Over the last couple of weeks, the Chinese markets have been under severe pressure. They may have recovered some lost ground recently, but the outlook remains cloudy.
Now you might remember that nearly a year ago, I singled out one company as the bellwether stock for China'.
The stock is, of course, China Cinda Asset Management (1359 HK), the largest state-controlled asset management company in terms of assets, revenue, net profit and market share. With 31 branches nationwide, the company's business is in buying up distressed assets, repackaging them, and flogging them at a higher price.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
In 2014, distressed assets contributed over 60% of China Cinda's total revenues. The company also has investments in non-distressed assets.
Prior to the initial public offering (IPO) in December 2013, prominent Western financial institutions, including banks, sovereign wealth funds and hedge funds, took strategic stakes in the company. These include Norwegian central bank Norges Bank (the oil fund), hedge funds such as Farallon Capital Management, Oak Tree Capital Group, and Och-Ziff Capital.
I thought that if they remained invested after Cinda's lock-up period expired in December 2014, it would be a sign that the smart money' was bullish about making money in China.
As far as I can tell, they have kept their stakes. However, the yield on their investment has been paltry.
The stock is down 10% since I featured it, and up a mere 6% since flotation. Most tellingly, it dipped below the IPO price during the market turmoil.
I think the inadequate performance can be attributed to four factors.
Four problems facing China Cinda
1. Chinese government intervening in the market
2. Foreign banks have been trimming their holdings
3. A new share issuance has been planned
4. More competitors are coming into the market
Overall, I question the rationale of investing in distressed asset management companies operating in a command economy.
For comparison, the investment case was easier after the Asian financial crisis of 1997-98. Thailand and South Korea allowed assets to be re-priced lower, paving the way for distressed asset buyers to buy cheaply and sell (more) expensively.
However, there are alternative ways to play a bearish China outlook. One attractive route is through a pawnbroker.
Three pawnbrokers that might be worth looking at
I mentioned three stocks: Oi Wah Pawnshop Credit Holdings, Maxi-Cash Financial Services Corp and Srisawad Power Public Company. Since I mentioned them, Oi Wah and Srisawad have risen 47% and 27% respectively. Maxi-Cash, meanwhile, has fallen 22%.
While not directly focused on China, I believe Oi Wah Pawnshop (1319 HK), which operates 12 pawnshops, a pawn loan service and mortgage loan service centre, looks interesting.
In the second quarter of 2015, Oi Wah reported revenue and net profit of about HK$146.5m and HK$80.1m an increase on 52.9% and 95.0% respectively.
According to Bloomberg, there are two research houses covering the stock, pegging the fair value to HK$3.50 equivalent to a 63% upside.
I have no idea whether that is feasible. However, it seems that some believe that it could work. For instance, Value Partners, a 20-year veteran value investor in Greater China, has recently accumulated a 6.3% stake. An opportunity to keep an eye on, anyway.
Lars is our resident emerging markets expert, with 17 years of 'on the ground' experience hunting down profit opportunities in Asia.
Lars spent ten years living in Malaysia and Thailand, seeking out strategic opportunities, before moving to London to manage the Oracle Asia Absolute Fund.
In short, Lars has real knowledge of where the opportunities in Asia are. Sign up to his free newsletter, The New World, here.
Stocks and shares ISAs beat cash ISAs despite rising interest rates
Exclusive analysis for MoneyWeek shows that the stock market beat cash ISAs last year - and when inflation is factored in, cash savers actually made a loss. We run through the figures.
By Ruth Emery Published
Waspi women: could they get £10,000 compensation under new bill?
Many women born in the 1950s got a raw deal due to the rising state pension age. The “Waspi” campaign group has been lobbying for compensation for years - we outline the journey so far, and whether they might finally receive some money.
By Ruth Emery Published