When director deals matter

No-one likes selling at a loss. That includes board members. So when directors swallow a loss, it’s bad news.

922_MW_P16_Strategy

One behavioural quirk that almost every investor has experienced at some point is a deep reluctance to crystallise a loss. We all know it's a big mistake, and yet we all make it. We take a look at the psychology behind what's been named the "disposition effect" in the box below. But the key point is that it's painful, whoever you are and however canny an investor you are, to sell shares when it means acknowledging that you have taken a hit as a result. None of us makes the decision comfortably, and many of us put it off until we feel we have no other choice.

So what does it say about a company if its directors who should be in a position to know the company better than anyone else are willing to sell at a loss? That's the question raised in a recent paper by Peter Kelly of the University of Notre Dame, highlighted by John Authers on Bloomberg. Investors often pay attention to director dealings, but the usefulness of doing so has always been a little vague.

Just because a director or founder is selling, for example, doesn't mean that anything sinister is going on things like divorce or school fees or simply locking in some hard-earnedgains are perfectly valid reasons for insiders to offload some of their shares. As a result, a straightforward "sell" decision by a director doesn't mean you should follow suit.

Yet as Kelly notes, if directors are selling at a loss, it should be a far more sinister sign for investors in the stock in question. "Since selling at a loss is painful, an investor who does so must have particularly negative information, information that manifests itself in a poor stock return over the next few months." And it turns out that Kelly's hunch is correct such stocks underperform the wider market in the wake of the sale. In short, "a sale of stock at a loss is a much more negative signal about future returns than a sale of stock at a gain". Kelly also found that if more than one insider takes a loss on a share sale, or the loss taken is particularly large, then the subsequent return of the stock is even worse.

The tricky part, as Authers notes, is figuring out at the point of sale whether or not a director has taken a loss. However, if you aremaking the effort to invest in individual stocks, then it shouldn't be too hard for you to record when directors buy and at what price, then monitor any "sell" decisions closely. Kelly found that the most recent purchase price worked well as a reference price in his research. Be particularly watchful of companies already showing signs of stress any loss-making director sales in this case suggest a recovery is not imminent. In short, if an insider is willing to swallow their pride and lose money, they must have good reason and history suggests you should do the same.

Recommended

Being unpopular can make life easier for companies – just ask BP and HSBC
Investment strategy

Being unpopular can make life easier for companies – just ask BP and HSBC

When you're as hated as banking and the oil sector, it doesn't take much to pull off a nice surprise. John Stepek explains what that means for investo…
27 Oct 2020
Robin Geffen: dividend cuts aren't all down to Covid
Stockmarkets

Robin Geffen: dividend cuts aren't all down to Covid

The seeds of recent dividend cuts and cancellations were sowed many years ago, says veteran investor Robin Geffen.
25 Oct 2020
Dividend payments will take a long time to recover
Income investing

Dividend payments will take a long time to recover

Companies are gradually resuming dividend payouts, but we can expect only a modest rebound in 2021, says Cris Sholto Heaton.
25 Oct 2020
Buying bitcoin could be the best way to play the remote working boom
Bitcoin

Buying bitcoin could be the best way to play the remote working boom

The coronavirus pandemic has accelerated the move to home working, flexible employment practices and the rise of the “digital nomad”. One of the best …
21 Oct 2020

Most Popular

The Bank of England should create a "Bitpound" digital currency and take the world by storm
Bitcoin

The Bank of England should create a "Bitpound" digital currency and take the world by storm

The Bank of England could win the race to create a respectable digital currency if it moves quickly, says Matthew Lynn.
18 Oct 2020
Don’t miss this bus: take a bet on National Express
Trading

Don’t miss this bus: take a bet on National Express

Bus operator National Express is cheap, robust and ideally placed to ride the recovery. Matthew Partridge explains how traders can play it.
19 Oct 2020
Three stocks that can cope with Covid-19
Share tips

Three stocks that can cope with Covid-19

Professional investor Zehrid Osmani of the Martin Currie Global Portfolio Trust, picks three stocks that he thinks should be able to weather the coron…
12 Oct 2020