Ditch the demented Help to Buy policy now

If we ever want the UK to have a slightly less dysfunctional property market than the one it has now, the government needs to get rid of Help to Buy, says Merryn Somerset Webb.

Housebuilder Redrow has just announced a record year. The number of houses it sold is up 9%. Revenues are up 16%. Pre-tax profits are up 21%. And the dividend payment to the firm's lucky shareholders is up 65%. The chairman and founder Steve Morgan is pleased.

He's also keen for this fabulous money-making run to keep going. So he has an idea. He'd like the Help to Buy scheme under which the government effectively underwrites 20% of the purchase cost of a new-build home to continue forever. "If it ain't broke," he says, "why fix it?"

He has something of a point. H2B works brilliantly for the housebuilders: 30% of Redrow's sales last year relied on it a number that is typical across the industry. Without it the sales number above might be rather lower. But H2B doesn't just help housebuilders shift stock. It helps them shift it at high prices, too after all, anyone effectively getting an extra 20% worth of loan from the state to buy can clearly pay more for a house than otherwise (might that be part of the reason Redrow's profits are rising rather faster than its revenues?).

You will remember that H2B was originally set up to solve the problem of high house prices. That it has instead stoked demand for hideously low-quality identikit houses, pushed up prices across the board (the average house price is up 30% since it was introduced), helped the well-off trade up at the expense of the taxpayer (32,000 H2B buyers used it to climb rather than get on the property ladder), and lined the pockets of housebuilder executives and shareholders might well mean "it ain't broke" to Mr Morgan. To the rest of us, I suspect, it means "very broke indeed".

The policy may be popular (as economically illiterate things so often are), but given the misery it is causing and the state resources it is wasting ("£9bn and counting", says Simon French in The Times), the government's review of it shouldn't take long. If they look at this bonkers policy from an economic viewpoint rather than a political one they will see that if they ever want the UK to have a slightly less dysfunctional property market than the one it has now, it's long past time for H2B to go.

To distract yourself from the incompetence of our leaders I suggest you now turn to our cover story on public gaming tournaments, something that are a source of endless confusion for the over-40s. Why on earth, we ask, would anyone ever want to sit in a stadium watching someone else play a video game?

The answer is the same as the one to the question as to why anyone would want to watch anyone else playing snooker or darts. It might not be a traditional sport, but the level of skill is still incredibly high. And that's exciting for viewers, for venue owners, and crucially for game developers. See our cover story for some tips on what to buy with the cash you get from selling your Redrow shares.

Recommended

Is London’s office market a bargain?
Property

Is London’s office market a bargain?

Private-equity groups are swooping on London’s property companies, which are trading on steep discounts to net asset value.
23 Oct 2020
Big spending government is here to stay – just ask Rishi Sunak
UK Economy

Big spending government is here to stay – just ask Rishi Sunak

Governments around the world are splashing huge amounts of cash as they do “whatever it takes” to prop up their economies. John Stepek looks at where …
23 Oct 2020
Why negative interest rates are a lousy idea
UK Economy

Why negative interest rates are a lousy idea

The Bank of England’s governor says negative interest rates can encourage investment rather than having cash stashed in the bank. But is that really t…
22 Oct 2020
I wish I knew what negative interest rates were, but I’m too embarrassed to ask
Too embarrassed to ask

I wish I knew what negative interest rates were, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

There’s been a lot of talk from the Bank of England recently about introducing “negative interest rates”. So what on earth are they, and what would th…
20 Oct 2020

Most Popular

Negative interest rates and the end of free bank accounts
Bank accounts

Negative interest rates and the end of free bank accounts

Negative interest rates are likely to mean the introduction of fees for current accounts and other banking products. But that might make the UK bankin…
19 Oct 2020
UK post-Covid recovery stocks: these 20 companies could be set to rocket
Share tips

UK post-Covid recovery stocks: these 20 companies could be set to rocket

Finding stocks with the potential to rise tenfold or even further is far easier said than done. But the pandemic has produced the most promising backd…
22 Oct 2020
Big spending government is here to stay – just ask Rishi Sunak
UK Economy

Big spending government is here to stay – just ask Rishi Sunak

Governments around the world are splashing huge amounts of cash as they do “whatever it takes” to prop up their economies. John Stepek looks at where …
23 Oct 2020