Features

HSBC is at a crossroads

The route HSBC takes next will determine whether it can remain a leader in global banking, says Matthew Lynn.

John Flint, former chief executive of HSBC ©Getty Images

Flint: we blinked and he was gone

The route HSBC takes next will determine whether it can remain a leader in global banking.

John Flint had only served for 18 months as chief executive of HSBC, one of the world's biggest banks, and had barely had enough time to make any changes to its strategy or operations, and then he was gone. On Monday morning, HSBC announced that he was stepping down and that an interim leader would be installed while it searched for a permanent replacement.

Flint's ousting may appear harsh. A long time HSBC banker, he rose to the top and the results that were released at the same time as the news of his departure were hardly terrible. HSBC chalked up a 16% rise in profits, and announced a $1bn share buyback programme. There is no crisis and no hint of scandal. Compared with most of its rivals across Europe, it is in robust health.

And yet its performance has been plodding. On Flint's watch, the shares have dropped by 17%. Since the start of this year they have drifted aimlessly while the rest of the market stormed ahead. Flint's plans for investing more in IT, for trying to turn around its American unit, and for concentrating on growth in China, were all worthy enough. But they were hardly setting the world on fire. His successor will need to make some hard choices.

First, he or she will need to decide whether its real opportunities are in Asia, Europe or the US. It is impossible to focus on all of them. More importantly, the bank needs to decide whether, in a world where China and the US are engaged in a bitter trade war, and where most of Europe is putting restrictions on Chinese investment, it can straddle that divide. It is great to be a bridge between East and West, but it may turn into a no-man's land. HSBC may have to split into Chinese and European/US wings, perhaps in a loose confederation with the same brand and similar shareholdings, but separate management.

HSBC needs to make some tough decisions

Third, HSBC needs to decide whether it can be both a retail and capital markets bank. It has managed to avoid the disasters in investment banking that have crippled the likes of Deutsche or Royal Bank of Scotland over the years. It has kept its investment bankers disciplined and focused on making money for the parent company. And yet the tension between the two types of banking remains. HSBC might be better off choosing retail and business banking and letting the investment bank go its own way.

Finally, it needs to make up its mind where the real growth in banking is. Over a century, HSBC has grown by taking stakes in different territories. But the real divide may not be between continents and countries, but between analogue and digital banking. Amazon and Google are now the real threat, along with dozens of new fintech companies. This may be the moment to make a radical break with the past and ditch branch networks completely.

HSBC came through the financial crisis relatively unscathed. In many ways, it has one of the best positions of any global bank. It has a strong retail presence in Britain and Hong Kong. It is one of the few Western companies with deep roots in China. It has at least a presence in every major economy in the world. HSBC has the assets to become potentially the most successful financial institution of the next decade. But it is at a crossroads and the new CEO needs to decide where it wants to go next.

Recommended

Gold regains some of its shine
Gold

Gold regains some of its shine

The gold price perked up this week, hitting a four-week high.
3 Sep 2021
Hold gold: insuring your portfolio could prove lucrative
Gold

Hold gold: insuring your portfolio could prove lucrative

Gold has had a grim year, but the backdrop for the traditional safe haven and store of value remains auspicious. There is scope for the price to jump …
20 Aug 2021
Gold is frustrating – but it’s still worth holding
Gold

Gold is frustrating – but it’s still worth holding

It's been a frustrating time for investors in gold. But the idea that you should always have a bit of physical gold in your portfolio and just hope th…
20 Aug 2021
I wish I knew what the gold standard was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask
Too embarrassed to ask

I wish I knew what the gold standard was, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

These days, most currencies are "fiat" currencies backed by the economies of the countries that issue them. But in days gone by currencies were on the…
17 Aug 2021

Most Popular

The times may be changing, but don’t change how you invest
Small cap stocks

The times may be changing, but don’t change how you invest

We are living in strange times. But the basics of investing remain the same: buy fairly-priced stocks that can provide an income. And there are few be…
13 Sep 2021
Two shipping funds to buy for steady income
Investment trusts

Two shipping funds to buy for steady income

Returns from owning ships are volatile, but these two investment trusts are trying to make the sector less risky.
7 Sep 2021
How to stop recurring subscriptions becoming a drain on your money
Personal finance

How to stop recurring subscriptions becoming a drain on your money

Tracking and pruning subscriptions isn’t as easy as it sounds. Here's how to take charge.
14 Sep 2021