Advertisement

What investors can learn from SLA's ill-fated merger

The merger of Aberdeen Asset Management and Standard Life was supposed to create a “formidable player” on the global money-management stage. Things are not going well. Merryn Somerset Webb looks at what investors can learn from the mess.

When Martin Gilbert and Keith Skeoch the one-time CEOs of Aberdeen Asset Management and Standard Life signed their huge merger deal last year, the plan was simple to get big enough to be a "formidable player" on the global money-management stage.

So far, so bad. Six months in and, while the combined business is the UK's largest listed fund manager, it is also "plagued by disappointing performance, flighty investors and falling staff morale", says the Financial Times. Worse still given the men's stated aim (scale, scale, scale) their biggest client has sacked them. Lloyds Banking Group has said it will pull out £109bn that Aberdeen has been managing for Lloyds' Scottish Widows insurance and pensions unit since 2013. That £109bn makes up around 20% of SLA's assets under management (AUM), and not far off a third of the assets Aberdeen brought to the merger. Nasty.

Advertisement - Article continues below

What lessons can ordinary investors learn here? First, this is a timely reminder that big mergers more often destroy than create value: in merging with Standard Life, says Shore Capital's Paul McGinnis. Aberdeen rendered its £500m purchase of Scottish Widows "essentially worthless". Second, for the right client, big fund managers can offer bargain-basement prices. SLA has made much of the fact that while the Lloyds money makes up 20% of AUM, it produces only 5% of revenues. That means Lloyds was having its billions managed for under 0.15% a year.

I wonder how end clients of Scottish Widows feel about that (you can be sure their bill is a little higher)? More pertinently, I wonder how the rest of Standard Life Aberdeen's clients feel? If I were one of them, I'd have a quiet word about my own fees, particularly if I happened to be invested in their vast, hideously complicated, high-charging and embarrassingly underperforming Global Absolute Return Fund (yours for 0.89% a year, and down 1.3% over the last three years).

Advertisement - Article continues below

The lessons are simple: mostly sell shares in firms involved in big mergers; remember your fund manager is probably overcharging you; and steer clear of very large funds run by very big fund-management firms (it's hard for them to outperform). This week, Max King offers an alternative Max Ward's Independent Investment Trust. It's nearly as cheap as Lloyds money managed by Aberdeen used to be (0.2% a year you don't need "scale" to offer value). It is simple. It is focused. It isn't looking to get bigger. And it is very successful. The GARS fund is up 13% over the last five years. The Independent Investment Trust is up 175%. They aren't quite the same thing, so it isn't 100% fair to compare them, and of course past performance is no guarantee of future performance. But if I was looking for somewhere to put cash for the long term, and I wasn't going passive, I know which I would go for.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

The British equity market is shrinking
Stockmarkets

The British equity market is shrinking

British startups are abandoning public stockmarkets and turning to deep-pocketed Silicon Valley venture capitalists for their investment needs.
8 Nov 2019
BP has slashed its dividend – and markets love it
Income investing

BP has slashed its dividend – and markets love it

BP has bowed to the inevitable and cut its dividend in half – and its share price promptly rose. John Stepek explains what it means for shareholders …
4 Aug 2020
Listed companies are dying out, and that could have serious consequences
Stockmarkets

Listed companies are dying out, and that could have serious consequences

Private equity is taking over from public stockmarkets as the biggest provider of capital to companies. That’s bad for investors and bad for society a…
3 Aug 2020
The revolutionary potential of 5G
Sponsored

The revolutionary potential of 5G

SPONSORED CONTENT – With the right investment and support, the next generation of connectivity could transform society
3 Aug 2020

Most Popular

BP has slashed its dividend – and markets love it
Income investing

BP has slashed its dividend – and markets love it

BP has bowed to the inevitable and cut its dividend in half – and its share price promptly rose. John Stepek explains what it means for shareholders …
4 Aug 2020
Listed companies are dying out, and that could have serious consequences
Stockmarkets

Listed companies are dying out, and that could have serious consequences

Private equity is taking over from public stockmarkets as the biggest provider of capital to companies. That’s bad for investors and bad for society a…
3 Aug 2020
Gold hits the big $2,000 level – are Aim miners about to play catch up?
Gold

Gold hits the big $2,000 level – are Aim miners about to play catch up?

With the price of gold shooting through $2,000 an ounce, the yellow metal looks unstoppable. Things are so bullish, even Aim-listed junior gold miners…
5 Aug 2020