Advertisement
Cover Story

The climate of fear will only get worse – and that’s down to Saudi Arabia

The low price of oil is a serious problem for Saudi Arabia. But as Peter Frankopan explains, it should also be a serious worry for us too.

15-11-19-Saudi-634
Saudi Arabia needs oil revenue to keep its youngsters on the road

As Western leaders grapple with how best to respond to the attacks in Paris last week, few doubt that we are living in an age of fear and uncertainty. The bad news is that things are more likely to get worse than to get better. There are several reasons for that, but one of the main ones is the fragility of a key player in the Middle East Saudi Arabia.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Over the course of the summer, tens of billions of dollars were pulled from global asset managers by Saudi Arabia, resulting in an unusually volatile August for global markets. The cause was the slump in oil prices.

The oil crash looks like great news if you are trying to stimulate stagnant economies, hit by nearly a decade of financial scandal and recession. But it's not so helpful if you are a state with an undiversified economy that is heavily dependent not only on rising consumption of fossil fuels, but also on limited new reserves being discovered the last thing you need is the rise of technologies (such as improved fracking) that challenge what has been the basis of energy production over the last century.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Many states are under serious pressure as a result of the oil collapse Russia is atrophying at a worrying rate, for example. But the biggest threat to us all comes from Saudi Arabia: itsbudget balances when oil trades at more than $100 per barrel, more than double the current price. So the fall over the last 18 months has been painful for the Saudis. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) puts their reserves at just over$660bn. That sounds a tidy sum to have down the back of the sofa for a rainy day, but it's a lot less than the $750bn Saudi Arabia had a year ago.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The problems facing Saudi Arabia are now threefold. First, how to rein in lavish spending by an elite that is used to the best things in life, and which has grown in size as the royal family has reproduced energetically. Keeping everyone close to the centre is not just a perceived privilege, but a mechanism of maintaining order in, and control of, a state that is huge in size, but also more disparate than most observers understand.

And it is not just the gilded elite who need to be kept happy: upgrading roads, and building hospitals, bridges and broadband is a way that the ruling house shows its benevolence to the wider population. In the short term, lower-than-anticipated revenues are being papered over by cash redemptions from abroad. But this cannot go on forever which makes rising spending particularly concerning.

Saudi Arabia already has one of the largest defence budgets in the world, with spending estimated to be nearly $50bn this year alone. So acute is the gap between revenues and spending that the IMF warned last month in its World Economic and Financial Regional Survey that the country might go bust by 2020, unless spending is brought under control, or oil prices rise sharply.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Secondly, Saudi Arabia'sregional entanglements. These are not only proving expensive, but are sowing the seeds of long-term problems on its doorstep. Most obvious is Yemen, where 1.5 million people have been displaced. There are many reports of violations of international law, and, according to the UN's World Food Programme, some six million people have been pushed to the brink of starvation.

Saudi Arabia is agitated, too, about the prospect of the rehabilitation of Iran on the global scene, as much for ideological and religious reasons as from concerns about the release of yet more oil onto the international markets: most of Saudi Arabia'soil is produced in parts of the country with large Shi'ite populations, who are more receptive to leadership from Tehran than Sunni Riyadh.

This brings us to the third, and perhaps most serious problem. History teaches that failing states become increasingly volatile and dangerous as they come under pressure. Desperate times call fordesperate measures, as the saying goes. And in the case of Saudi Arabia, the worry is that bad choices serve to make things worse, not better. Middle East watchers have long been alarmed about the iron grip Wahhabism has managed to exert, not just in Saudi Arabia, but across the region.

Advertisement - Article continues below

This virulent form of Islam rejects tolerance of other religious groups, promoting in its place a violent end to what its adherents see as an age of jahiliyyah (ignorance) similar to that of the pre-Islamic era. Saudi Arabia treads a precarious path, for while formally a Wahhabi state, it disavows groups such asIslamic State (IS) that espouse similar views with the Grand Mufti recently asserting that IS is "enemy number one of Islam".

This sits uncomfortably alongside some home truths regarding Saudi involvement in Islamic fundamentalism. It is not just that 15 of the 9/11 suicide bombers were Saudis; so too are all 12 of the divisional heads of IS. Money, support and sympathy help keep IS in business. The irony, of course, is that if the Saudi economy contracts to the point of paralysis (or worse), military engagements with Yemen and perhaps beyond continue, and the destabilising reach of IS gets ever longer, one thingis almost guaranteed to happen amidthe resulting chaos: the price of oilwill rise. It's a strange world we live in.

Dr Peter Frankopan is a senior research fellow at Worcester College, Oxford.His best-selling book, The Silk Roads:A New History of the World, is published by Bloomsbury.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

Bullish investors return to emerging markets
Stockmarkets

Bullish investors return to emerging markets

The ink had barely dried on the US-China trade deal before the bulls began pouring into emerging markets.
27 Jan 2020
What escalating tension between Iran and the US means for oil prices
Global Economy

What escalating tension between Iran and the US means for oil prices

The tension between the US and Iran is unlikely to mean all-out war in the Middle East. But markets may be getting a little too complacent about its e…
6 Jan 2020
Beware the hidden risks when investing in emerging markets
Investment strategy

Beware the hidden risks when investing in emerging markets

Emerging markets look cheap compared with developed countries, but earnings may be less trustworthy.
23 Dec 2019
Rising output will keep a lid on the oil price
Oil

Rising output will keep a lid on the oil price

Oil exporters’ cartel Opec gave further encouragement to the bulls this month after agreeing to new production curbs.
20 Dec 2019

Most Popular

An economics lesson from my barber
Inflation

An economics lesson from my barber

On reopening his shop after lockdown, Dominic Frisby’s barber doubled his prices. It’s all part of the post-Covid inflation process – and we’re going …
8 Jul 2020
Three ideas for Lloyds Bank's new boss
UK stockmarkets

Three ideas for Lloyds Bank's new boss

The Black Horse needs whipping into shape. A change at the top provides a great opportunity, says Matthew Lynn.
12 Jul 2020
Why the moving average is my favourite charting tool
Sponsored

Why the moving average is my favourite charting tool

Traders and technical analysts use "moving averages" to iron out daily fluctuations and give a much clearer picture of a market's direction. Dominic …
13 Jul 2020