How the private sector works to help the public sector spend our money badly

Eight years ago you could buy what is known as a “Scottish Executive” ticket from Edinburgh to London for £199. This sounds expensive, but it was actually a pretty good way to travel. For your £199 you got a completely flexible first-class return ticket, free parking at the station and travel inside zones 1 and 2 when you got to London.

I used it a lot (paying, by the way, with my own money!). Then the price started to go up – to £220, then to £250 and then early this year (with no notice at all) to a staggering £329. It is still cheaper (just) than a first anytime return, but nonetheless this is quite a big jump.

Now here’s the thing. I don’t have a particular problem with the price rise in itself. Relative to other fares the Scottish Executive was always oddly cheap (at one point booking it the day before travel was quite a lot cheaper than booking a standard return the day before travel). What I do have a problem with is who I think who uses the ticket.

There is something odd about the Scottish Executive. It isn’t sold as a first-class ticket. Go into the Virgin Trains East Coast website and look for a first-class return from Edinburgh to London and you won’t find it. There’s no £329 fare available. But look for a standard ticket instead – and there it is. You see, the Scottish Executive counts as a standard class ticket which includes a “first class upgrade.” Why? I think you know why.

It is so that anyone who works for an organisation that isn’t particularly price sensitive (by virtue of having only other people’s money to spend) but which, for reputational reasons, can’t be seen to be paying for first-class tickets, can travel first class while brandishing (and handing in as expenses) a ticket that says standard class. It doesn’t matter how expensive Virgin make this ticket, people will still buy it.

How many public-sector workers use the ticket? Judging by the people I chat to in busy first class carriages, an awful lot. Virgin doesn’t receive any official subsidies on the east coast line. But isn’t this really a subsidy in disguise?

After all, if Virgin made the Scottish Executive an official first-class ticket rather than a first-class ticket in disguise, anyone not supposed to be travelling first class would have to buy a standard ticket. Book two weeks in advance and that’ll save a hundred quid per person journey or so – and given the movement between London and Edinburgh every week it wouldn’t be long before that added up to real money.

You could even save money by actually allowing public sector workers to travel first class: if they booked specific trains and did so well in advance they could get a first-class return ticket for well under £200.

You will think I am making a fuss about not very much. Maybe I am. But to me this is just one more example among the many millions (you’ll all have your own) that show us first how horribly inefficiently the public sector spends our money, and second how very, very willing the private sector is to help them do so.

  • A Frith

    Why do we assume that any public servant must necessarily be doing work that is so insignificant that his or her travel time can be spent unproductively in Second Class rather than taking advantage of the quiet and more comfortable conditions of First?
    Any officer whose job requires them to travel regularly the length of the country is presumably in a senior and responsible role.
    Your rather prejudiced view of “public service” is that it is valueless to the community. My own experience is that the boundary between public and private sector is largely a bookkeeping exercise.
    The million or so former public servants transferred to the private sector, while still doing the same work, can be forgiven for thinking that they are still doing the same job despite what the accountants say.
    Sauce for the goose, you know.

    • Horiboyable .

      The state is a consumer of wealth, not a creator. The state produces nothing I wish to buy so it is insignificant. Those whom graft in the public service are a special breed of moocher.

    • M Somerset-webb

      I’m not making any assumptions on the value of work here. Simply pointing out that Virgin is gaming the system. And saying I don’t like that.


Claim 12 issues of MoneyWeek (plus much more) for just £12!

Let MoneyWeek show you how to profit, whatever the outcome of the upcoming general election.

Start your no-obligation trial today and get up to speed on:

  • The latest shifts in the economy…
  • The ongoing Brexit negotiations…
  • The new tax rules…
  • Trump’s protectionist policies…

Plus lots more.

We’ll show you what it all means for your money.

Plus, the moment you begin your trial, we’ll rush you over THREE free investment reports:

‘How to escape the most hated tax in Britain’: Inheritance tax hits many unsuspecting families. Our report tells how to pass on up to £2m of your money to your family without the taxman getting a look in.

‘How to profit from a Trump presidency’: The election of Donald Trump was a watershed moment for the US economy. This report details the sectors our analysts think will boom from Trump’s premiership, and gives specific investments you can buy to profit.

‘Best shares to watch in 2017’: Includes the transcript from our roundtable panel of investment professionals – and 12 tips they’re currently tipping. The report also analyses key assets, including property, oil and the countries whose stock markets currently offer the most value.