I don't go to very many speeches by important-sounding people (it is rarely worth it). But I made an exception yesterday for Mark Carney, who was up in Edinburgh giving a speech about what makes a successful currency union.
He was keen to point out (over and over) that whether an independent Scotland would join with England in currency union and what the terms of any deal might be, are nothing to do with him. He runs a "technocratic organisation" that simply implements the instructions it is given by the government.
However, whatever he might think about the politics (and I know that he is a great fan of a book called What Money Can't Buy by Michael J Sandel) his talk made it pretty clear that in his view, the SNP is going to find it very hard to get what it says it wants fiscal independence alongside monetary union. A successful currency union always "requires some ceding of national sovereignty".
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
There are excellent reasons for wanting to be inside a currency union with a like-minded country. It makes people more likely to invest across borders whenthey don't have to bother with exchange rates; it means everyone has access to more liquid financial markets; and if you have a history of inflation or bad financial management, you can cut your borrowing costs by taking on another country's financial credibility via their currency.
It can also help with pricing transparency, said Carney, encourage the free flow of labour, and "improve the flow of technology and ideas". Sounds brilliant, doesn't it? No wonder the SNP wants to stay in the currency union it is already part of.
[cfsp key="opinion-poll-3"]
successful
The answer is to have that union inside a nation state. So it works in the US and in Canada. It doesn't work in Europe. That's partly down to having a common language and integrated labour market, but, says Carney, it's also down to the major feature of successful currency unions they are also banking unions.
They have a joint deposit guarantee scheme, common supervisory schemes and access to the same central bank as a lender of last resort. They share institutions, and in particular, a "national backstop" in the form of their supranational central bank. But "pooling risk" like this automatically implies a "loss of sovereignty".
After all, a backstop puts sovereign (taxpayer) funds at risk, and with a deposit guarantee scheme, "all member states must be persuaded that they won't simply be left with the bill for the mistakes of others".It doesn't stop there. Successful unions don't just have "common fiscal backing". They have shared fiscal arrangements they have a system that transfers cash between regions (the worse-performing get money from the better via a central government); something that helps "mitigate the loss of exchange rate flexibility".
Europe is heading down the road (with some difficulty) to fiscal union, or at least a "set of robust fiscal rules" in order to survive. When it is done, it will look much like a huge nation state. The degree of fiscal risk sharing, said Carney, is "likely to be significant". Join a currency union, and you end up part of a nation state.
Look at it all like that and you might find yourself wondering exactly what the point of demands for Scottish independence really are it clearly isn't possible to downgrade from being part of a nation state to being in a currency union with the bigger part of that state.
As I have said before, Scotland is effectively a member of five unions (the Crown, defence, currency, European, parliamentary). The SNP plans to keep four of those intact, and as things stand, shift the dial on the fifth (parliamentary union).
But if you believe Mark Carney (and as he says, the politics of the case are nothing to do with him), it is clear the dial can't be shifted very far. It's all a bit more 'devo max' than independence, isn't it?
As Bill Jamieson puts in The Scotsman, Scotland has set out on what looks to be a very "steep learning curve about the meaning of sovereignty and its limits".
* You can find the full speech here should you feel up to it.
<img src="https://wms-eu.amazon-adsystem.com/20070822/GB/img/noscript.gif?tag=moneywcom-21" alt="" /><br />
-
Bitcoin price one of the most-asked questions on Alexa - here's how to buy the cryptocurrencyAccording to figures from Amazon, which cover September 2023 to November 2024, pop star Taylor Swift and Bitcoin were named among the most popular Alexa queries of 2024
-
Investing for children this Christmas – five ideasIt might not come with a shiny ribbon, but an investment fund could be the gift that keeps on giving. We share five ideas if you are investing for children this Christmas.
-
Beating inflation takes more luck than skill – but are we about to get lucky?Opinion The US Federal Reserve managed to beat inflation in the 1980s. But much of that was down to pure luck. Thankfully, says Merryn Somerset Webb, the Bank of England may be about to get lucky.
-
Rishi Sunak can’t fix all our problems – so why try?Opinion Rishi Sunak’s Spring Statement is an attempt to plaster over problems the chancellor can’t fix. So should he even bother trying, asks Merryn Somerset Webb?
-
Young people are becoming a scarce resource – we should value them more highlyOpinion In the last two years adults have been bizarrely unkind to children and young people. That doesn’t bode well for the future, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
-
Ask for a pay rise – everyone else isOpinion As inflation bites and the labour market remains tight, many of the nation's employees are asking for a pay rise. Merryn Somerset Webb explains why you should do that too.
-
Why central banks should stick to controlling inflationOpinion The world’s central bankers are stepping out of their traditional roles and becoming much more political. That’s a mistake, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
-
How St Ives became St Tropez as the recovery drives prices sky highOpinion Merryn Somerset Webb finds herself at the epicentre of Britain’s V-shaped recovery as pent-up demand flows straight into Cornwall’s restaurants and beaches.
-
The real problem of Universal Basic Income (UBI)Merryn's Blog April employment numbers showed 75 per cent fewer people in the US returned to employment compared to expectations. Merryn Somerset-Webb explains how excessive government support is causing a shortage of labour.
-
Why an ageing population is not necessarily the disaster many people think it isOpinion We’ve got used to the idea that an ageing population is a bad thing. But that’s not necessarily true, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
