In the future, no one will own a car. Here’s why and what it means for investors

Sales of new cars are plummeting. If Dominic Frisby’s experience is anything to go by, that’s no surprise. Soon, nobody will ever need to own a car again. Here’s why.


Zipcar one of the many new ways to get around by car
(Image credit: 2006 Getty Images)

Car sales in Germany slumped by 30.5% compared to the same month last year, I read this morning on Twitter.

Worryingly for the German giants, Audi was down 77.7%, Porsche 75.5% and Volkswagen 61.9%.

If my own experience is anything to go by, further falls lie ahead.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE

Get 6 issues free

Sign up to Money Morning

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter

Sign up

I'm getting more and more interested in the future of urban transport systems, as the asset-light generation Generation Rent, the generation which prizes experience over material things, and does not want the hassle of ownership comes into prominence.

I got a little taster at the weekend of what lies ahead.

You really don't need to own a car anymore

Let's start with a little bit of back story.

I acquired my first car in 1987, when, as a sprightly lad of 17, I passed my driving test at the second attempt. My mum gave me her car so she could buy a new one.

During the 2000s, however, the costs of owning a car began to nag away at me. There were the constant incidental payments parking, insurance, fines.

And then there was the fact that whenever I bought a car, the Parker's or Glass's guides always seemed to suggest that the value of the car was below what I was having to pay; yet whenever I sold, those same guides always suggested it was worth more than the price for which I was able to sell.

I was also always conscious of the stat maybe an urban myth that you could get taxis for every journey you make in a car and, over the course of a year, it would still work out cheaper.

Meanwhile, as I got older (and was working out of town less and less) I was using the car less and less. The value it offered seemed to be constantly shrinking.

The last car I owned a beautiful Mercedes convertible, don't you know I ended up leasing, and when the lease ran out, I didn't get round to leasing another straight away.

In the meantime, I started using Uber. This is rather convenient, I thought. I began sending Uber to pick up my kids. The 20-minute drive to get a son from footy or a daughter from friends, the waiting in between, and the 20-minute drive back meant I kept losing large chunks of my day.

Uber got me the time back. I could track exactly where they were and who was driving them at any given moment, so safety was not an issue. Over the course of a year, it worked out cheaper.

When I needed a car myself, I could use the Zipcar parked opposite my house, or I could schlepp over to the car hire place and rent one. So I never got another car.

This schlepp started to get on my nerves, however. The nearest car hire outlet is about two or three miles away; they only come and pick you up when they're not busy; the admin always seems to take an age; there were often queues; you had to go through the same rigmarole when you returned the car; and you were limited by their opening hours.

The other day I had to drive to Leicester and back. To avoid the car hire place, I used Zipcar, but then I got hit with a large charge because I went so far over their (to be fair, clearly stated) 60-mile-a-day limit. That irritated me.

I quite like Zipcar, but it's designed for short-term, short-distance hire. There has to be something better, I thought, a way of hiring a car for a longer-distance drive over , say, a weekend that doesn't necessitate me having to go the car hire place. But I never seemed to be able to find anything. (I know I am massively behind the curve on this.)

However, this weekend I had to drive to Devon, so I searched again. This time an ad for a company called Drivy popped up.

My experience with AirBnB for cars

This looks interesting, I thought. It's basically AirBnB for cars a peer-to-peer, car-hire platform. If you own a car, but perhaps don't use it all the time, you can put it up for hire through the Drivy platform. There are all the vetting procedures you would expect, plus there is a user-review system that ensures high standards.

To my surprise, there were all sorts of cars advertised within half a mile of my house, all available at short notice. I only skim read the list, but I noticed a BMW 5 series and a Fiat 500 so there's a good range, from big to small. I went for a Kia Optima Sportswagon, because it seemed cheap (£105 for three days), was parked only about ten minutes' walk away, and I'd never driven a Kia before.

I registered with the site, was approved and booked the car within a few minutes. I was able to start the hire at 11:30 at night, which I liked (I wanted to have the car parked outside my house and be able to leave at the crack of dawn the next day).

Just before the hire, I got a notification from the Drivy app. It linked to both Google and Apple Maps, so I was able to find the car easily, parked up a side road. The app on my phone opened the car. The keys were inside. I was then instructed to photograph the car inside and out and the app uploaded the photos to HQ. This took no more than a minute, and I was good to go.

The car had only done 9,500 miles. It was immaculately presented. It drove beautifully and economically. I am now a Kia fan, and would buy one were it not for the fact that I have no intention of ever buying a car again.

Three days later I returned the car once again at 11:30 at night. You had to return the car with the same amount of fuel as you took it (or pay the difference) and you had to return the car in a presentable state (or pay a cleaning fee). I did both, drove the car back where I had found it, photographed the outside, uploaded the photos, left the keys inside, hit "end rental" on the app and the car automatically locked.

Shortly after, an email arrived telling me that I had checked out successfully. I was also sent an adjustment bill as I had gone over the 100-mile-a-day limit (17p a mile about a third less than Zipcar, which also has a lower daily limit). All-in-all it was a lot more convenient than the car hire place.

What does this mean for the future of driving?

There are several takeaways from this. First, I now feel even less need to buy a car than I did. Others will feel the same way. This is another step forward for the so-called sharing economy. (When cars go driverless, even fewer people will buy.) Car ownership, especially in cities, will continue to fall.

Second, if you do own a car, but don't use it all the time, then you should sign it up to a peer-to-peer car hire company (Drivy is not the only one) and get it working for you. If I had a forecourt of some kind, and was that way inclined, I would buy several vehicles and sign them all up.

I've no doubt we will see many people doing this as they wake up to the opportunity. The platform has created opportunities for ordinary inclusion in the car rental business.

Finally, peer-to-peer car hire companies (for example, EasyCar, Drivy, Turo, Hiyacar) are, surely, going to do to traditional car hire firms what AirBnB has done to the hotel business. It's one of those transformations, I guess, that will be gradual, then sudden.

Enterprise (which also owns Alamo and National) is privately owned, but Hertz (NYSE: HTZ), which also owns Dollar Thrifty, and Avis (NYSE: CAR) cool ticker! are both listed. I would not want to own either in my portfolio. Longer-term, they are probably a short. If peer-to-peer car hire can get in on the airport game, they almost certainly are.

Dominic Frisby

Dominic Frisby (“mercurially witty” – the Spectator) is, we think, the world’s only financial writer and comedian. He is the author of the popular newsletter the Flying Frisby and is MoneyWeek’s main commentator on gold, commodities, currencies and cryptocurrencies. 

His books are Daylight Robbery - How Tax Changed our Past and Will Shape our Future; Bitcoin: the Future of Money? and Life After the State - Why We Don't Need Government. 

Dominic was educated at St Paul's School, Manchester University and the Webber-Douglas Academy Of Dramatic Art. You can follow him on X @dominicfrisby