Jewellery baron Nirav Modi has become caught up in what may be the subcontinent’s biggest-ever financial scandal. It’s a huge fall from grace for a man who wanted to take on Cartier and Tiffany. Jane Lewis reports.
Nirav Modi: "India's most celebrated jewellery baron"
(Image credit: 2018 Hindustan Times)
Over the past decade, Nirav Modi has become "India's most celebrated jewellery baron", says the Financial Times. His creations are favoured by Hollywood and Bollywood stars and the super-rich. "He was among an elite group of Indian business leaders who joined prime minister Narendra Modi [no relation] at last month's World Economic Forum in Davos." So it was a huge shock to India's establishment when his name was dragged into allegations of a fraud totalling up to $1.8bn at the Punjab National Bank (PNB) shortly after hisDavos appearance.
Modi has yet to be charged and last month denied any wrongdoing, but investigators allege it was a family affair embroiling his wife, brother, uncle and "three firms in which they were partners". They claim that Modi and his uncle, Mehul Choksi, colluded with bent bank officials to create fake letters of undertaking (LoUs) to obtain unauthorised international loans (Choksi has also denied any wrongdoing, as have the officials allegedly implicated).
It's a serious blow to Modi's business although not directly implicated, his flagship gem-trading business, Firestar Diamond, has filed for bankruptcy in New York. It is also turning into an incipient banking crisis, says The Times of India. The plunge in PNB's shares, down by nearly 25% at one point, reflects concern about the health of India's second-largest state-run bank. But the fear of contagion "dozens of lenders have provided loans against the LoUs issued by PNB" sent the whole sector reeling. More broadly, worries about lax controls and high rates of corporate default have led many to wonder what other nasties may be lurking under the bonnets of Indian banks.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Two years ago, when he was still riding high, Modi, 48, outlined plans to build "Asia's first luxury brand" named Nirav Modi which would be up there with "Cartier and Tiffany". The ambition seemed lofty, but any backer might have reasoned that, as the scion of a family of gem experts, he was steeped in the business. Brought up in Antwerp the European centre of the diamond trade to an Indian migr family, Modi didn't plan to join the business. But after dropping out of his Japanese and finance studies at Wharton in the US, he was sent to Mumbai to learn the ropes from his maternal uncle, Choksi. In 1999, he set up his own firm, Firestar, to source rare diamonds quickly acquiring a string of international companies that got him into contract manufacturing.
The "soft-spoken and unassuming" Modi took advantage of the financial crisis to buy "rare diamonds at bargain prices", says The Times of India. He marked the launch of his jewellery design house with a necklace featuring a flawless 12-carat Golconda diamond, which Christie's put on the front cover of its catalogue. At his peak, Forbes put Modi's net wealth at $1.6bn.
Modi, believed to be in New York, has vigorously denied the allegations, maintaining that the "media frenzy" has "destroyed my brand" and restricted his ability to repay his debts, notes the BBC. The ruling BJP party, which came to power on an anti-corruption ticket, has distanced itself from the situation. But that hasn't stopped opposition politicians are making hay from the situation. They are now drawing parallels with another prominent businessman, Kingfisher's Vijay Mallya, who skipped the country in similar circumstances in 2016 (see page 3).
Sign up for MoneyWeek's newsletters
Get the latest financial news, insights and expert analysis from our award-winning MoneyWeek team, to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Jane writes profiles for MoneyWeek and is city editor of The Week. A former British Society of Magazine Editors editor of the year, she cut her teeth in journalism editing The Daily Telegraph’s Letters page and writing gossip for the London Evening Standard – while contributing to a kaleidoscopic range of business magazines including Personnel Today, Edge, Microscope, Computing, PC Business World, and Business & Finance.
She has edited corporate publications for accountants BDO, business psychologists YSC Consulting, and the law firm Stephenson Harwood – also enjoying a stint as a researcher for the due diligence department of a global risk advisory firm.
Her sole book to date, Stay or Go? (2016), rehearsed the arguments on both sides of the EU referendum.
She lives in north London, has a degree in modern history from Trinity College, Oxford, and is currently learning to play the drums.
Review: Eden Roc Cap Cana – fun, sun and golf in the Caribbean
Reeves delays cash ISA reform, but savers are not out of the woods yet
