Merryn's Blog

Scottish independence – why so complicated?

The debate about Scottish independence is being made much more complicated than it actually is. And that’s making it hard to make a rational choice.

At a dinner last night to publicise the campaign to raise money for the new V&A in Dundee,I sat next to one of Scotland's best-known businessmen. We talked (inevitably) about independence.

He had an interesting take. He can't understand, he says, why the SNP insists on making the argument so very complicated.

Subscribe to MoneyWeek

Become a smarter, better informed investor with MoneyWeek.

At the moment Scotland is effectively a member of five unions. First, a union of the crown; second, a currency union; third a parliamentary union; fourth, a European union; and fifth, a defence union. Deconstruct the independence' plans and you will see that the SNP really only wants to fiddle with the third. So why not just say so?

This is really about very little other than controls over taxation and if you think of each union as a line with total separation at one end and togetherness at the other just how far you move your marker up and down the parliamentary line. It's already shifted significantly with devolution and the Scottish Parliament. All that needs to be argued about now is how much further it can be moved while keeping the other unions intact (as most people and the SNP appears to want).

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

If the SNP would make this clear, said my companion, it would make it a great deal easier for the people of Scotland to figure out want was going on, and to make rational choices.

Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/519858/how-long-can-the-good-times-roll
Economy

How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019
Visit/516758/beyond-the-brexit-talk-the-british-economy-isnt-doing-too-badly
Economy

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019

Most Popular

Visit/520338/how-much-the-state-pension-will-rise-by-this-year
Personal finance

How much the state pension will rise by this year

While Boris Johnson promised to hold a full budget within 100 days of his election victory, many of the details of next year’s state pension increases…
10 Jan 2020
Visit/520525/currency-corner-how-high-can-the-pound-go-against-the-euro-in-2020
Currencies

Currency Corner: how high can the pound go against the euro in 2020?

In the month in which we should finally leave the European Union, Dominic Frisby takes a look at the pound vs the euro and asks just how high sterling…
13 Jan 2020
Visit/520575/20-predictions-for-the-2020s
Investments

Where will markets be in 2030? Here are 20 forecasts for the 2020s

A lot has changed in the last ten years – stockmarkets soared, technology transformed our lives and politics has changed beyond measure. Here, Dominic…
14 Jan 2020
Visit/520258/running-with-the-crowd-is-bad-for-your-finances-heres-how-to-resist-it
Investment strategy

Running with the crowd is bad for your finances – here’s how to resist it

To be a good contrarian investor, you have to avoid being swayed by the crowd. John Stepek explains how to go about it.
3 Jan 2020