Don't count on the stockmarket bounce

The bulls are in charge. Investors emboldened by improving data are looking forward to an economic recovery.

In Britain, the National Institute of Economic and Social Research has said the recession is over. Elsewhere, the latest data also suggest that the downtrend is easing.

Yet the data is hardly unequivocally positive. The latest Chinese export report shows that foreign shipments fell a record 26% year-on-year in May. In April, eurozone industrial production was down by a record 26.4%.

Try 6 free issues of MoneyWeek today

Get unparalleled financial insight, analysis and expert opinion you can profit from.

Start your trial

Sign up for MoneyWeek’s free twice-daily newsletter.

Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.

Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.

Sign up

And in America, unemployment claims have hit a record for 19 weeks in a row, while a widely watched manufacturing index covering the first half of June has dipped. "Optimism is not enough" to bring about a global recovery, says Wolfgang Munchau in the FT. The world economy is still contracting, albeit at a slower rate.

The statistics were bound to improve, given the vast sums of money thrown at the world economy by central banks and governments, says the FT. What's more, in downturns firms amplify a drop in overall demand and output by running down existing stocks of goods rather than making more. Once inventories need replenishing, there is always an uptick in demand and output.

The question is whether it is sustainable. That seems unlikely, given mounting unemployment, falling house prices and historically low savings, and towering debts imply consumption is likely to prove lacklustre for years in Britain and America. We have not yet "made a dent" in the ratio of private-sector debt to GDP, says Buttonwood on Economist.com.

It could take America, where household debt is still 130% of disposable income, five years to cure its debt hangover, says Capital Economics. It may still be "years away from a meaningful recovery".

And the global banking sector is hardly out of the woods. Nobody is "solving the toxic assets and recapitalisation problems of the banks", says Munchau. Yet past banking crises show that until banks' balance sheets have been "cleansed", there can be no sustainable recovery, says the International Monetary Fund's Dominique Strauss-Kahn. So the squeeze looks far from over. Throw in tax rises and public spending cuts over the next few years and full recovery seems a long way off. Markets counting on a V-shaped bounce are likely to be disappointed.

The big picture: we've a long way to fall yet

This chart puts the current global downturn into perspective and it's not a pretty sight. The slump in global industrial output has been "at least as severe" as in the Great Depression, say economists Barry Eichengreen and Kevin

O' Rourke.

Having updated the chart in early June, they see "no clear signs of green shoots". As far as stockmarkets are concerned, global equities have done far worse than they did after 1929. Fourteen months after the 1929-1933 crisis began, global stocks were down by around 20%. Now, 14 months after April 2008, they have fallen by almost twice as much.