Carney’s blind bet
The Bank of England governor placed his bets on the one number nobody can be sure of, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
Not many people grasp just how bad the UK's recession has been. It hasn't felt quite as bad as it should, thanks to the ultra-low interest rates that have kept the wolves from many doors, and a bout of inflation that temporarily disguised falling real wages.
But it is worth remembering that the Great Depression ran for 42 months, while we have been mired in our own misery for 60 months.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
When Bank of England governor Mark Carney introduced the idea of forward guidance' back in August, he said he would start looking at raising interest rates when unemployment hit 7%, which he expected to happen in 2016.
We weren't convinced: we said we expected unemployment to fall and hence rates to rise rather faster than the Bank did.
So far that's been a good call. Unemployment in the UK is now down to 7.6% of the economically active population or just 7.1% if you look at the one-month rather than the rolling three-month numbers. Carney now thinks we will hit 7% 18 months earlier than he had previously thought.
But while, on the face of it, this might suggest you should plan for the first rate rise (fix that mortgage!), remember that none of this is set in stone. That's largely because we don't really understand the UK unemployment numbers.
Unemployment rose post-crisis but by nowhere near as much as the Bank expected. But output and productivity (a measure of how efficient the work force is) fell rather more than expected.
We also know that huge numbers of people two million are underemployed. They are in jobs, but aren't doing the hours they want to do. So you could say that what really matters is not employment itself, but two other numbers under-employment and productivity.
If both improve, then unemployment can only come down slowly if the staff already on your payroll work better and for longer, you don't need to hire to raise output. If they don't, employment will rise as demand does.
So Carney has made more of a bet on productivity than anything else. And if there is one number in the UK economy no one can quite get to grips with, it is productivity. Why did it fall? What might make it go up? We all have ideas, some more polite than others. But no one really knows.
We said from the start that forward guidance seemed a pretty dim-witted policy. Based as it is on a number no one understands, we still think it is. It tells us nothing about when rates will actually rise it may be 2014, but if it is, the bare unemployment numbers won't be the trigger.
I have met Mr Carney since I last wrote about forward guidance. He seemed nice. But we instantly found something to disagree on (the impact of changes to executive compensation on economic growth, in this case). That at least is, I think, a trend we can be sure will continue.
-
‘Sandwich generation’ carers losing £6,000 a year to support elderly relativesMiddle-aged adults are often caught between caring for children or grandchildren and their elderly parents, leaving them taking time out of the workforce and facing a huge hit to wages while they are still trying to save for retirement. We look at the true cost of caring.
-
Ground rents to be capped at £250 a year – what does it mean for you?The government has published draft legislation which would see ground rents capped at £250 per year for leaseholders. We examine what it means for homeowners and the housing market.
-
Inflation may be slipping but there is still plenty of misery aheadEditor's letter Inflation may be a little lower than last month as the prices of petrol and diesel fall back, but it remains structural and long-term, says Merryn Somerset Webb. And there are no painless solutions.
-
Beat the cost of living crisis – go on holidayEditor's letter As inflation rages, energy bills soar and the pound tanks, what’s a good way to save money this winter? Go on holiday, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
-
How to tackle rising inflation and falling stockmarketsEditor's letter Inflation is rising around the world. Even though inflation is widely expected to return to around 3.5% next year, it is still wreaking havoc. Merryn Somerset-Webb explains what to do about it.
-
How capitalism has been undermined by poor governanceEditor's letter Capitalism’s “ruthless efficiency” has been undermined by poor governance, a lack of competition and central banks’ over-enthusiastic money printing, says Andrew Van Sickle.
-
Don't be scared by economic forecastingEditor's letter The Bank of England warned last week the UK will tip into recession this year. But predictions about stockmarkets, earnings or macroeconomic trends can be safely ignored, says Andrew Van Sickle.
-
The biggest change in the last 17 years – the death of the “Greenspan put”Editor's letter Since I joined MoneyWeek 17 years ago, says John Stepek, we’ve seen a global financial crisis, a eurozone sovereign debt crisis , several Chinese growth scares, a global pandemic, and a land war in Europe. But the biggest change is the death of the “Greenspan put”.
-
The wolf returns to the eurozone’s doorEditor's letter The eurozone’s intrinsic flaws have been exposed again as investors’ fears about Italy’s ability to pay its debt sends bond yields soaring.
-
Things won't just return to normal – that's not how inflation worksEditor's letter You might think that, if inflation is indeed “transitory”, we just need to wait and everything will return to “normal”. But this is a grave misunderstanding of how inflation works, says John Stepek.
