The queen has money stashed away in secretive accounts in the Cayman Islands. Members of Donald Trump's cabinet have financial links to Russian oil interests. Your local football club turns out to be owned by a trust based somewhere with lots of palm trees, and your credit card is funded from a small island you have probably never heard of. Even Bono, the closest thing we have to a modern-day saint, has been caught up in the scandal.
The "Paradise Papers", a huge stash of offshore financial information leaked at the beginning of the week, have certainly prompted some lurid headlines, and created some red faces, not least at Buckingham Palace.And yet, along with a string of other massive leaks of offshore data, they don't actually reveal anything very much that is genuinely illegal. What they do show is something that should worry us all a lot more: that financial confidentiality is being destroyed.
When every piece of data is routinely stored online, and those computers connected to the internet, any kind of account can be hacked into, or the data transferred to a simple USB stick, and then published online for anyone to take a look at. We should be very careful about allowing that. People have a right to privacy in their financial affairs as much as in any other aspect of their lives. There are perfectly legitimate reasons for individuals or companies to keep bank accounts private.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Such as? They may have family members or spouses to placate. Parents don't always want their offspring to know exactly how much money they are giving to anyone else, and wives might want to keep some financial details secret from their partners, and vice versa. Companies might choose to have an offshore subsidiary because they don't want to reveal the details of their finances to their rivals. Or they might want to keep information back from employees or suppliers. Those are all good reasons why bank accounts are kept confidential.
With the Paradise Papers, so far as we can tell at the moment, someone took vast quantities of data estimated at 13.4 million records from the law firm Appleby and handed it over to the German newspaper Sddeutsche Zeitung, which then shared it with papers around the world. That sounds like theft of private information. When the "Panama Papers" were leaked to the same organisation last year, the source was an anonymous individual who claimed he or she was fighting global inequality. A disgruntled employee? A lone hacker? A former client? We have, as yet, no way of knowing.
Sure, if people are money laundering or evading taxes they should be exposed, and they should be punished if guilty. But we seem to be creating a culture in which it is viewed as perfectly acceptable to hack into private bank accounts and put everyone's details on the web. It is not likely to stop at offshore accounts either. Once we get used to the annual round of leaks, it won't be long before banks, fund managers and financial advisers in this country find details of their clients are leaked and posted online as well.
Confidentiality had a purpose. It allowed people to manage their affairs in private, to handle tricky situations, and to talk candidly to their bankers, brokers and advisers. A few organisations have decided that every financial deal should be exposed. In truth, banks and their clients may have to get used to that. Certainly anyone with an offshore account should, by now, expect details of it to be published either this year, or next. But we will miss that old-fashioned privacy more than we realise because without it far less will get done.
-
Christmas at Chatsworth: review of The Cavendish Hotel at BaslowMoneyWeek Travel Matthew Partridge gets into the festive spirit at The Cavendish Hotel at Baslow and the Christmas market at Chatsworth
-
Tycoon Truong My Lan on death row over world’s biggest bank fraudProperty tycoon Truong My Lan has been found guilty of a corruption scandal that dwarfs Malaysia’s 1MDB fraud and Sam Bankman-Fried’s crypto scam
-
The true price of paradiseFeatures The so-called Paradise Papers have highlighted the use of far-flung remnants of the British Empire as tax havens. The bargain tax rates are looking increasingly costly, says Simon Wilson.
-
Don't chase the super-rich for tax, just simplify the systemFeatures It might seem fair for HMRC to chase the super-rich. But if the tax system were simpler, they might be less inclined to go looking for loopholes.
-
The big government threat to big corporations – and small statesFeatures Apple's potential €13bn tax bill should sound a warning to investors, says John Stepek. Governments have finally worked out how to raid big multinationals' balance sheets.
-
Politicians’ tax returns: who pays whatFeatures The country’s most high-profile politicians have been falling over themselves to show off their earnings and the amount of tax they paid. Here’s who got what.
-
Time to duck: ‘government by headline’ is backFeatures David Cameron's dilemma over the Panama Papers is a symptom of our flawed tax regime. But it's what we're stuck with, says John Stepek. And it's going to get worse.
-
The billionaire banker battling corruption charges in BrazilProfiles Already charged with corruption in Brazil, the Panama Papers is just the latest scandal to implicate Brazilian billionaire banker Joseph Safra.
-
Tax dodge scandal claims first scalp in Iceland's prime ministerFeatures Icelandic prime minister Sigmundur Gunnlaugsson has been the biggest casualty so far of the Panama Papers scandal, says Matthew Partridge.
-
The mood music doesn't favour tax simplicityEditor's letter Don't expect a simpler, more transparent tax system anytime soon, says John Stepek. Thankfully, there still remains plenty of scope for sensible tax planning.
