The pension income-drawdown time bomb

Some pension savers being paid a regular income from their retirement funds could be heading for disaster.

Are pension savers heading for disaster by taking too much cash out of income drawdown plans early in retirement? Research from personal finance analyst Moneyfacts suggests that 70% of savers opting for a regular income from an income drawdown plan are taking 4% or more of their fund out each year. That includes 30% who are taking an income of 8% or more. Moneyfacts also reckons that 13% of savers have already burned through their entire pension fund.

A crisis is brewing

We may be heading for a crisis with income drawdown plans, which have soared in popularity since the pension freedom reforms of 2015. While the vast majority of savers used to convert pension fund savings into income via an annuity guaranteed for life, income drawdown plans allow you to withdraw cash directly from your pension fund. Crucially, there are no limits on withdrawals and nothing to stop you withdrawing your entire pension fund early in retirement, or even in one go.

Moneyfacts' data echoes recent warnings from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), the financial watchdog, which has repeatedly suggested that savers may be withdrawing too much from their pension funds. The FCA estimates that 40% of income drawdown plan holders are withdrawing at least 8% of their pension fund each year.

There is no clear limit on how much you can take out of your pension each year if it is to last for your whole retirement. That will depend on how long you live, but the way in which you invest your remaining pension fund will also be important, since this provides opportunities to replenish your savings. However, financial experts suggest that a withdrawal rate of 3% to 4% a year is at the top end of a safe drawdown programme, particularly for savers who have invested their pension fund in low-risk assets likely to generate lower levels of return. In that case, many savers will run out of pension fund well before their deaths.

So far, however, regulators have been reluctant to intervene. One major problem is that their data is incomplete: it measures people's withdrawal rates from each pension fund they hold rather than from their entire pension savings. In many cases, regulators suspect, savers withdrawing significant levels of income from one fund have other pension plans to fall back on.

Still, the data shows that people taking out income drawdown plans without first consulting an independent financial adviser are more likely to be withdrawing larger amounts. That suggests some may not understand the risks they are taking. Many in the pension industry now believe that the spread of income drawdown plans may prove to be a time bomb.

Recommended

Companies cut back on their pensions bills
Personal finance

Companies cut back on their pensions bills

Britvic is the latest firm hoping a cheaper inflation index will cut pension costs. David Prosser reports.
28 Aug 2019
The drawbacks of pension drawdown
Pensions

The drawbacks of pension drawdown

Income drawdown – tapping your pension savings for income – can be risky, says David Prosser. Here's what to watch out for.
11 Aug 2020
Covid-19 sees a surge in early retirement
Pensions

Covid-19 sees a surge in early retirement

The number of people taking early retirement has risen by more than ever before, says the ONS – in part because of problems in the labour market cause…
7 Aug 2020
We're all going to have to be a lot more flexible
UK Economy

We're all going to have to be a lot more flexible

As the world gets older, we'll all have to retire later and finance it for longer. That's going to take a major rethink about an awful lot of things, …
6 Aug 2020

Most Popular

No, the UK did not “plunge” into recession yesterday
UK Economy

No, the UK did not “plunge” into recession yesterday

That the economy took a massive hit due to Covid-19 should be news to no one, says John Stepek. The real question is what happens now.
13 Aug 2020
Inflation spiked in the US last month – is this the shape of things to come?
US Economy

Inflation spiked in the US last month – is this the shape of things to come?

Prices in the US rose much more dramatically than expected in July. Can we expect more of the same, and what does that mean for your money? John Stepe…
14 Aug 2020
The MoneyWeek Podcast: house prices, staycations, and the death of cash
House prices

The MoneyWeek Podcast: house prices, staycations, and the death of cash

John and Merryn talk about the rise in UK house prices and the fact that everybody is holidaying in the UK, plus gold's new highs, the death of cash, …
12 Aug 2020