Why a pension is a much better investment than property

Too many people see property as a good investment and pensions as a waste of time. They couldn't be more wrong, says Merryn Somerset Webb.

945_MW_P03_Letter
Pension taxes are proving increasingly vexing for NHS staff

In an interview with The Times at the weekend, MP Michael Fabricant answered the question: "What's better for retirement property or pension?" with "Property. I've made a bit of money on my London flat". Two questions for Mr Fabricant. First, how does he intend both to live in and live off his flat? And second, has he ever looked at his pension? Fabricant has been an MP since 1992. He has built up 26 years' worth of pension entitlement, which should mean that he retires on an inflation-linked pension of not far off £50,000 a year (I can't be exact here, as he could have made one of a variety of contribution choices).

To buy a similar income on the open market would cost not far off £2m. You can buy a one-bedroom flat in Westminster for £2m if you really try, but most still cost under £1m. So while Fabricant might have made a bit of money on his London flat, we can be pretty sure he hasn't made an MP's pension-worth on it. Not by a long shot.

Still, the key point here is that Fabricant aside, lots of public-sector workers are starting to grasp just how much more generous their pensions are than everyone else's and how that means they are starting to breach the new allowance system. The current lifetime allowance (LTA) is £1.055m. Have more than that in your pension fund (a defined-benefit pension is valued at 20 times the income from it for these purposes) and you pay an extra tax when you draw down. So £50,000 a year brings you close.

More serious for many is the annual allowance taper. Most people can put £40,000 a year into their pension. As your income rises to an "adjusted" level of £150,000 that falls, eventually to £10,000. Pension contributions are included in the "adjusted" bit. Because public-sector pensions are more generous than most, this pushes people over the thresholds, and lands them with a tax bill to be paid now (on cash they don't get until they retire and should they die early, will never get). The result? Extra chaos in the NHS, where almost all GPs and consultants find themselves with hard-to-calculate risks and are, they say, cutting their hours and retiring early to avoid them.

This isn't all bad. We wrote here many years ago that the absurdities inherent in the new system a lifetime allowance that punishes successful investment performance, and the incomprehensible taper system would only get wider attention when they started to noticeably affect public sector workers (and services). And so it is. There needs to be a limit on pension savings (the UK can't afford unlimited tax-free saving). But the current limits are the wrong ones. Hopefully the fuss from the doctors will help MPs grasp this and maybe start considering how generous their pensions are compared with yours and mine.

Most of us have none of these worries, of course. Our defined-contribution pensions are unlikely to hit the lifetime allowance particularly easily now that the annual allowance is so constrained (we can't contribute much in our highest earning years). If our aim is a public-sector style retirement we just have to invest well. With that in mind, in this week's issue of MoneyWeek magazine, Max King looks at a good trust investing in Eastern Europe; Jonathan Compton explains where the best value investments are to be found globally right now; and we ask if a new emperor in Japan could mean a new dawn for its stockmarkets too.

Recommended

The British equity market is shrinking
Stockmarkets

The British equity market is shrinking

British startups are abandoning public stockmarkets and turning to deep-pocketed Silicon Valley venture capitalists for their investment needs.
8 Nov 2019
Companies cut back on their pensions bills
Personal finance

Companies cut back on their pensions bills

Britvic is the latest firm hoping a cheaper inflation index will cut pension costs. David Prosser reports.
28 Aug 2019
Share tips of the week
Share tips

Share tips of the week

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
14 Aug 2020
The road to driverless cars
Sponsored

The road to driverless cars

The electrification of the automotive industry is gathering pace, but does the real future lie in driverless vehicles?
12 Aug 2020

Most Popular

No, the UK did not “plunge” into recession yesterday
UK Economy

No, the UK did not “plunge” into recession yesterday

That the economy took a massive hit due to Covid-19 should be news to no one, says John Stepek. The real question is what happens now.
13 Aug 2020
Inflation spiked in the US last month – is this the shape of things to come?
US Economy

Inflation spiked in the US last month – is this the shape of things to come?

Prices in the US rose much more dramatically than expected in July. Can we expect more of the same, and what does that mean for your money? John Stepe…
14 Aug 2020
The MoneyWeek Podcast: house prices, staycations, and the death of cash
House prices

The MoneyWeek Podcast: house prices, staycations, and the death of cash

John and Merryn talk about the rise in UK house prices and the fact that everybody is holidaying in the UK, plus gold's new highs, the death of cash, …
12 Aug 2020