
Investment strategy

Temple Bar’s Ian Lance and Nick Purves: the essence of value investing

Ian Lance and Nick Purves of the Temple Bar investment trust explain the essence of “value investing” – buying something for less than its intrinsic v…
14 Jan 2022