Why did the EUR/USD fall hard last week?

Conventional analysis will tell you that the European Central Bank (ECB) rate cut, the US GDP number on Thursday and the jobs data on Friday ‘surprised’ the market and lifted the dollar.

Of course, you can read much more detailed and involved commentary around this theme, but that will be the basic ‘explanation’ for the sharp fall in the euro.

As you must know by now, I have a totally different take on the markets than that provided by most pundits.

The problem with the conventional analysis is that it is ‘post facto’. This means that it is a rationalisation for a move that has already happened.

The question traders must therefore ask is this: can this help me make profits, or am I wasting my time reading such material? In other words, can reading about markets after the event help me take a position ahead of it?

This is, in fact, nonsense unless you possess a time machine. Otherwise, the move is over and you are still left without a profit.

What we all need as traders is a way of positioning in advance of such moves and thereby making those profits.

And that is where my methods can help – and in this case, the Elliott wave model can really help.

Following the roadmap

On 4 November, I showed how the turn at the 1.38 level satisfied all of my requirements for a major turn and that the most likely path was down. This was, of course, contra to the majority opinion.

This was the Elliott wave count on the hourly chart I had working then:

EUR/USD spread betting chart

The very sharp down move on 31 October was entirely in keeping with a third wave because it was long and strong, with few green bars and many red ones.

Also, momentum readings reached very low levels, proving the strength of selling.

This was my first sign that the trend had likely changed. To clinch it, I needed to see five impulsive waves down.

When I took the chart, this third wave was probably ending there at the 62% Fibonacci retrace level. And a wave 4 up was likely before a resumption of the downtrend into wave 5.

That wave 4, if it materialised, would have been an excellent place to enter a low-risk short trade.

That was my roadmap.

Let’s see how that panned out:

EUR/USD spread betting chart

How about that? My wave 3 did terminate at the Fibonacci 62% retrace, and I did get my wave 4 up – and then a new low in wave 5 on Friday after the jobs data. That was what I was looking for.

The answer I was looking for

So that answered my question: the euro fell hard because it had to complete the fifth wave of a five-wave sequence – and you could have followed it all the way down as it obeyed all of the Elliott rules (especially the A-B-C in wave 4).

This is about as textbook as you will see – and one reason, incidentally, why I love trading the EUR/USD. It displays excellent Elliott waves, tramlines and Fibonaccis.

I recommend all traders take a serious look at trading this market above all else.

Also note the textbook A-B-C pattern in wave 4 – again, indicating the immediate trend is down, and giving added confidence for a short trade:

EUR/USD spread betting chart

And wave 4 terminated at the Fibonacci 23% retrace of waves 1-to-3 – another great place to enter a short trade.

Knowing when to go against the tide

So already, a trader had several excellent low-risk opportunities to position correctly in the right direction.

But of course, most traders have been very bullish the euro lately. If you were in that herd, you would have been caught out, sadly. But it didn’t have to be!

By reading the signs that I have written about, you would have exited any long trades and then positioned short.

I find most novice (and not so novice) traders cling to a view for way too long. Yes, being bullish the euro was correct since July. But back then, this was a minority opinion! In the summer, there was much chatter about the eurozone breaking up and sentiment was very bearish.

It took courage to go against that story.

How sentiment drives the market

But this month, the talk is of the survival of the eurozone (it is ‘turning the corner’). And the dollar is getting a bad press partly because of government shut-downs and debt ceiling worries.

Naturally, this set the scene for a resurgence in the dollar!

EUR/USD spread betting chart

This is how sentiment drives markets. Sentiment extremes in the euro have produced these major turns.

When the EUR/USD trades much lower, I am sure stories of the doomed euro will re-surface.

Now with the US government back at work, I can now access the latest commitments of traders (COT) data:

Non-commercial Commercial Total Non-reportable positions
long short spreads long short long short long short
(Contracts of EUR 125,000) Open interest: 252,554
103,333 70,190 6,975 93,269 124,922 203,577 202,087 48,977 50,467
Changes from 10/29/13 (Change in open interest: -30,369)
-32,721 4,753 1,167 5,807 -31,418 -25,747 -25,498 -4,622 -4,871
Percent of open in terest for each category of traders
40.9 27.8 2.8 36.9 49.5 80.6 80.0 19.4 20.0
Number of traders in each category (Total traders: 186)
44 62 24 51 54 109 126


The hedge funds (non-commercials) are still net long, but reduced their longs by a whopping amount in the previous week. I guess they didn’t like the 300-pip hit that week!

But now, with a chunk of the long positions removed, the market is more evenly balanced.

With my five waves down on the hourly chart, I expect some sort of a bounce. This is especially true, now that the decline has hit the Fibonacci 50% retrace on the nose, and is entering a chart congestion zone (see last Wednesday’s post):

EUR/USD spread betting chart

If I do get my bounce, I will be on the lookout for new tramlines and trading off these.