A new chapter for high-street banks in the PPI mis-selling saga

The PPI mis-selling scandal is nearly over for the banks. But a new nightmare may be just about to begin.

Woman paying for a coffee with her phone © Getty Images

Snazzy new tech is eating the banks' lunch

Lloyds has just seen six years of profits wiped out at a single stroke. RBS has posted a huge quarterly loss. Barclays and Santander have taken big hits. The payment protection insurance (PPI) mis-selling scandal has turned into a neverending nightmare for the main banks. The policies came with so many conditions they were virtually worthless and almost all were mis-sold. Over the last few years the banks have paid out an estimated £44bn in compensation to millions of customers.

This was no accident

But hold on. In truth, it is not really over. PPI was no one-off accident. It is not as if a few over-enthusiastic branch managers went a little crazy and started over-selling a product they hadn't really understood. Nor was it caused by one or two banks going rogue. PPI was systemic. For years it was virtually impossible to buy any financial product without coming under pressure to take out PPI. Why would supposedly well-managed companies make selling such a bad product so central to their strategy?

The reason is simple. The high street banks have a very expensive branch network that collects and distributes cash, and it is all paid for by a "free" basic product the current account that is steadily facing more and more competition. In the past banks made the whole thing work by charging interest on loans, and fees for overdrafts. But as those markets became more competitive, it became harder to make the model work. So they turned to selling products such as PPI to maintain profits. It wasn't that they didn't realise the products weren't much good (after all, the banks drafted the small print). Or that they didn't care. It was simply that there wasn't any other way to make money.

The problem has got worse. In the last few years, competition has intensified. Challenger and app-based banks have captured a younger market with snazzy new features and offers. Hundreds of start-ups are muscling in to the market too, developing hyper-competitive products in niches such as international money transfers or processing credit-card transactions. Peer-to-peer lenders have marched into the main business of collecting deposits and making loans.

Perhaps most worrying of all, the technology giants are all edging into the financial-services market. Amazon already offers a current account, Google and Apple have sophisticated payment systems built into their phones, and Facebook is launching its own currency (admittedly with mixed results so far). Even Uber has this month launched its own credit card. It is going to be harder than ever to make any money in traditional retail banking.

The next PPI?

Recommended

Warsaw and Stockholm: the unexpected new threats to the City of London
UK stockmarkets

Warsaw and Stockholm: the unexpected new threats to the City of London

London has seen off challenges from Frankfurt and Paris, but two other booming financial centres are a bigger threat, says Matthew Lynn.
19 Sep 2021
The charts that matter: more pain for goldbugs
Economy

The charts that matter: more pain for goldbugs

Gold investors saw more disappointment this week as the yellow metal took a tumble. Here’s what’s happened to the charts that matter most to the globa…
18 Sep 2021
The new social-care levy: an unfair tax that protects the “assetocracy”
National Insurance

The new social-care levy: an unfair tax that protects the “assetocracy”

The government’s regressive social-care levy will make Britain’s tax system even more complex. Root-and-branch reform is long overdue.
18 Sep 2021
Kieran Heinemann: the history of shareholder capitalism
Investment strategy

Kieran Heinemann: the history of shareholder capitalism

Merryn talks to Kieran Heinemann, author of Playing the Market: Retail Investment and Speculation in Twentieth-Century Britain, about the history of t…
17 Sep 2021

Most Popular

The times may be changing, but don’t change how you invest
Small cap stocks

The times may be changing, but don’t change how you invest

We are living in strange times. But the basics of investing remain the same: buy fairly-priced stocks that can provide an income. And there are few be…
13 Sep 2021
Two shipping funds to buy for steady income
Investment trusts

Two shipping funds to buy for steady income

Returns from owning ships are volatile, but these two investment trusts are trying to make the sector less risky.
7 Sep 2021
Should investors be worried about stagflation?
US Economy

Should investors be worried about stagflation?

The latest US employment data has raised the ugly spectre of “stagflation” – weak growth and high inflation. John Stepek looks at what’s going on and …
6 Sep 2021