Advertisement

Let’s open our arms to hostile corporate raiders

An Eighties fashion is coming back in, says Matthew Lynn. We should welcome the shake-up.

887-BA-634
A period of turbulence would do some companies good

An Eighties fashion is coming back in. We should welcome the shake-up.

A bitter takeover battle between an audacious corporate raider and an old established industrial name. Bids and counter-bids, and a war of words fought through the pages of the business press. Politicians calling for a national treasure to be protected. Add in some Human League songs, and the bid for aerospace-parts firm GKN by Melrose could be right out of the 1980s.

Advertisement - Article continues below

In many ways, this is a classic hostile raid. A small, aggressive business wants to take control of an old industrial conglomerate by persuading shareholders it can manage the assets more effectively. It is the kind of stunt that firms such as Hanson and BTR pulled all through that decade, often with stunning success. Melrose, which was only formed in 2003, is very much out of that mould.

Not much missed

In the last two decades the hostile raid has been about as fashionable as shoulder pads. Bids and deals were mostly agreed mergers in similar industries, or management buy-outs backed by private-equity houses, or straightforward acquisitions of medium-sized businesses by far larger ones. We have seen activist investors, who build a substantial stake, then demand changes in the way a company is run. But there have been few who were willing to stake billions on being able to run a business better.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Nobody much missed the raiders. They provided lots of great stories for business journalists (always a good thing). But they ended up with a bad reputation for short-term profiteering rather than long-term wealth creation.

And yet, this might be the moment for their return. Why? Because today there are plenty of companies that need the kind of pressure that hostile raiders exert. The methods were brutal, and the costs often excessive, but there was a kernel of truth to the arguments the raiders of the 1980s deployed. There were lots of big companies with assets that were underperforming, management teams that had grown complacent, and with strategies that had fallen behind the times.

Shareholders might have exerted some pressure behind the scenes, but that could often be swatted away, and very few had the time, knowledge or focus to force a business to make radical changes. It took an actual offer to make that happen. There can be no question that by the end of the decade the pressure from corporate raiders had made British and American industry leaner, more effective, and more profitable.

No shortage of targets

Look at GKN. It has just about admitted that its combination of businesses didn't make much sense. But it took the pressure of the Melrose bid to force it to make some changes. Regardless of whether the offer succeeds or not, it has already worked for shareholders.

Advertisement - Article continues below

As for other examples, drug giant GlaxoSmithKline has been drifting for years, with few new blockbuster drugs. WPP looks to have run out of steam under Martin Sorrell, with a model built for a pre-internet era. IAG has let its British Airways brand decline to the point where many lucrative business-class passengers actively avoid it.

Pearson's decision to get out of consumer media and bet big on education increasingly looks like a huge mistake that is destroying value on an epic scale. Barclays seems to stumble from crisis to crisis, changing CEOs along the way, but without making any fundamental changes to improve its performance. M&S can't seem to work out how to sell fashionable clothes any more.

At all those companies, it might well be time for a break-up, or for a radical change of management. If a hostile raid is the only way that can be achieved, it might do the FTSE a lot of good to see a few more.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

How long can the good times roll?
Economy

How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019
Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly
Economy

Beyond the Brexit talk, the British economy isn’t doing too badly

The political Brexit pantomime aside, Britain is in pretty good shape. With near-record employment, strong wage growth and modest inflation, there is …
17 Oct 2019
Businesses must be bold if they want to survive
UK Economy

Businesses must be bold if they want to survive

It’s a difficult time for companies, but battening down the hatches is the wrong approach, says Matthew Lynn.
2 Aug 2020
How Russia’s dirty money sullies Britain
UK Economy

How Russia’s dirty money sullies Britain

Russia’s kleptocrats have grown used to laundering their money and reputations in London. The government has promised change, but how serious is it?
1 Aug 2020

Most Popular

Gold bugs' dreams are coming true – but we could still see a V-shaped recovery
Gold

Gold bugs' dreams are coming true – but we could still see a V-shaped recovery

John and Merryn talk about how it's perfectly reasonable to expect a V-shaped recovery and to continue holding gold as well. Plus, inflation, staycati…
30 Jul 2020
UK banks have had a shocking week – so it’s probably a good time to buy
UK stockmarkets

UK banks have had a shocking week – so it’s probably a good time to buy

Lloyds Bank reported a £676m loss this week. And, with all of the UK's high street banks having a terrible time of things, bank stocks are detested ri…
31 Jul 2020
The charts that matter: gold finally sets a new record high 
Global Economy

The charts that matter: gold finally sets a new record high 

As gold surges past its previous high, John Stepek looks at how it's affected the charts that matter most to the global economy.
1 Aug 2020