Imagine you are the head of the European Central Bank (ECB).
Most of the European Union is in a deep recession, with many people out of work. Berlin is trying to get everyone to stick to tough fiscal rules, which may make things worse. Citizens are protesting, or even rioting, about austerity.
Bond markets are starting to worry that a default in the Spain, or Portugal, or Greece is inevitable. This in turn causes the cost of new borrowing to rise, making the fiscal positions of these countries even worse.
Start your trial of MoneyWeek today
Get unparalleled financial insight, analysis and expert opinion you can profit from.
Start your trial
Sign up for MoneyWeek’s free twice-daily newsletter.
Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
So you'd think that cutting interest rates would be a no-brainer for the ECB.
Latest Videos FromMoneyWeek
Instead, the head of the ECB, Mario Draghi, chose to keep rates at 1% yesterday. Not only that, he also threw cold water on the idea that the ECB could begin another round of either quantitative easing (QE) or LTRO (Long-Term Refinancing Operations) in the near term.
Instead he thinks that, "the full supportive impact of the euro-system's non-standard measures will need time to unfold".
Here's what his decision reveals about the ECB's thinking and what it means for the euro's future.
The ECB is in denial about growth
Draghi is much more upbeat than most experts. He expects "the euro area economy to recover gradually in the course of the year".
Indeed, if you read his speech he almost seems more concerned with inflation than a lack of growth. He also hints that the ECB is looking to a time when QE can be unwound a sign of confidence.
In contrast, forecasters such as Capital Economics believe that things are grim and will get worse. Not only do they think that euro-area GDP will shrink by 1% this year, but also they expect it to fall by another 2.5% in 2013.
You might argue that Draghi is also trying to boost confidence by talking up the economy. However, given that the ECB's thoughts on future economic growth are closely watched by European finance ministers, it will also reduce the pressure on them to rethink certain policies, such as the fiscal pact.
In other words, Draghi's view throws the ECB's weight behind those calling for austerity, rather than those who want to see the larger countries stepping in to bail out the troubled ones.
This is not necessarily all bad. Indeed, it is hard to argue with his call for "decisive structural reforms". As Draghi puts it, "policies aimed at enhancing competition in product markets and increasing the wage and employment adjustment capacity of firms will foster innovation, promote job creation and boost longer-term growth prospects".
However, the impact of continued cuts and ECB inaction will have much more impact, in the short and medium term, than any boost delivered by economic reform. The crisis also risks helping extremists of both left and right. Indeed, on Sunday, French voters have a choice between Nicolas Sarkozy, who has tried to pander to Marine Le Pen's National Front, and Franois Hollande, who promises to bring in penal tax rates and repeal pension reforms.
The only way to meet both the needs of bond markets and the wider public is to take measures to increase the money supply. However, the ECB still refuses to do this, hoping that the economy will recover on its own.
You can understand why. The politics of the eurozone make it very hard for the ECB to take any action. But realistically, the ECB is the only one with the power to keep the zone intact in its current form (at least until the next crisis).
The euro endgame could play out in a number of ways, from the exit of the peripheral countries to a complete disintegration (Fitch has produced a paper on this topic). But if Draghi sticks to his current course, the process will take place much sooner than most people think.
