Earlier this week the government quietly sold around 6% of RBS, the bank it bailed out in 2008.
This decision has been controversial. Several commentators pointed out that the current price means that the taxpayer will make a £1bn loss on the sale.
While few people argue that RBS should be kept in state hands for the long term, the decision to sell it at the current price has raised eyebrows, especially since it were much higher only a few months ago.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Indeed, there are mutterings that some hedge funds may have found out about the surprise sale beforehand and shorted the shares, further depressing the price.
But none of that matters to investors. The only thing that they should care about is whether the shares are worth buying at the current price.
We think RBS shares might be worth a gamble.
RBS has a chequered history
Under its chief executive, Fred Goodwin, RBS expanded at a rate that was aggressive even compared to its competitors. In 2007, it bought part of Dutch bank ABN Amro and became the biggest bank in the world, with assets of £1.9trn.
This meant that RBS became massively overextended just as the flow of money was drying up. The government forced it to raise extra capital from the market, but this failed. The taxpayer was forced to step in at a cost of £45bn, and ended up with a 79% stake in the bank. Goodwin was removed as CEO in October 2008.
RBS goes on a diet
As part of this, the bank slimmed down drastically. It has sold off over 600 UK branches, plus Coutts, its private bank. Other sales include its insurance business and German operations.
Overall assets are down by nearly half from their peak levels, and expected to fall further. Normally such actions would be a big negative. But in this case it should help RBS become a much more stable and focused institution.
It is also having an immediate effect on the bottom line. The bank unexpectedly made a profit last year, and recent results were also extremely positive.
The end of state control
So the good news from this week's sale is that it shows George Osborne is eager to move RBS back to the private sector as soon as possible a goal he will be eager to accomplish given his ambitions to succeed David Cameron as prime minister.
Importantly, studies have shown that investing in newly privatised companies can be a smart move. Around two-thirds of the companies that were sold off in the 1980s and 1990s outperformed the market.
While a few shares, such as BT and British Airways, haven't done so well, others, including BAA and British Gas, proved lucrative. Indeed, one company, Amersham International (a medical device group sold off in 1982) produced huge returns for shareholders when it was bought by General Electric for £5.7bn in 2002.
It's clear that professional managers answering to shareholders are far better at running a company than civil servants or government-appointed trustees.
Governments are also bad at selling assets. Since a failed privatisation leads to a lot of bad PR, they tend to be undervalued as with the botched sale of Royal Mail in 2013. The state also has a knack of selling when the market is at its lowest point, as it did with gold between 1998 and 2002.
Litigation risk priced in
However, these concerns seem overstated. Litigation is a problem for the entire sector, rather than RBS specifically. RBS is also looking to sell its stake in US subsidiary Citizens' Financial Group, which should further reduce its legal exposure. It's hard to see how even the most aggressive legal costs could exceed the $10bn that the bank has already set aside.
In any case, these risks are outweighed by the fact that it is valued at an attractive rate. RBS (LSE: RBS) currently trades at 12.8 times forward earnings, and at a discount of 30% to its reported net assets. Even when these assets are valued more conservatively, there is still a 10% discount.
-
Will the Bitcoin price hit $100,000?With Bitcoin prices trading just below $100,000, we explore whether the cryptocurrency can hit the milestone.
-
Inheritance tax receipts jump 11% even before Autumn Budget overhaulOfficial figures show inheritance tax receipts are rising even before the chancellor’s changes to reliefs
-
Banks pass stress testFeatures Britain’s seven biggest lenders have passed the second round of annual stress tests – but how resilient are the tests?
-
RBS starts its return to the private sectorNews The government began to return Royal Bank of Scotland to the private sector this week, seven years after saving it from collapse.
-
Legal troubles haunt banksNews HSBC has put money aside for legal expenses, while US prosecutors have reopened investigations into Standard Chartered.
-
What's wrong with Britain's banks?Cover Story British banks are still in the post-crisis recovery position. Look at what they do, not what they say, to see which ones are progressing, says James Ferguson.
-
RBS shares slide – but this isn’t a buying opportunityFeatures After announcing an £8bn loss, RBS's share price has taken a beating. However, as Ed Bowsher explains, that doesn’t mean the bank is worth buying.
