Trouble in store for Tesco?
Tesco is getting a good deal with its bid for wholesaler Booker. But regulators could yet block the merger, says Ben Judge
Tesco is getting a good deal with its bid for wholesaler Booker. But regulators could yet block the merger, says Ben Judge.
Last week, Tesco surprised investors with a £3.7bn bid for Booker, which is Britain's biggest wholesale food distributor and also owns the Makro cash-and-carry and the Budgens and Londis chains of shops. The deal represents "a massive bet on post-Brexit Britain and the UK consumer" by Tesco, says Allister Heath in the Daily Telegraph.
Tesco has retrenched from unprofitable overseas ventures and is reshoring "vast amounts of cash" in a bid to become the "undisputed king" of the UK consumer market. By buying Booker, it could rationalise its operations, "freeing up unwanted property that could be turned into housing", while transforming Booker's systems, and increasing productivity.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Buying Booker is a "defensive but logical move" for Tesco, says the Financial Times' Lex column. Booker is a better business than Tesco. Its operating margins are almost twice as big and it "converts a greater proportion of that profit into cash". So the price that Tesco is paying looks reasonable the £175m of annual savings will "easily cover the premium being paid".
Quite, says Stephen Wilmot in The Wall Street Journal. That's why the deal is much sweeter for Tesco than for Booker's shareholders. In the past ten years, Booker turned £100 of investor cash into over £2,300. Tesco turned £100 into £67. "When you own a great company you deserve a great takeover premium." The mere 12% premium that Tesco is paying for Booker "looks too slim".
Nor is it obvious what Tesco adds to Booker's business, says Wilmot. Booker had organic growth of 5.1% excluding cigarette sales last quarter. Tesco had a meagre 1.5%. And as a supplier to caterers and restaurants, Booker benefits from the rising trend for eating out; supermarkets don't. You can argue Booker gets access to Tesco's purchasing power, but this is "where the risks lie", as competition authorities circle.
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), which regulates mergers in the UK, will almost certainly take an interest given Tesco's "already substantial negotiating power with its suppliers" and the fact that it "owns a range of convenience stores that compete with Booker's customers".
The CMA should wave the deal through, says Heath. Tesco will be able to harness its buying power to supply wholesale products to small retailers at lower prices, supply Booker's franchises with the tools to make them more efficient and offer better prices to customers. The outcome will be to "enhance competition and efficiency".
Not likely, says Matthew Vincent in the Financial Times. Yes, supply chains and logistics will be merged, but overall "the value of the strategy is questionable". All Tesco is getting from this deal is "the ability to squeeze suppliers a little bit harder".
Sign up to Money Morning
Our team, led by award winning editors, is dedicated to delivering you the top news, analysis, and guides to help you manage your money, grow your investments and build wealth.
Ben studied modern languages at London University's Queen Mary College. After dabbling unhappily in local government finance for a while, he went to work for The Scotsman newspaper in Edinburgh. The launch of the paper's website, scotsman.com, in the early years of the dotcom craze, saw Ben move online to manage the Business and Motors channels before becoming deputy editor with responsibility for all aspects of online production for The Scotsman, Scotland on Sunday and the Edinburgh Evening News websites, along with the papers' Edinburgh Festivals website.
Ben joined MoneyWeek as website editor in 2008, just as the Great Financial Crisis was brewing. He has written extensively for the website and magazine, with a particular emphasis on alternative finance and fintech, including blockchain and bitcoin.
As an early adopter of bitcoin, Ben bought when the price was under $200, but went on to spend it all on foolish fripperies.
-
How to invest in nuclear power
We need nuclear power to go green, says Dominic Frisby. But there is a better option than huge power stations
By Dominic Frisby Published
-
Chase slashes its easy-access savings rate – is it time to switch?
The Chase easy-access savings account has proved popular with savers thanks to its competitive rate and bonus deals. But, as the rate has dropped, has it lost its charm?
By Katie Williams Published
-
How to profit from rising food prices: which stocks should you invest in?
Tips Food prices are rising – we look at the stocks to avoid and the one to invest in this sector.
By Bruce Packard Published
-
Tesco looks well-placed to ride out the cost of living crisis – investors take note
Analysis Surging inflation is bad news for retailers. But supermarket giant Tesco looks better placed to cope than most, says Rupert Hargreaves.
By Rupert Hargreaves Published
-
Tesco sells its retail subsidiary in Thailand and Malaysia for £8bn
News Tesco has agreed to sell its southeast Asian operations to Thai conglomerate Charoen Pokphand for £8.2bn in cash.
By Dr Matthew Partridge Published
-
Tesco should keep its Asian assets
Opinion The £7bn that Tesco could get for its Tesco Lotus business in Asia looks enticing. But holding on to it would be smarter, says Matthew Lynn.
By Matthew Lynn Published
-
Tesco cashes out of the mortgage business
Features Tesco Bank has left the mortgage market by selling its £3.7bn loan book. Its 23,000 customers will be moved to the Halifax, a subsidiary of Lloyds.
By Dr Matthew Partridge Published
-
Share tips of the week
Features MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
By moneyweek Published
-
Tesco wields the axe
Features Britain’s biggest supermarket is cutting back on staff and fresh food. Will the move prove counterproductive? Matthew Partridge reports.
By Dr Matthew Partridge Published
-
If you'd invested in: Tesco and Associated British Foods
Features Tesco has seen its market value rise almost 50% in a year, while AB Foods has seen shares slide despite a rise in profits.
By Alice Gråhns Published