Merryn's Blog

Separatism: it can be good and it can be bad, but it is what it is

No matter what words you want to use, voting for an independent Scotland means separating from the rest of the UK.

Readers, help me out here. I used the word separatist' on Twitter todayto describe the Scots who intend to vote for independence in the referendum in September.

It's the word I usually use to describe them alongside unionist' for those who intend to vote against independence and for the union. One side wants to stay in the union and one side wants to separate from the rest of the union so they seem to me to be the best short had descriptive words for everyone's end goal.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

Today, however, a few people got really very cross. I was told that calling people separatists is a bit like calling them racists. I was told that it is an "inaccurate" word. That it is "unnecessarily emotive","highly charged", and "pejorative."

I don't get it. How can it be any of these things? Voting for independence is voting to leave the union. Nothing wrong with that (as long as you do it for emotional not economic reasons) but it does make separation a perfectly good word to use. So I pushed back on it.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

What's wrong with it, I asked. Finally one of my followers told me it was too hard to explain on Twitter.

Hmmm. A few months ago I wondered here why the SNP were making all this quite so complicated.Right now, Scotland is effectively a member of five unions: a union of the crown; a defence union (Nato); a monetary/currency union; the European Union; and a fiscal union.

If you listen to what the SNP say you will see that in the main they say want to keep the first four and only to turn the dial on the fifth (fiscal independence, as Mark Carney has made as clear as possible, is not possible without monetary independence). But that isn't really going to be possible post a yes vote (which I why I am pleased to see that a plan B to sterling is now being worked on).

So here's why I think that Scotland's separatists don't like being called separatists: the word makes it clear that voting yes doesn't mean voting for a tad more fiscal devolution (as I imagine the SNP might like the undecided to think), it means breaking or at least heavily negotiating to stay in most of the other unions. It means separation. Separating can be good and it can be bad, but it is what it is.

PS Regular readers will know that I am generally a unionist (hard not to be when you are born in Ireland, part educated in England and married to a Scot) but with occasional sympathies towards the romance of the separatists. But you can read my interview with the firmly separatist Angus Tulloch here.

PPS One person told me on Twitter this morning that they preferred to be called a civic nationalist'. This seems to me to be the political equivalent of the now famous phrase conscious uncoupling' a euphemism used to make what is actually happening seem rather less dramatic than it really is.

Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/516758/beyond-the-brexit-talk-the-british-economy-isnt-doing-too-badly
Economy

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
Visit/investments/property/house-prices/600638/uk-house-prices-may-be-heading-for-a-boris-bounce
House prices

UK house prices may be heading for a Boris bounce

The latest survey of estate agents and surveyors from the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors is "unambiguously positive" – suggesting house pric…
16 Jan 2020
Visit/520591/are-uk-house-prices-really-on-the-rebound
Property

Are UK house prices really on the rebound?

The latest house price data from the Office for National Statistics paint a picture of a housing market that is showing signs of rallying. That's not …
15 Jan 2020
Visit/520584/weak-inflation-data-may-gives-the-bank-of-england-an-excuse-to-cut-rates
Economy

Weak inflation data may gives the Bank of England an excuse to cut rates

UK inflation is edging lower, and is now well below the Bank of England’s 2% target rate. That could mean even lower interest rates. Here's why. 
15 Jan 2020

Most Popular

Visit/economy/600632/money-minute-friday-17-january-uk-weakness-likely-to-continue
Economy

Money Minute Friday 17 January: UK weakness likely to continue

Today's Money Minute previews UK retail sales figures the UK, inflation data from Europe and industrial production from the US.
17 Jan 2020
Visit/520525/currency-corner-how-high-can-the-pound-go-against-the-euro-in-2020
Currencies

Currency Corner: how high can the pound go against the euro in 2020?

In the month in which we should finally leave the European Union, Dominic Frisby takes a look at the pound vs the euro and asks just how high sterling…
13 Jan 2020
Visit/investments/property/house-prices/600638/uk-house-prices-may-be-heading-for-a-boris-bounce
House prices

UK house prices may be heading for a Boris bounce

The latest survey of estate agents and surveyors from the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors is "unambiguously positive" – suggesting house pric…
16 Jan 2020
Visit/investments/stocks-and-shares/share-tips/600636/class-acts-going-cheap-buy-into-europes-best
Share tips

Class acts going cheap: buy into Europe’s best bargains

Value investing appears to be making a comeback, while shares on this side of the Atlantic are more appealing on metrics such as price/earnings ratios…
16 Jan 2020