Are any of the world's so-called great investors' actually any good? asks US money manager Bill Gross.
In his latest investment outlook, he questions the track records of some of the biggest namesin investing, such as Warren Buffett and George Soros. But the co-founder of Pimco, the world's biggest bond fund, isn't just trying to put down the competition he also calls his own record into question.
68-year-old Gross, whose success has earned him the nickname the Bond King', reckons that he and his peers may just have been lucky.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
"There is not a Bond King or a Stock King or an Investor Sovereign alive that can claim title to a throne. All of us, even the old guys like Buffett, Soros, Fuss, yeah, me too - have cut our teeth during perhaps the most advantageous period of alltime, the most attractive epoch, that an investor could experience", admits Gross.
"Since the early 1970s when the dollar was released from gold and credit began its incredible, liquefying, total return journey to the present day, an investor that took marginal risk, levered it wisely and was conveniently sheltered from periodic bouts of deleveraging or asset withdrawals could, and in some cases, was rewarded with the crown of greatness'."
So the usual measures of investing success are actually far too short-term, says Gross. "The standard analysis tends to judge an investor or his firm on the basis of how the bullish or bearish aspects of the cycle were managed." But really you would need to judge an investor on a much longer time frame.
"Pimco's epoch, Berkshire Hathaway's epoch, Peter Lynch's epoch, all occurred or have occurred within an epoch of credit expansion", says Gross. Now there are signs that the epoch may be changing.
Ageing populations, climate change and resource scarcity could well herald a new era of investing. One which plays with different rules.
The 30 or 40-year track records feted today may seem impressive, but they are not enough to show true 'greatness'. That could only be measured by judging an investor's ability to make money in different epochs.
Unfortunately, we'll probably never find out how the great investors of the last 40 years would fare in different circumstances, as "epochs can and likely will outlast them".
-
Widow’s warning: Are you missing out on up to £11,000 in inherited state pension?If your late spouse built up contributions under the old state pension, you could be entitled to inherit a portion of it. What are the rules and are you eligible?
-
How much should I have in savings? Average savings by ageWe look at how much you should aim to have in your savings at every decade of your life, and how you can go about achieving this.
-
How Warren Buffett built his fortuneAnalysis Warren Buffett is considered by many to be the best investor of all time. We examine how much Buffett is worth and how he made his fortune.
-
Why investment forecasting is futileOpinion Every year events prove that forecasting is futile and 2020 was no exception, says Bill Miller, chairman and chief investment officer of Miller Value Partners.
-
Warren Buffett: investors should ignore scary headlinesOpinion You wouldn’t buy or sell your own business on the back of today's headlines, sasy Warren Buffett, so why sell shares in good firms?
-
The world’s greatest investors: Francisco García ParamésTutorials Spanish value investor Francisco García Paramés has enjoyed annualised returns of 16% over 25 years.
-
The world’s greatest investors: Cheah Cheng HyeFeatures Cheah Cheng Hye – dubbed “Goldfinger” and the “Asian Warren Buffett” – is the co-founder and chairman of Hong Kong-based Value Partners Group.
-
Thomas Russo: the world’s greatest investorsFeatures A focus on long-term compounding became the core of Thomas Russo’s investment strategy.
-
Charlie Munger: the world’s greatest investorsFeatures Charlie Munger was originally a value investor, buying companies that were trading below their book value.
-
Paul Samuelson: the world’s greatest investorsFeatures Paul Samuelson was one of the key people involved in the development of the efficient market hypothesis.
