James Montier: valuations are way too high
The market is completely discounting the risk to the economy and operating as if there is nothing to worry about, pricing in a V-shaped recovery, says James Montier, investment strategist at GMO.
James Montier, investment strategist, GMO
Investors normally overreact at extremes, James Montier, the value-investing guru who serves on GMO’s asset allocation team, tells Barron’s: they value stocks at “peak multiples on peak earnings and trough multiples on trough earnings”. But this time, it’s different. “Instead of following the collapse in earnings, the market is completely discounting [the risk] and operating as if there is nothing to worry about … and has priced in a V-shaped recovery.”
Yet even if earnings were to rebound, valuations still seem expensive. The economic expansion that ended with the Covid-19 crisis “was the longest but also the weakest economic recovery on record” and stockmarket gains have run ahead of earnings growth. That’s especially true in America, where rising valuations and share buybacks have been responsible for virtually all the superior performance of US stocks over the rest of the world, as Montier noted in a research report before the pandemic arrived in March.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
 
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
So most assets are making no allowance for the potential risks. Small caps look especially vulnerable to a severe recession, but even larger stocks that have done well so far – ie, big tech – “are probably only relative winners … Google and Facebook … aren’t going to see an increase in advertising revenue, so it’s not clear they win in an absolute sense”. Only emerging markets look cheap enough. “Everybody and their mother hates emerging markets,” which gives you a “much greater margin of safety.”
Get the latest financial news, insights and expert analysis from our award-winning MoneyWeek team, to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
MoneyWeek is written by a team of experienced and award-winning journalists, plus expert columnists. As well as daily digital news and features, MoneyWeek also publishes a weekly magazine, covering investing and personal finance. From share tips, pensions, gold to practical investment tips - we provide a round-up to help you make money and keep it.
- 
 Lessons from Nobel Prize winners in economics on how to nurture a culture of growth Lessons from Nobel Prize winners in economics on how to nurture a culture of growthThe Nobel Prize in economics went to three thinkers who show us why economies grow and how we can help them do so. Governments would be wise to heed the lessons 
- 
 Two of Britain's rarest gold coins Two of Britain's rarest gold coinsGold coins from Britain are sought after by collectors around the world, says Chris Carter 
- 
 Two of Britain's rarest gold coins Two of Britain's rarest gold coinsGold coins from Britain are sought after by collectors around the world, says Chris Carter 
- 
 Yoshiaki Murakami: Japan’s original corporate raider Yoshiaki Murakami: Japan’s original corporate raiderThe originator of Japanese activism, Yoshiaki Murakami, was disgraced by an insider-trading scandal in 2006. Now, he's back, shaking things up 
- 
 Cash in on the vast growth potential of the companies electrifying the world Cash in on the vast growth potential of the companies electrifying the worldOpinion Martin Todd, portfolio manager, head of sustainable equities, Federated Hermes, highlights three electrification companies where he'd put his money 
- 
 Galliford Try has firm foundations for strong growth Galliford Try has firm foundations for strong growthBuilder Galliford Try has a finger in a wide range of pies, notably important work in the public sector 
- 
 Card Factory is a stand-out small-cap going cheap Card Factory is a stand-out small-cap going cheapIn a digital world, we still value the personal touch. That’s good news for Card Factory, whose unique business model is suited to weather all economic storms 
- 
 8 of the best smallholdings for sale now 8 of the best smallholdings for sale nowThe best smallholdings for sale – from a medieval cross-passage farmhouse in Taunton, Somerset, to a former farmhouse with an orchard in the Welsh Marches 
- 
 How much gold does China have – and how to cash in How much gold does China have – and how to cash inChina's gold reserves are vastly understated, says Dominic Frisby. So hold gold, overbought or not 
- 
 How to invest in undervalued gold miners How to invest in undervalued gold minersThe surge in gold and other precious metals has transformed the economics of the companies that mine them. Investors should cash in, says Rupert Hargreaves 
 
