Four years after it was first proposed, US regulators have approved the Volcker Rule.
Named after the former chairman of the US Federal Reserve, this bans banks from making bets with their own money proprietary (prop) trading in order to reduce the likelihood of Wall Street's big players engaging in overly risky activity and requiring a bail-out.
What the commentators said
Still, as the FT pointed out, implicit state guarantees for big banks and lax regulation of prop trading helped fuel the credit bubble. But turning the Volcker rule into a workable law has proved "fiendishly difficult". A key issue is deciding what constitutes prop trading and what is market making, whereby a bank buys and sells assets for clients.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
For instance, said The Daily Telegraph, the process of making a market, or establishing a price, for a client will often involve the firm holding a certain amount of the product on its own balance sheet.
"How do you know whether a certain amount of overstocking might amount to no more than an optimistic view on trading volumes rather than an outright bet on... the product's price?
Practical difficulties notwithstanding, said David Reilly in The Wall Street Journal, the Volcker rule will be worthwhile if it marks a first step towards stopping banks having their fingers in so many pies that they become too big to fail.
Why, for instance, are they allowed to run their own fund management arms, when implicit government backing gives them an advantage over stand-alone firms and encourages risk taking? And shouldn't other companies, rather than banks, handle market making? We must get "banks back to being banks".
-
Which UK region has the most in savings? Average savings by areaThe amount people have in their savings differs from region to region in the UK. How does your nest egg compare to those living nearby?
-
Doug and Mary Perkins: Specsavers’ clear-sighted foundersHelped by the deregulation of the sector in the 1980s and brilliant advertising, Mary Perkins and her husband Doug have taken Specsavers to the top of the optometry market
