Merryn's Blog

Why does the media hate the child benefit cut? Because it affects their own families

Scrapping child benefit for higher-rate tax payers is a 'tax on the middle classes', scream the papers. But it's not. The average wage is far lower than the Daily Mail would have you believe.

They're a powerful lot the media. Anyone in any doubt should just ask themselves what constitutes a "middle earner." If you answer £44,000 to £48,000 you've just been nobbled by the press.

The Daily Mail calls the abolishing of child benefit for higher-rate tax payers as a new "tax on the middle classes". The Telegraph makes a similar point. The Times quotes a "senior Tory backbencher" as saying that the policy represents "a frankly worrying failure to understand the family finances of those on middle incomes". Another MP fumed unchallenged to the papers that the Tories no longer have a feel for "Middle England". And even Yvette Cooper was doing the rounds yesterday referring to people earning £44,000 to £50,000 as being on "middle incomes".

Advertisement - Article continues below

But it just isn't true is it? Just because newspaper columnists and MPs can't see how anyone could live on less than £40,000 a year doesn't make £40,000 £50,000 a middle income in the UK. In fact, the mean income is more like £26,000 as David Cameron pointed out earlier this week when he announced that household benefits payments were to be capped at around that level. And the median is around £20,000. So £45,000 puts you in the top 10% of earners in the UK, and £59,000 puts you in the top 5% (if you ignore all the tax dodgers that somehow don't make it into the stats).

And despite all the carping from the quality papers (even the Guardian) the truth is that among real middle earners, the scrapping of child benefit for those they consider to be rich is overwhelmingly popular: a YouGov poll in The Sun shows some irritation with the anomalies I discussed in yesterday's blog but an overall approval rating of 83% for the policy. That's huge.

And it also makes it hard to escape the idea that journalists and MPs oppose the cut not because it makes sense to oppose it, but because it actually affects them. That's a problem because a great many of the cuts to come are also going to affect them. And as a sensible editorial pointed out in The Times today, the government is going to have some trouble with the great task ahead of it if "every time there is a serious attempt to address the problem it is met with an unedifying display of self regard dressed up as moral outrage".




How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
UK Economy

Mervyn King: why the Covid pandemic is a classic example of radical uncertainty

This week, Merryn talks to ex-governor of the Bank of England Merryn King about the pandemic and how to prepare for a future that is unknowable; the g…
2 Jun 2020
UK Economy

“Stealth” debt jubilees are here – and that’s a very good thing

We may not have had a full-scale debt jubilee, but many Covid relief measures quietly amount to “micro-jubilees”. That’s something to celebrate, says …
1 Jun 2020

Most Popular

UK Economy

What bounce back loans can tell us about how we’ll pay for all this

The government will guarantee emergency "bounce back loans" for small businesses hit by Covid-19. Inevitably, many businesses will default. And there'…
1 Jun 2020

This looks like the biggest opportunity in today’s markets

With low interest rates and constant money-printing, most assets have become expensive. But one major asset class hasn’t. John Stepek explains why com…
2 Jun 2020
Global Economy

The MoneyWeek Podcast: James Ferguson on the virus, the lockdown, and what comes next

Merryn talks to MoneyWeek regular James Ferguson of Macrostrategy Partnership about what's happened so far with the virus; whether the lockdown was th…
28 May 2020