Features

Macron’s listening exercise

A bold democratic initiative or a cynical political move? Matthew Partridge reports

930-Macron-634

Macron: the Jupiterean president comes down to earth

A bold democratic initiative or a cynical political move? Matthew Partridge reports.

President Emmanuel Macron's plans for a national "grand debate" to help resolve the crisis caused by the ongoing gilets jaunes protests currently roiling France could be seen as either "an imaginative bid to revitalise democracy in the social-media age" or "a cynical manoeuvre to outfox the yellow-vest protesters, and buy time before the Euro-elections in May", says the BBC's Hugh Schofield.

The "mass consultation" of the French people that the president has embarked upon will conducted in town halls, at public meetings and on the internet, and the results will be fed up to government to "help shape the second half of the Macron mandate". The idea is to deal with protestors' complaints about "the lack of democratic representation felt by many people in rural and small-town France".

Will it work?

While Macron can't be seen to be "bowing to violence", it would be a "terrible mistake" to ignore the legitimate concerns of the protestors many of whom "are French cousins of Donald Trump voters in the US". One issue that "must be addressed" is the "chronic, long-standing sore" of the cost of living.

Historical precedent would suggest things don't exactly look encouraging for Macron's chances of success, says Ben Hall in the Financial Times. A similar call for public consultation by Louis XVI in 1789, rather than defusing public anger, simply increased the "spirit of insurrection", leading to the French Revolution. Macron runs the risk of similarly fanning the flames.

The range of topics up for discussion is "absurdly broad", and Macron has made it clear that he will not revisit tax decisions taken in the past 20 months, including the scrapping of the wealth tax, "the number one beef of many gilets jaunes". The theory is that the exercise will channel public frustration in more productive directions. It's more likely to "prove a waste of time that only breeds public cynicism".

Violence getting out of hand

Indeed, many experts are comparing the current protests "to the atmosphere of the 1930s, when fascistic leagues threatened France's democracy and marched on the National Assembly". The current situation, Macron told the mayors at his first event, presents the country with a lot of challenges. "That was something of an understatement."

Recommended

How the Covid-19 vaccine crisis is putting the EU in danger
EU Economy

How the Covid-19 vaccine crisis is putting the EU in danger

The botched coronavirus vaccine campaign will cause long-term harm to the EU's economy, says Matthew Lynn.
4 Apr 2021
How the vaccine wars will harm us all
Global Economy

How the vaccine wars will harm us all

Grabbing and hoarding vaccine supplies, or even manufacturing one’s own, might seem to make sense for a state in an emergency. But the damage done to …
27 Mar 2021
The European Central Bank fumbles its way towards yield curve control
EU Economy

The European Central Bank fumbles its way towards yield curve control

The EU’s economic recovery is faltering, but its bond yields keep rising. That makes things tricky for the European Central Bank, says John Stepek. He…
12 Mar 2021
Vexing vaccine delays hit drug firms
Biotech stocks

Vexing vaccine delays hit drug firms

AstraZeneca and Pfizer are being attacked by the EU over what it claims are delays in delivering the Covid vaccine.
28 Jan 2021

Most Popular

Lab-grown meat: how “moo’s law” will drive innovation
Soft commodities

Lab-grown meat: how “moo’s law” will drive innovation

Jim Mellon and Anthony Chow, co-founders of Aim-listed Agronomics, explain why they believe that “cellular agriculture” will benefit from massive long…
16 Apr 2021
The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it
Bitcoin

The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it

The cryptocurrency’s price has soared far beyond its fundamentals, says Matthew Partridge. Here, he looks at how to short bitcoin.
12 Apr 2021
Lab-grown meat: the new agricultural revolution
Soft commodities

Lab-grown meat: the new agricultural revolution

Vegan alternatives are taking off, but the future of food technology lies in lab-grown meat – cultivating steaks and burgers from animal cells, says A…
16 Apr 2021