Features

“Plan A” dons a false moustache

Theresa May’s deal is back on the table. Will it be more appetising the second time? Emily Hohler reports.

931-May-634

May: Brexit deal not dead

A week after she suffered the "biggest parliamentary defeat of modern times" and for all her "fine words about cross-party engagement", Prime Minister Theresa May is still "refusing to budge" over her Brexit withdrawal bill, says Michael Deacon in The Daily Telegraph. Her "tantalisingly billed" Plan B turned out to be "Plan A in a false moustache".

In her statement to the Commons on Monday she insisted the centrepiece of her strategy is negotiating changes to the Irish backstop. She also reiterated that a second referendum could undermine "faith in our democracy" and refused to rule out a no-deal Brexit, "claiming the only way to do so was to accept her deal or revoke Article 50 altogether", say Heather Stewart and Jennifer Elgot in The Guardian.

Drop the backstop

The Northern Ireland backstop is the critical issue, says Boris Johnson in The Daily Telegraph, but there is nothing our MPs can do to "change that text" in the withdrawal deal. That is why May must now return to Brussels "with a real take-it-or-leave-it determination" and get them to take the backstop out, or at the "very least give us a legally binding change that allows for the UK to come out of its own accord".

Then we will be able to say that the agreement, while "imperfect", is "at least tolerable". It will also "unite her party; and the national feeling of relief will be astounding". There are large numbers of MPs who want to stop Brexit, and are hatching "absurd plots" endless "amendments, feints, ruses, motions" to do so. But they won't stop Brexit, and by "seeming so blatantly to go against the wishes of the electorate" they will merely contribute to the sense of a growing divide between the public and the political elite.

So what are May's chances of securing concessions, ask Karla Adam and William Booth in The Washington Post. Germany's chancellor, Angela Merkel, shifted some of the onus back on the EU, saying "we have a responsibility to shape a divorce process" so people don't ask us why we didn't compromise 50 years from now.

The Polish foreign minister, Jacek Czaputowicz, suggested limiting the Irish backstop to five years. Jean-Claude Juncker's chief spokesman responded by saying the withdrawal deal was "not open to negotiation" and told reporters it was "pretty obvious" that border infrastructure (ie, a hard border) would be needed if the UK were to leave the EU without a deal remarks the Democratic Unionist Party's Brexit spokesman, MP Sammy Wilson, described as "belligerent bluffing", says Daniel Boffey in The Guardian.

If a five-year limit to the backstop found favour with other member states, that "could well do the trick", as would a "unilateral withdrawal mechanism for the UK", says Sebastian Payne in the Financial Times. For now, both Ireland and the EU are standing firm, but resolve will be tested "the closer we move towards the prospect of a crash Brexit".

Even if May does secure changes to the backstop, the objections of many Tory MPs go "way beyond" this "narrow issue", says Rachel Sylvester in The Times. True, but some of the "most boisterous Brexiters", including Jacob Rees-Moggand Nadine Dorries, have changed their tone in recent days, realising they

"risk allowing perfect to become the enemy of the good", says Payne. May's Brexit is "far from" the "buccaneering vision of taking back control'", but "opposing it could result in no Brexit at all". Perhaps they will stand firm and Parliament will "take control and direct what happens next", but "an orderly Brexit" is in the interests of all the key players. May's deal "may not be quite dead".

Second-vote juggernaut is unstoppable

To avoid a "catastrophic crash-out" from the EU on 29 March, MPs have begun "wresting control of the process from the government", says the Financial Times. This is a "justifiable effort to forge consensus" in the absence of a working government majority. MPs should "legislate against a no-deal outcome" and seek to extend Article 50. They should then hold "indicative votes to test support for other options". However, if none can win a majority and Theresa May's deal "remains deadlocked", then a second referendum seems the only option, it says.

Voters don't seem "very keen for MPs to pass them the buck", says John Curtice inThe Daily Telegraph. Popular support for a second vote is not as great as the People's Vote campaigners suggest. According to polls, aroundtwo-thirds of Remainerswould like one, but only one in eight Leavers would.

A second referendum would be the "most bitter and divisive event in modern history" and would probably be a tight contest, says William Hague in the same paper. But, by a process of elimination, it is coming. "The deal as it stands cannot be passed", an improved deal is "a long shot", a hard exit "can be killed off", calling a general election is

too risky and cross-party agreement on a new plan looks improbable as Jeremy Corbyn (who has endorsed a plan for MPs to vote on whether a second referendum should be held, notes The Independent) won't even talk to Theresa May. It must also be remembered Brexit is not a single event. Any plan needs "a majority to sustain both it and the government" over many months winning votes and passing laws.

A second vote will be a tragedy, "because as the world economy slows down, the West fragments, and new great scientific and ecological challenges arise, we will have another year of arguing with ourselves. But it's not hard, after the events of the last week, to see it coming".

Recommended

House prices: from boom to even bigger boom
House prices

House prices: from boom to even bigger boom

UK house prices have risen to new to record highs, says Nicole Garcia Merida. Demand continues to outpace supply, but continued low interest rates, th…
9 Apr 2021
1 April 1999: The minimum wage is introduced in Britain
This day in history

1 April 1999: The minimum wage is introduced in Britain

On this day in 1999, the national minimum wage was introduced in Britain, bringing an instant pay rise to 1.9 million low-paid workers.
1 Apr 2021
How the vaccine wars will harm us all
Global Economy

How the vaccine wars will harm us all

Grabbing and hoarding vaccine supplies, or even manufacturing one’s own, might seem to make sense for a state in an emergency. But the damage done to …
27 Mar 2021
House price rise slows – but not by much
House prices

House price rise slows – but not by much

The rate of increase in UK house prices slowed in the year to January. But nothing seems able to halt their determined march higher, says Nicole Garci…
26 Mar 2021

Most Popular

The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it
Bitcoin

The bitcoin bubble will burst: here’s how to play it

The cryptocurrency’s price has soared far beyond its fundamentals, says Matthew Partridge. Here, he looks at how to short bitcoin.
12 Apr 2021
Four investment trusts for income investors to buy now
Investment trusts

Four investment trusts for income investors to buy now

Some high-yielding listed lending funds have come through the crisis with flying colours. David Stevenson picks four of the best.
12 Apr 2021
Central banks are rushing to build digital currencies. What are they, and what do they mean for you?
Bitcoin

Central banks are rushing to build digital currencies. What are they, and what do they mean for you?

As bitcoin continues to soar in value, many of the world’s central banks are looking to emulate it by issuing their own digital currencies. But centra…
8 Apr 2021