Features

Free broadband? Wait until this election campaign really gets going

Labour has added a chunk of BT to the list of things it will renationalise if it wins the election. That probably won’t happen, says John Stepek. But you need a plan B, just in case.

John McDonnell and Jeremy Corbyn © Dan Kitwood/Getty Images

Labour probably won't win the election. But you need a plan just in case they do.

Britain is enduring a much-needed election. You might have noticed.

Since the financial crisis, we've got used to elections being all about sackcloth and ashes.

Austerity. Cuts. Taking away your house to pay for your elderly care.

All policies that might be poorly implemented or ill thought through in the first place, but which do involve some nod to the notion that we can't just stick it all on the credit card forever.

Problem is, voters don't like that. And eventually, politicians particularly the more flamboyant sort cannot help themselves but play to the crowd.

That's why this election is all about the spending. Which brings us to the latest wheeze "free" broadband for all!

Have some free stuff all paid for by taxpayers

This morning, the Labour Party added a chunk of BT to the list of things it plans to renationalise if and when it gets into power.

We're already looking at renationalised water utilities, railways, National Grid and Royal Mail. Now we're looking at BT Openreach the broadband network too. The goal would be to give everyone in the UK free full-fibre broadband by 2030.

The potential cost of the nationalisation is debated, as it always is. The people who plan to take control of the asset the Labour Party say it will cost less than it probably will.

They've got the cost of the roll-out at more than £20bn, while the cost of the part-nationalisation would be set by Parliament, and paid for with government bonds.

The people who own the asset BT shareholders (or at least their representatives, in the form of the management) say it will cost more than it probably will. At the moment, figures of close to £100bn are being bandied about.

Meanwhile, the cost of maintaining the network will be funded by a new tax on the current public enemy number one, the tech multinationals.

I'm not sure what form this tax will take, given that we're currently struggling to tax them properly and it's an issue that lots of clever people have been looking at. But let's not worry about the details right now.

So what's the upshot of all this? The upshot is you get a load of brief headlines about "free broadband", as though the minute a Labour government gets into power, your Wi-Fi will suddenly be a lot better and also free of charge.

And being cynical about it as you should be that's the point.

Look, I'm entirely open to talking about the best way to own and run aspects of the economy. The "private vs public" ownership debate is frequently couched in overly simplistic terms, with one being bad and one being good depending on which side of the political fence you're on.

But this isn't being driven by finding the best solution to a tricky set of problems. It's being driven by ideology and the ability to promise "free" stuff ahead of an election. That's it.

As the FT notes, "Mr McDonnell said that this latest nationalisation was the limit of our ambitions'". However, as the paper also adds, that's exactly what he said in July after Labour talked about nationalising the water companies. To wit: "This is the limit of our ambition when it comes to nationalisation."

It'll be interesting to see just what else we're told we can get for "free" in the next few weeks.

Make sure you have a Plan B

From an investor's point of view, the main question here is: how likely is this to happen?

At the moment, according to the polls, the answer to that is "not very". That's presumably why BT's share price has recovered relatively quickly from an early panic-spike lower.

Of course, as we all know, polls may not reflect what happens on the night. So what can you do about it?

Realistically, anyone holding BT at the moment has to be aware that it's not exactly a company without its troubles.

So if you were still happy enough hanging on through the stock (and I'll warn you that I haven't done enough research into BT itself to give you a high-conviction view on it as yet), then I'm not sure this added threat should make a lot of difference to your investment case.

As for the wider risk of a Labour government all that this BT plan demonstrates is that the current manifesto is just the tip of the iceberg.

A few investment banks persuaded themselves a month or so ago, that a Corbyn government would be less of a risk than a "no deal" Brexit. Their idea was that Corbyn's bark would be worse than his bite. That when in power, the courts or reality or coalition partners would act as restraints on his ambitions to roll back capitalism.

Even if we put aside the fact that "no deal" Brexit appears to be pretty much off the table now, that now surely seems terribly naive.

I suspect that we won't get a Corbyn government next month. However, if we do, investors need to understand that they cannot take their property rights for granted. And that means having some sort of plan right now for your most vulnerable assets.

We've looked at this several times in MoneyWeek magazine over the last few months. If you're not already a subscriber you can get your first 12 issues for £12 here.

Also don't miss our all-day Wealth Summit. It's next Friday. If you haven't booked your ticket yet, hurry the last few are going fast!

Recommended

House prices: from boom to even bigger boom
House prices

House prices: from boom to even bigger boom

UK house prices have risen to new to record highs, says Nicole Garcia Merida. Demand continues to outpace supply, but continued low interest rates, th…
9 Apr 2021
1 April 1999: The minimum wage is introduced in Britain
This day in history

1 April 1999: The minimum wage is introduced in Britain

On this day in 1999, the national minimum wage was introduced in Britain, bringing an instant pay rise to 1.9 million low-paid workers.
1 Apr 2021
How the vaccine wars will harm us all
Global Economy

How the vaccine wars will harm us all

Grabbing and hoarding vaccine supplies, or even manufacturing one’s own, might seem to make sense for a state in an emergency. But the damage done to …
27 Mar 2021
House price rise slows – but not by much
House prices

House price rise slows – but not by much

The rate of increase in UK house prices slowed in the year to January. But nothing seems able to halt their determined march higher, says Nicole Garci…
26 Mar 2021

Most Popular

The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it
Bitcoin

The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it

The cryptocurrency’s price has soared far beyond its fundamentals, says Matthew Partridge. Here, he looks at how to short bitcoin.
12 Apr 2021
Four investment trusts for income investors to buy now
Investment trusts

Four investment trusts for income investors to buy now

Some high-yielding listed lending funds have come through the crisis with flying colours. David Stevenson picks four of the best.
12 Apr 2021
Central banks are rushing to build digital currencies. What are they, and what do they mean for you?
Bitcoin

Central banks are rushing to build digital currencies. What are they, and what do they mean for you?

As bitcoin continues to soar in value, many of the world’s central banks are looking to emulate it by issuing their own digital currencies. But centra…
8 Apr 2021