Don’t sell in May this year – the market is telling you it’s time to be long

Investment lore has it that you should “sell in May, go away, come back on St Leger Day”. That may have worked in the past. But not now, says Dominic Frisby. Here's why.


Markets don't go on holiday like they used to

It's 1 May, so, according to some investment lore, we should be selling our holdings and looking to come back on St Leger Day (that's the second week of September, if you're not a follower of horse racing).

Our American brothers have it that Labor Day 2 September this year should be the day or return.

But that is all flimflam in my view. I'm long, I'm especially long the US indices, and I've no current plans to lighten up this May. I don't see any reason to.

Here's why.

Forget "sell in May", stick with "the trend is your friend"

The maxim, "sell in May, go away, come back on St Leger Day" was born in a time when markets really did slow down over the summer, because brokers, traders, and the rest, were all taking their summer holidays.

But these days holidays don't last as long. We can fly to where we want to be in a few hours. It doesn't take several weeks by steamer to get there.

And once we are there we have our wretched smartphones. So, save for remote parts of the Himalayas, it's impossible to get away even if you wanted to.

In the meantime, innumerable computers, quants, algos and bots are doing the work previously done by brokers and traders, and they don't need holidays. It's one of the reasons employers like them.

In short, markets no longer slow down. They don't even sleep, let alone take holidays. Whatever rationale there was behind the maxim has long since become an anachronism.

Countless studies have been done looking at the sell-in-May strategy, and overall, over the past 20 or 50 years, there has been some marginal outperformance. But there are far better strategies to be found. I outlined one of them last week. And with each passing year, the sell-in-May strategy works less and less well.

Trend following by whatever means you use to define and follow a trend works better. And so does buying the break-out. Whenever a market is going up, it will inevitably break to new highs. Break-outs lead to higher highs far more often than they don't. This is especially so under a monetary system which, unlike gold, is not finite.

The Nasdaq broke to new highs last week. It has for years been the US market leader. The S&P 500 followed. The Dow Jones is flirting with new highs. The laggard has been the Russell 2000 index of small companies. But even though it's not at all-time highs, it is still in an uptrend.

Now, you can make the argument that the indices are making an almighty "double top". They might be. But all markets that are testing old highs look like they are making a double top until they break decidedly higher.

You could also argue that the fact that the Russell 2000 is lagging is a bearish sign. You want to see small-cap stocks leading. That could be true as well. Although small-cap leadership is something you tend to see towards the end of bull markets.

You have to think about things like capital flows. Where would rather have your money at the moment? The US? Europe? China? Russia? South America? Most money managers will be arriving at the same conclusion as you. There might be opportunities in all of those places, but surely the US looks the best bet at the moment, and so it makes sense to be overweight there.

Reasons to be moderately bullish

Here's the S&P 500 over the last two years. The red line is the 30-day simple moving average. It gives you an idea of the intermediate term trend. It is clearly sloping up. Yes, the market will stumble as it retests these old highs (dashed line), but there is no reason this market cannot carrying on doing what it has been doing since late last year grinding higher.


Here's the Nasdaq. This is the market leader. I know Alphabet (Google) put out some disappointing results, but I don't think this is game over for the Nasdaq. The trend is up.


Here, by the way, courtesy of a chap on Twitter who goes by the name of "Odd Stats" is the S&P 500 with, highlighted, all the times Alphabet has a down day of 8% or more (such as yesterday). Leaving aside the 2008 crash, there were sometimes wobbles that followed, especially in 2011, but just as common was for the market to grind on higher.


Here, finally, is the Russell 2000 the laggard flirting with its February highs, which are lower than its September highs.


Barron's just published their semi-annual Big Money poll. It seems there are many fund managers who de-risked their portfolios in the market weakness of late 2018, who are only now starting to buy again. The BoAML Fund Manager Survey, meanwhile, reveals that equity weightings are low compared to their historical average. That means there are plenty of potential buyers out there. These markets can go higher.

Recent action has been that of an orderly advance, rather than a blow-off top and that can continue. If we get a proper break-out in the S&P and the Dow, then things may start to get a bit more disorderly on the upside, and the small caps will play catch up as risk-on takes hold, but we are not there yet.

In short, the trend is up. There will be wobbles as we flirt with old highs. But selling in May this year would be fighting the trend. More often than not, that has not proved an effective strategy. Let the trend be your friend instead.

Dominic Frisby is author of the first (and best, obviously) book on bitcoin from a recognised publisher, Bitcoin: the Future of Money?, available from all good bookshops (and a couple of rubbish ones too). Follow Dominic @dominicfrisby


Stockmarkets have a spring in their step

Stockmarkets have a spring in their step

Global stockmarkets have been basking in the post-Covid economic recovery as GDP, retail sales and manufacturing are all on the way back up.
23 Apr 2021
Gold will soon regain its shine

Gold will soon regain its shine

With the gold price down by 9.5% in the first quarter of 2021, it has been a rotten start to the year for gold.
9 Apr 2021
Why gold has been such a bad investment so far this year

Why gold has been such a bad investment so far this year

Gold – the ultimate safe haven investment – is proving anything but safe. It’s lost over $200 an ounce since its high at the start of the year. Domini…
3 Mar 2021
Gold will soon regain its lustre

Gold will soon regain its lustre

Despite roaring commodity prices and central bankers stoking inflation, gold is being left behind. But that won't last.
26 Feb 2021

Most Popular

How are my cryptocurrency gains taxed in the UK?
Bitcoin & crypto

How are my cryptocurrency gains taxed in the UK?

Many investors in cryptocurrencies have made big gains. But once you take profits – or even buy one cryptocurrency with another – you could be liable…
18 May 2021
US stocks look expensive – here’s what to own instead
Investment strategy

US stocks look expensive – here’s what to own instead

Right now, US stocks are among the most expensive in the world. So if you want a decent return on your investments, you should look into diversifying …
17 May 2021
We’re in another house price boom. How long will it last?
House prices

We’re in another house price boom. How long will it last?

UK house prices are in full-on boom mode again. And booms can last a lot longer than you might expect. John Stepek looks at what’s driving the current…
18 May 2021