Bring on a pension price war

Many people are paying too much for their personal pensions, says David Prosser. A probe of the market is not before time.

882-lidl-634

Supermarkets show that more competition cuts prices

If you set up your personal pension some years ago, there's a good chance you're overpaying for it. Consumer groups have long argued that many plans are too expensive, and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has now announced an investigation of the non-workplace pensions market.

In practice, that means any individual pension set up separately from your employer. Most recently, self-invested personal pensions (Sipps) have been the most popular individual arrangements, but the investigation will also cover traditional personal pensions, stakeholder pensions and a variety of other schemes going back more than 30 years.

In some cases, personal pensions are highly competitive. Sipp providers in particular have been caught up in a price war since the pensions freedom reforms of 2015.

However, other personal pensions carry much higher charges, often levied through different types of fee that make it difficult to work out the total cost. Savers who took out such pensions some time ago are particularly likely to be paying over the odds, especially those who began investing in the 1980s and 1990s, before the government introduced stakeholder pensions, which capped charges at maximum levels.

In some cases, these pensions are now gathering dust, with savers investing for retirement via new vehicles; even so, the charges are still deducted, eating into whatever investment growth the pension fund is achieving.

Defining what constitutes a high charge isn't straightforward. Savers whose personal pension investments go beyond the most traditional options basic equity and bond funds will typically have to pay higher charges for the privilege. You may also have to pay extra fees for particular product features.

In the workplace-pension sector, an FCA investigation into charges resulted in the introduction of a cap of 0.75% a year. This only applies to the default pension funds offered under a workplace scheme providers may charge higher fees for more specialist investments but it gives some idea of what regulators believe is appropriate.

Stakeholder pensions, introduced in 2001, are not allowed to charge more than 1.5% a year for the first ten years. Thereafter, charges are capped at a maximum of 1% a year. If competition is failing, similar rules may be needed again.

Regulator slams gate closed after horse bolts

The regulator set up to protect members of final-salary pension schemes whose employers get into financial difficulties is too slow to act, argue MPs. The House of Commons' Work and Pensions and Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) committees have demanded an explanation from the Pensions Regulator after it emerged that the watchdog had been talking to the ill-fated Carillion about its pension scheme for almost a decade.

Despite the discussions, the scheme had a deficit of close to £600m when the company collapsed. Rachel Reeves (pictured), chair of the BEIS committee, complained about "regulators who monitor rather than act, who are adept at closing the gate after the horse has bolted".

The row highlights the difficult situation in which the regulator often finds itself. Where it knows a pension scheme is substantially short of the assets required to meet the pension promises made to staff, it has powers to intervene to order the sponsoring employer to take action. However, doing so may exacerbate the financial difficulties of the employer, potentially undermining its ability to remain solvent and continue sponsoring the scheme over the long term.

The Carillion case follows recriminations over the deficit in the pension scheme at bankrupt retailer British Home Stores (BHS). The regulator has told former BHS boss Dominic Chappell that he must pay around £10m into the BHS scheme. The fund has already received a £363m injection from Philip Green, who sold BHS in 2015 to Chappell's consortium.

Tax tip of the week

If you find your tax return stressful, rejoice, says consumer group Which. HMRC is rolling out a simplified system for certain taxpayers. Existing state pensioners who submit a tax return because their state pension is worth more than the annual personal allowance will be switched to the Simply Assessment system for the 2017/2018 tax year. Those who are eligible will receive a letter from HMRC setting out their income, and can then either pay their tax bill or tell HMRC if anything is incorrect or missing.

Recommended

Inheritance tax: how your pension can help you plan your estate
Pensions

Inheritance tax: how your pension can help you plan your estate

Pensions can help you minimise your family’s potential inheritance-tax bill. David Prosser explains how.
12 May 2021
Does part of the £50bn lying forgotten in dormant accounts belong to you?
Personal finance

Does part of the £50bn lying forgotten in dormant accounts belong to you?

Around £50bn of our money is just sitting in dormant bank, savings and pension accounts. Make sure none of it's yours, says Ruth Jackson Kirby.
20 Apr 2021
The minimum pension withdrawal age is set to rise – don’t get caught short
Pensions

The minimum pension withdrawal age is set to rise – don’t get caught short

From April 2028, the earliest age at which you can take money from your pension savings will rise to 57. It's vital that you understand the detail of …
13 Apr 2021
Make sure you max out your pension contributions this year
Pensions

Make sure you max out your pension contributions this year

If you're saving for retirement, make sure that you have used up all their allowances before the tax year ends, and contributed as much to your pensio…
31 Mar 2021

Most Popular

How will Joe Biden’s capital gains tax rise affect crypto prices?
Bitcoin & crypto

How will Joe Biden’s capital gains tax rise affect crypto prices?

The US president wants to increase capital gains tax – and that’s going to hit a lot of American cryptocurrency speculators. Saloni Sardana looks at h…
14 May 2021
US stocks look expensive – here’s what to own instead
Investment strategy

US stocks look expensive – here’s what to own instead

Right now, US stocks are among the most expensive in the world. So if you want a decent return on your investments, you should look into diversifying …
17 May 2021
Inheritance tax planning: the rules around gifting
Inheritance tax

Inheritance tax planning: the rules around gifting

There are plenty of legal ways to minimise an inheritance tax bill. Perhaps the simplest is to give away assets to reduce the size of your estate. Dav…
11 May 2021