The media wakes up to the truth about pension fund deficits

The way pension funds are driven into low-yielding bonds in defiance of any sort of sense is finally making its way into the mainstream press.


Finally, finally one of our main bugbears is being picked up properly by the rest of the press.

We have been raging here for several years about the way that super-low interest rates affect defined-benefit pension fund deficits. The lower interest rates go, the deficits soar and the more money companies have to divert away from productive activity and towards the desperate effort to stop the sharp slide towards disaster.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

The result is panicky newspaper articles, hysterical trustees, low levels of investment in the real economy and lower productivity and wages than we would otherwise have. It is all bad for all of us.

The maddening thing about this is that, while it looks necessary, it isn't. Let's look at why deficits soar as rates fall and so why the problem looks so much worse even since our "Brennaisance" referendum (PwC data shows a rise in the collective deficit by £100bn in the month of August alone).

Advertisement - Article continues below

As Jonathan Ford points out in the FT today, the deficit numbers have "little to do with the health of a scheme or indeed the underlying covenant supplied by its sponsoring company. It reflects rather the mechanical effect of using risk free' yields to compute the present value of cash that will be paid out to pensioners over many decades."

The funds use government bonds yields as a proxy assumption for the returns they will make in the future. Every time yields fall, so does their return assumption and hence the amount of money they assume they will have in the future based on the value of the assets they have now. The natural conclusion? They must have more money.

But think about this and it is obviously silly. The gilt yield doesn't necessarily bear any relationship at all to the returns available on assets the pension funds already hold. And if the fund is capable of making an higher yield via a diversified portfolio (most can!) why should swings in gilt yields "require an immediate response" particularly given that low rates drive up the price of other assets?

The whole thing is madea million times worse by what we call "liability driven investment" where pension trustees are told to cut the risk in schemes by buying bonds to lock in safe income and hedge against interest rate falls. This is nuts, of course the lower bond yields go, the more of them the pension funds feel they must buy and the more ridiculous the whole thing gets.

The good news is that the ex-pension minister, Ros Altmann, sees the problem (see my last interview with her). We see it, Rob Cox sees it, and in the FT alone today two other people see it as well.

Royal London's CIO Piers Hillier is quoted as saying how nuts it is that the system pushes funds into low-yielding bonds when it should be steering them to high-yielding infrastructure. There are few pages in the paper too on the chief executive of AP7, the Swedish pension fund, lamenting the way that low interest rates are destroying pension funds and demanding that central banks change the way they make interest rate policy.

Advertisement - Article continues below

All this might sound technical and boring. But it is incredibly important (pension fund deficits destroy companies). So the fact that it is all finally getting some media traction is a very good thing.




How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019
Personal finance

Companies cut back on their pensions bills

Britvic is the latest firm hoping a cheaper inflation index will cut pension costs. David Prosser reports.
28 Aug 2019

Good news for pensions savers from HMRC

HMRC has withdrawn its appeal over breaches of the pensions lifetime allowance.
28 Jun 2019

Tinkering with the pensions tapering system

The problems caused by the annual pension contribution allowance have been partially addressed, says David Prosser.
24 Mar 2020

Most Popular


What does the coronavirus crisis mean for UK house prices?

With the whole country in lockdown, the UK property market is closed for business. John Stepek looks at what that means for UK house prices, housebuil…
27 Mar 2020
UK Economy

The UK’s bailout of the self employed comes with a hidden catch

The chancellor’s £6.5bn bailout of the self employed is welcome. But it has hidden benefits for the taxman, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
27 Mar 2020

Gold is hard to find right now – so should you be buying?

With demand through the roof and the physical metal hard to find, it's not the best time to buy gold. But right now, says Dominic Frisby, you want to …
25 Mar 2020
Share tips

Share tips of the week

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
27 Mar 2020