Great frauds in history: Cortes Randell

Everything was going well for Cortes Randell until US investment magazine Barron's starting probing.

Cortes Randell was born in Virginia in 1935 and went on to found the National Student Marketing Corp (NSMC) in 1965.The idea behind the company was that the growing numbers of college students (a result of the post-war baby boom) would create huge demand for youth-related products such as employment services.

After it floated in 1968, NSMC started buying up related firms, including a computing job placement service, a beer mug manufacturer and a travel guide publisher. Thanks to these acquisitions and a booming equity market, NSMC's share price soared from $6 a share when it listed to a peak of $144 by the end of 1969.

What was the scam?

Randell used NSMC shares to buy other companies, so as long as the company's share price kept rising, it was easyfor it to keep snapping up rivals. A soaring share price also allowed him to entice employees with promises of stock options. Lavish parties and aggressive earnings projections also helped him win the favour of analysts.

However, he also engaged in balance sheet fraud, including counting $2.8m in so-called "unbilled receivables" revenue that had not been received or even requested. He also claimed another $3m in income from subsidiaries that had not been yet acquired.

What happened next?

Shortly after the stock peaked, Barron's, an American investment magazine, ranan article questioningNSMC's reported earnings. While this immediately caused the price of NSMC shares to fall by $20, the real blow came in early 1970 when the company reported a loss, confounding analysts' predictions of large profits.

To make matters worse, the company was forced to restate the report a few weeks later. Its losses were then revised upwards and revenue revised downwards. With his stake reduced to 10% by the various mergers, Randell was removed as CEO in February 1970. By the summer of 1970 the stock was back down to $6 a share.

Lessons for investors

Randell was sentenced to18 months in jail and would laterdo another stint in prison foran unrelated count of mail fraud. One of NSMC's auditors would also spend ten days injail for covering up evidence that Randell had misled investors.

Ultimately, the main lesson of NSMC's rise and fall, which took place during the final stage of a stockmarket boom, is that it is important not to get carried away by wild promises of meteoric growth, however compelling the long-term prospects for the sector in question might appear.

Recommended

The irresistible rise of ESG investing
Investment strategy

The irresistible rise of ESG investing

Many fund managers talk up their green credentials to sell funds, but buying an environmental and sustainability specialist is the best way to profit …
15 Aug 2022
Don’t listen to the doom-mongers – the future is bright
Economy

Don’t listen to the doom-mongers – the future is bright

With volatile markets, raging inflation and industrial unrest, it may feel like things are bad and likely to get worse. But the end of the world is no…
15 Aug 2022
Fill your portfolio with your very best ideas
Investment strategy

Fill your portfolio with your very best ideas

Fund managers’ top picks beat the market, but the rest of their portfolios often add little value, says Chris Sholto Heaton.
13 Aug 2022
Why the market is wrong about private equity
Investment trusts

Why the market is wrong about private equity

When it comes to listed private-equity trusts, investors are overly sceptical, with many funds trading at heavy discounts to their net asset values. B…
9 Aug 2022

Most Popular

Are UK house prices set to fall? It’s not so simple
House prices

Are UK house prices set to fall? It’s not so simple

Figures suggest UK house prices are starting to slide, but we shouldn’t take these numbers at face value, explains Rupert Hargreaves.
11 Aug 2022
Is gold cheap relative to equities?
Gold price

Is gold cheap relative to equities?

Dominic Frisby looks at the Dow-gold ratio and explains why gold is starting to appear inexpensive compared to equities.
12 Aug 2022
The energy price cap keeps rising - here is what you can do about it
Personal finance

The energy price cap keeps rising - here is what you can do about it

The energy price cap could hit £5,000 next year, even higher than expected, predicts energy consultancy Auxilione. Saloni Sardana explains what you ca…
12 Aug 2022