The Turkish lira crashed this morning – falling by as much as 15% against the US dollar at one point – after Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan sacked the central bank governor, Naci Agbal, this weekend.
Last week, the lira had strengthened sharply after Agbal had increased Turkey’s key interest rate by two percentage points to 19%, more than economists had expected. Inflation in Turkey is running at above 15% a year.
Agbal’s move was designed to get ahead of the problem. However, it clearly went against the wishes of Erdogan, who promptly replaced him with Sahap Kavcioglu, a former member of the ruling party.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
What caused the slump?
Agbal has only been in the job since November, when he was appointed to help combat inflation. This shot up to eye-watering levels during the country’s debt crisis of 2018, which saw the lira slide by 34% against the dollar, driving up inflation beyond 25% at one point.
The two main drivers of the currency crash were Turkey’s high current account deficit (in other words, more money was going out of than coming into the country, leaving it reliant on foreign investment, which can be very short term) and high levels of private foreign-currency denominated debt (debt denominated in foreign currencies becomes harder to service the weaker the borrower’s currency becomes).
Since Agbal’s appointment as central bank chief, the lira had strengthened in value as both overseas and domestic investors preferred his traditional macroeconomic policies. And his latest rate hike had been applauded by both local and foreign investors as a credible move to tackle inflation.
Indeed, before Monday’s sharp sell-off, the Turkish lira had been one of the highest-flying emerging-market currencies so far this year, “owing in part to Agbal’s long-needed tightening of monetary policy and prudent decision making”, notes Sophie Griffiths, market analyst at OANDA.
However, the rate hike was too much to stomach for Erdogan, a long-time opponent of higher interest rates. Erdogan is of the – shall we say, unusual – opinion that higher interest rates cause inflation, rather than stifling it. Whether this belief is genuine or not, like most politicians, he prefers low interest rates because they tend to make borrowing cheaper and (nominal) growth faster, which tends to be more politically popular.
Thus he has appointed Kavcioglu, a professor of banking at Marmara University, as Agbal’s replacement for the top job. Kavcioglu is known to be more dovish in nature and shares Erdogan’s taste for lower interest rates, according to multiple reports.
Will there be a knock-on effect?
So will the lira’s plunge reverberate across other financial markets? Whenever these sorts of crises arise, investors’ memories tend to hark back to the Asian crisis of 1997, when a currency collapse in Thailand saw a domino effect take hold across the region.
However, so far the risks of “contagion” look fairly small. Although Turkey’s foreign currency debt is eye-watering at $430bn, currently worth 59% of the country’s GDP, most of this money is owed to Turkish businesses and households, notes Udith Sikand, analyst at Gavekal Research. “This gives Ankara considerable room for can-kicking, for example by issuing foreign currency bonds to domestic depositors”, adds Sikand.
This means that for now Turkey can avoid having to introduce capital controls to prevent foreign currency outflows, a scenario which would have prevented foreign banks and businesses from withdrawing their cash – and probably sparked a panic.
The situation is also nowhere near as bad as in 2018, when the European Central Bank warned banks who had exposure to the country about the risk of contagion spreading to other financial markets. Even though Spanish, Italian, French and German banks still have exposure worth $118bn to Turkey, “the European banking sector is not looking too troubled, at least by Turkey, as markets look for improved growth, lower loan losses and steeper yield curves to fatten their profits and increase their ability to pay dividends”, says Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell.
So while Turkish assets and the currency are likely to struggle under the new dovish governor – which will only exacerbate Turkey’s inflation problem, as Jason Tuvey, senior emerging markets economist at Capital Economics points out, it doesn’t yet look like this will cause major problems elsewhere.
What does this mean for my money?
Unless you have heavy exposure to Turkish assets (in which case you’ve already been through the mill several times over the last few years), there is no obvious reason to make big changes to your portfolio.
Even on the bond market front, Turkey is not a core holding for most emerging debt funds, says Sikand, pointing out that Turkey represents only a 3.5% weighting in the JP Morgan EMBI Global Diversified Index, a benchmark and total return index for $250bn worth of sovereign debt holdings.
-
Should you sell in May this year?The market adage looks unlikely to apply in 2024, and global equities are proving resilient
-
Should you invest in UK equities?The FTSE 100 hit a record high this week, but UK equities remain unloved and undervalued compared to their global and US peers. Should you snap them up at a discount?
-
Why you should keep an eye on the US dollar, the most important price in the worldAdvice The US dollar is the most important asset in the world, dictating the prices of vital commodities. Where it goes next will determine the outlook for the global economy says Dominic Frisby.
-
Sterling accelerates its recovery after chancellor’s U-turn on taxesNews The pound has recovered after Kwasi Kwarteng U-turned on abolishing the top rate of income tax. Saloni Sardana explains what's going on..
-
Will Liz Truss as PM mark a turning point for the pound?Analysis The pound is at its lowest since 1985. But a new government often markets a turning point, says Dominic Frisby. Here, he looks at where sterling might go from here.
-
Are we heading for a sterling crisis?News The pound sliding against the dollar and the euro is symbolic of the UK's economic weakness and a sign that overseas investors losing confidence in the country.
-
The US dollar is rising to dangerous levels – here’s what to do about itAnalysis The US dollar is back on the rise as panicky investors head for safety. That’s rattling markets across the world, says Dominic Frisby. Here’s how to cope.
-
Investors dash into the US dollarNews The value of the US dollar has soared as investors pile in. The euro has hit parity, while the Japanese yen and the Swedish krona have fared even worse.
-
Why a strong dollar hurts – and what you can do about itAnalysis The US dollar is at its strongest level in 20 years. That’s bad news for most investment assets, says John Stepek – here’s why
-
Can anything stop the dollar’s devastating bull run?Analysis The US dollar has been on a massive bull run for the last year or so. Commodity prices are sliding, and the euro – maybe even the pound – could hit parity. But when it turns there will be mad scramble, says Dominic Frisby. Here, he looks at what might halt the runaway dollar.
