Why house deposits and pensions don’t mix

First-time buyers should not be able to raid their pension savings to pay for a house deposit.

Should first-time buyers be able to access their pension savings in order to get on the property ladder? Pension industry experts say no, despite pensions minister Guy Opperman this month floating the idea of a product allowing savers to use their pensions to help finance a deposit on a first home.

Opperman points to countries such as New Zealand and the US, where retirement savings can be used in this way in certain circumstances. The idea has superficial appeal: young savers are often frustrated that despite having several thousand pounds in their pension funds, they can’t raise the money for a deposit. 

However, the evidence suggests that if people do raid their pensions in this way, they rarely manage to make up for the shortfall over time. More fundamentally, enabling access to pension funds does nothing to improve housing supply – first-time buyers may simply find that prices just become ever more unaffordable.

Opperman also appears to be unaware of lifetime individual savings accounts (Lisas), the scheme introduced in April 2017. These enable savers to put money by, with an additional bonus from the government, that has to be used either for a house purchase or as pension savings. Lisas therefore combine saving for a property and for old age – but have so far proved relatively unpopular.

Recommended

Stamp duty holiday extension will keep the house-price party going – for now
Property

Stamp duty holiday extension will keep the house-price party going – for now

The government is to extend to the stamp duty holiday by three months. Good for today’s buyers, says Nicole Garcia Merida, but what happens in June?
26 Feb 2021
Properties for sale with detached home offices
Houses for sale

Properties for sale with detached home offices

From a contemporary duplex apartment in a period property in Fulham, London, to a brick-and-flint house close to Marlow high street, Buckinghamshire, …
26 Feb 2021
How to get the best deal from your pension drawdown
Pensions

How to get the best deal from your pension drawdown

If you're thinking of taking out a pension drawdown plan on reaching retirement, don't just rely on the Money Advice Service’s price-comparison tool.
23 Feb 2021
Pandemic no barrier as house prices rise faster than at any time since 2014
House prices

Pandemic no barrier as house prices rise faster than at any time since 2014

December saw the biggest annual rise in house prices for over seven years, as buyers rushed into the market to be sure of completion before the end of…
19 Feb 2021

Most Popular

The days when you could get 7% from your bank are long gone – so what do you do?
Bitcoin

The days when you could get 7% from your bank are long gone – so what do you do?

With interest rates at rock bottom for so long, we’ve been forced to move from saving to speculating to earn any sort of return. Dominic Frisby asks w…
24 Feb 2021
Why you should still put money into a cash Isa
Cash ISAs

Why you should still put money into a cash Isa

Interest rates may be lousy, but tax-free saving into a cash Isa is still a good idea.
23 Feb 2021
Are we heading for another bond market tantrum?
Government bonds

Are we heading for another bond market tantrum?

The last time the US central bank tried tightening the purse strings, the bond markets threw a tantrum. With yields now rising, could we be about to s…
25 Feb 2021