Earlier this year the global insurance industry was under pressure. Claims for losses from the Australian and Californian wildfires were coming in, Covid-19 was expected to lead to an avalanche of claims for lost business and the hurricane season lay ahead. But the hurricane season passed without serious incident, the wildfire losses are quantified and those from the pandemic are proving manageable.
Steep rises in premiums
As a result, “this is a fantastic time” to consider the sector, says Nick Martin, manager of Polar Capital’s £1.4bn Global Insurance Fund. “Covid-19 has accelerated the insurance-pricing cycle, creating the best underwriting market in at least a decade.” Marsh & McLennan’s global pricing index, which tracks premiums, rose at an annual rate of 20% in the third quarter after 19%, 14% , 11% and 8% in previous quarters.
There are no investment trusts focused on the sector, while direct exposure in the UK is largely confined to the life insurance, household and retail markets. Polar’s fund has 16% exposure to the UK, but 78% to North America and avoids the savings-orientated life sector. About 43% of the portfolio is in commercial insurance, 18% in retail, 14% in reinsurance and 11% in insurance brokers, with weightings changing according to the insurance cycle.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
“Insurance is a must-have product, often required by law,” says Martin. “The role of the insurance industry is to take on the volatility from unexpected perils that individuals and companies do not want. If the underwriters price that risk appropriately, they will earn a good profit.” The fund was launched over 20 years ago by veteran expert Alec Foster as a Hiscox fund, but it moved to Polar in 2011. The current team have been managing the fund for over 15 years. It invests in 30-35 stocks with low turnover, targeting an 8%-9% annual return from a “conservative” 9%-10% annual growth in book value. Until earlier this year, when the price dropped by 25% (it has since partly recovered), volatility was low, reflecting shrewd management and good diversification.
“US industry valuations are really attractive at about 120% of book value,” says Martin, “down from 150% at the start of the year and halfway between the 30-year average of 135% and the 95%-100% levels we saw in the great financial crisis. We don’t think the fall in valuation is justified. Good insurers will come out of the pandemic with solid results and as a result of the losses, prospects over the next couple of years are very, very strong.” Book values were flat in the first half, but are estimated to have risen by 3% in the third quarter.
Neither growth nor value
The insurance sector is neither high-growth nor a clear value proposition, just a very attractive, but out-of-favour, sector with steady long-term returns. The Polar fund combines experienced management with a long-term record of outperformance; 2.5% per annum ahead of the MSCI insurance sector over five years, but 5% ahead since launch. Annualised performance of 9.2% lags the tech-driven MSCI World index by 3% over five years but, at 8.8%, is 2% ahead since launch, and that is for the relatively expensive “retail” share class, charging 1.25% per annum. Those fees are reduced to 0.75% in the “institutional” share class, available through some platforms.
As Martin points out, “the insurance industry is in the risk business and over time we have seen a relentless rise in risks. New ones are always emerging; wildfires, pandemics and cyber-events, perhaps enhanced by working from home. As long as we have severe weather, catastrophes, accidents, human negligence and ignorance, there will be robust demand for insurance”.
-
Why Chinese stocks are so far out of favourThere’s little appetite for Chinese stocks despite low valuations.
-
The 62 UK areas where you could be priced out of using your Lifetime ISASaving for your first home in Croydon, Ealing, Brent or any one of these other locations? You could be at risk of being priced out of using your Lifetime ISA
-
Why Chinese stocks are so far out of favour
There’s little appetite for Chinese stocks despite low valuations.
-
Three companies that dominate their markets with critical productsA professional investor tells us where he’d put his money. This week: Charlie Huggins, manager of Wealth Club’s Quality Shares Portfolio, picks three stocks.
-
Should you continue to hold Smithson Investment Trust?Opinion Smithson Investment Trust, a small- and mid-cap fund, has struggled to live up to lofty expectations, says Rupert Hargreaves.
-
Primark owner Associated British Foods is an overlooked gem going cheap — should you buy shares?Associated British Foods, the owner of Primark, is a family-owned business, which means it is passed over by the increasingly popular passive investment funds. That spells opportunity for private investors, says Jamie Ward.
-
Trump's tariffs and a shrinking market for alcohol deal double blow to DiageoDonald Trump's tariffs are a further headache for drinks giant Diageo, which is already being buffeted by a decline in alcohol consumption.
-
Three stocks in recruitment companies with promising recovery playsRecruitment agency Robert Walters and its peers are struggling, but now's the time to buy, says Rupert Hargreaves
-
Four UK data companies to buy nowCompanies that create, harness or turn data into a valuable offering could be sitting on a hugely profitable gold mine. Rupert Hargreaves picks four of the best UK data companies to buy now.
-
What’s the outlook for the shipping industry in 2025?All we know for certain about the year ahead is that it will be volatile. But the container shipping sector thrives on choppy waters
