Let’s cheer the end of Merkel’s reign

Germany needs bold and decisive leadership, says Matthew Lynn. The sooner Angela Merkel departs the stage, the better.

Merkel: it's time to leave the stage

2017 Getty Images

It looks as if Angela Merkel has finally lost the election that took place in Germany in September. Her centre-right CDU took only 32.9% of the vote, while the far-right Alternative for Germany rose to 12.6%; the Greens and the liberal FDP also scored well. She has been trying to piece together a so-called Jamaica coalition of the CDU, the FDP and the Greens, but talks have not gone well.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Imagine trying to get Caroline Lucas, Boris Johnson and Nicola Sturgeon into the same government. Whether she limps on in a minority government, or is forced into fresh elections, remains to be seen. Either way she makes Theresa May look like a commanding figure.

Will anyone be sorry to see her depart? The markets, understandably, prefer continuity to disruption. They know Merkel and they trust her policies. But sometimes a radical change is for the better and that is certainly true in Germany right now. Here's why.

First, Merkel's brand of cautious, consensus politics has left the eurozone in a mess. It is doing slightly better this year, but only because the European Central Bank has printed money by the truck-load. There are only two ways it can go from here.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Either it is turned into genuine monetary union, with a common fiscal policy and harmonised taxes, as France's President Emmanuel Macron has suggested. Or else some countries should be allowed to peel away, and be given help to leave. You can make a respectable argument for both options. But Merkel won't allow either. The result? Stagnation.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Second, Merkel has presided over a decline in German competitiveness. Sure, Germany exports a lot, and has racked up huge trade surpluses. But that is hardly a measure of success. The fundamentals are not in great shape. The hasty phasing out of nuclear power has led to some of the highest energy costs in the world (hardly a minor matter in a country that relies on manufacturing).

She has introduced the country's first minimum wage, pushing up labour costs. Taxes have remained high even with a budget surplus which is one reason the tax-cutting FDP did well at the election. Where are the German leaders in internet technology, or in the emerging industries of robotics or artificial intelligence? The country badly needs some pro-growth, pro-entrepreneurship policies. But Merkel won't tolerate them.

Finally, there is that surplus. Merkel has allowed it to grow to a massive 9% of GDP, one of the largest in the world. Sure, Germany has always been good at exporting, but this is crazy. Through much of the 1990s Germany ran deficits, and even past surpluses have never been much above 3% or 4% of GDP. It has doubled in the last decade as percentage of GDP. Trade imbalances are a major cause of financial instability, for the simple reason they have to be recycled through the banking system. In effect, Germany is recklessly exporting deflation and deindustrialisation to the rest of the world.

It could fix that if it wanted to. It could massively increase public spending to boost domestic demand until the surplus was reduced. Or cut taxes and borrow more. Or it could leave the euro. But Merkel won't agree any fix or admit that it is a problem. Instead, the surplus just rises and rises. It is now the most likely cause of the next financial crisis.

Merkel has now been chancellor for 12 years, but she has remarkably little to show for it, certainly compared with previous long-serving post-war chancellors. She has held on to office, but only by negotiating compromises and avoiding hard choices. Germany could use some bold and decisive leadership right now, and so could Europe. It won't get that from Merkel and the sooner she departs the stage, the better it will be.




How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019
UK Economy

Mervyn King: why the Covid pandemic is a classic example of radical uncertainty

This week, Merryn talks to ex-governor of the Bank of England Merryn King about the pandemic and how to prepare for a future that is unknowable; the g…
2 Jun 2020
UK Economy

“Stealth” debt jubilees are here – and that’s a very good thing

We may not have had a full-scale debt jubilee, but many Covid relief measures quietly amount to “micro-jubilees”. That’s something to celebrate, says …
1 Jun 2020

Sales will bounce back, but will profits?

As the lockdown ends, everyday life will resume – just don’t expect business as usual, says Matthew Lynn.
31 May 2020

Most Popular

UK Economy

What bounce back loans can tell us about how we’ll pay for all this

The government will guarantee emergency "bounce back loans" for small businesses hit by Covid-19. Inevitably, many businesses will default. And there'…
1 Jun 2020

This looks like the biggest opportunity in today’s markets

With low interest rates and constant money-printing, most assets have become expensive. But one major asset class hasn’t. John Stepek explains why com…
2 Jun 2020

These seven charts show exactly why you must own gold today

Covid-19 is accelerating many trends that were already in existence. The rising gold price is one such trend. These seven charts, says Dominic Frisby,…
3 Jun 2020